2019 Supreme(Raj) 1452
IN THE HIGH COURT OF RAJASTHAN AT JAIPUR BENCH
Prakash Gupta, J.
Deepak Singh - Appellant
Versus
Radhey Shyam - Respondent
Civil First Appeal No. 95 of 2019
Decided On : 19-08-2019
Important Points
Subject
Property Law - PARTITION
Headnote
HINDU SUCCESSION ACT, 1956 - SECTION 6, 8, 19 - PARTITION - SUIT FOR - MAINTAINABILITY - GRANDFATHER OF PLAINTIFF DIED INTESTATE LEAVING BEHIND DAUGHTERS - PROPERTY DEVOLVES ACCORDING TO SECTION 8 OF THE ACT AND NOT SECTION 6 - PLAINTIFF CANNOT MAINTAIN SUIT FOR PARTITION DURING LIFETIME OF HIS FATHER.
Fact of the Case:
Plaintiff filed a suit for partition, declaration, and permanent injunction against the defendants. The trial court framed a preliminary issue as to whether the plaintiff had the legal right to file the suit, considering that his father was alive and the property was ancestral. The trial court decided the issue in favor of the defendants and dismissed the suit.
Finding of the Court:
The High Court held that the plaintiff's grandfather died intestate leaving behind daughters, and therefore, the disputed property would devolve according to the provisions of Section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, and not Section 6. The court further held that the plaintiff could not maintain a suit for partition during the lifetime of his father.
Issues: Whether the plaintiff had the legal right to file the suit for partition during the lifetime of his father, considering that the property was ancestral and his grandfather died intestate leaving behind daughters.
Ratio Decidendi: The court relied on the provisions of Sections 6, 8, and 19 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, and the judgments of the Supreme Court in Uttam Versus Saubhag Singh and others, and Prakash and others Versus Phulavati and others, to hold that the plaintiff could not maintain the suit for partition during the lifetime of his father.
Final Decision: The High Court dismissed the plaintiff's appeal.
Prabhudh Vidyarthi, Advocate, Alok Chaturvedi, Advocate
JUDGMENT
Prakash Gupta, J. - This civil first appeal has been filed against the judgment dated 26.09.2018 passed by Additional District Judge No.2, Kota whereby the suit filed by the appellant-plaintiff (hereinafter referred to as 'the plaintiff') for partition, declaration and permanent injunction has been dismissed.
2. Facts of the case are that the plaintiff filed a suit for partition, declaration and permanent injunction against the respondents-defendants (hereinafter referred to as 'the defendants'). During the pendency of the suit, on 11.1.2018 following issue was framed by the trial Court as a preliminary issue:-
3. Burden to prove the said issue was put on the defendants.
4. On the aforesaid issue, it was submitted by the defendants before the Trial Court that the plaintiff's father was impleaded as defendant No.2 in the suit and after the death of plaintiff's grandfather late Jasraj Singh, his daughters were surviving. In this view of the matter, provisions of Section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 (hereinafter referred to as 'the Act of 1956') were applicable in the instant case and therefore, the property as mentioned in the plaint could not be said to be the joint Hindu family property. Thus, the plaintiff's father Mukut Singh being alive, the plaintiff has no legal right to file the suit and the suit filed by him is barred by law.
5. The learned trial Court vide its judgment dated 26.09.2018 decided the aforesaid preliminary issue in favour of the defendants and on that basis, dismissed the suit filed by the plaintiff as not maintainable.
6. Heard learned counsel for the plaintiff and carefully perused the material available on record.
7. Learned counsel for the plaintiff submitted that Late Nand Singh was the great grandfather of plaintiff and Late Smt. Pushpkanwar Bai was the great grandmother of the plaintiff. Smt. Pushpakanwar Bai was the absolute owner of the suit property as mentioned in para 2 of the plaint, whereas the property mentioned in para 4, which is agricultural land, originally belonged to late Shri Nand Singh and after his death, the property was recorded in the name of late Jasraj Singh in the revenue records and thus all the suit properties were ancestral properties as all the aforesaid three persons died intestate. The plaintiff in the suit not only prayed for partition of the suit properties but also prayed for declaration to the effect that the Will dated 4.10.1994 purportedly executed by late Jasraj Singh be declared null and void qua the plaintiff. He has further submitted that once the plaintiff specifically prayed for declaration and questioned the execution of purported Will dated 4.10.2014, the trial court ought to have framed the relevant issue in this regard on the basis of rival submissions of the parties but the learned trial court acted in a very narrow compass and framed only one issue with regard to legal right of the plaintiff to file the suit. Learned counsel also submitted that the court below while deciding the preliminary issue failed to appreciate that the plaintiff instituted the suit for partition in respect of suit properties, declaration in respect of alleged Will dated 4.10.1994, whereas Late Jasraj Singh expired on 6.10.1994 and thus the alleged Will was executed just 2 days back i.e. on 4.10.1994. Late Jasraj expired after the birth of plaintiff and thus as per provisions of Section 6 of the Act of 1956, the plaintiff immediately on his birth, acquired and inherited all successive rights in the ancestral suit property being a coparcener. He has further submitted that the grandson can maintain the suit for partition or any other nature during life time of his father in respect of ancestral land, if his birth was prior to the death of his grand father and his rights are governed by the provisions of Section 6 of the Act of 1956 and not by the provisions of Section 8 of the Act of 1956. He has further submitted that the plaintiff did not claim any right in respect of any