IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH AT SHIMLA
Sureshwar Thakur, Chander Bhusan Barowalia, JJ.
Amit Nayyer - Appellants
Vs.
State of HP and Ors. - Respondent
CWPOA No. 7048 of 2019
Decided On : 22-02-2021
Issuance of an advertisement notice - Provisional degree certificate - Requisite qualification – Posts of Assistant Professor - Petitioner and co-respondent No. 3 both applied for afore advertised post – However writ petitioner was not selected rather co-respondent No. 3 became selected and also became appointed - Consequently through extant writ petition a challenge is made by writ petitioner to selection and appointment of co-respondent No. 3 against afore-advertised post - Essential qualification(s) as prescribed in Annexure A-1 for theirs becoming imperatively possessed by aspirants concerned hence for theirs becoming awarded pro rata marks in consonance therewith is/are qua theirs possessing BE/B.Tech. and ME/M.Tech. in relevant branch of Engineering with first class or equivalent either in BE/B.Tech. or ME/M.Tech - A reading of Annexure A-1 discloses that last date for submission of applications as appertaining to afore advertised posts becoming recited - Consequently possession(s) if any of afore essential qualification(s) by aspirants concerned for theirs being awarded pro rata marks in consonance therewith were enjoined to be possessed or were enjoined to be submitted before recruiting agency concerned hence on – Held, Acquisition of a diploma later may qualify him later not this year - Otherwise dateline makes no sense - So short question is when can a candidate claim to have got a diploma - When he has done all that he has to do and result of it is officially made known by concerned authority - An examinee for a degree or diploma must complete his examination-written oral or practical-before he can tell the selection committee or court that he has done his part - Even this is not enough - If all goes well after that he cannot be credited with title to degree if the results are announced only after last date for applications but before selection - Second condition precedent must also be fulfilled official communication of result before the selection and its being brought to ken of committee in an authentic manner - May be examination is cancelled or marks of candidates are with-held - He acquires degree or diploma only when results are officially made known - Until then his qualification is inchoate - Writ Petition and same is dismissed.
JUDGMENT :
Sureshwar Thakur, J.
(Through Video Conferencing)
1. Through an advertisement embodied in Annexure A-1, the respondents concerned, advertised various posts, for being filled up, on a contractual basis. However, vis-a-vis the apposite, to the extant writ petition, five posts, of Assistant Professor (Computer Engineering), hence on a contractual basis, also became through Annexure A-1, hence, advertised for being filled up. The petitioner and co-respondent No. 3, both, applied for the afore advertised post. However, the writ petitioner was not selected, rather co-respondent No. 3 became selected, and, also became appointed. Consequently, through the extant writ petition, a challenge is made by the writ petitioner, to, the selection and appointment of co-respondent No. 3 against the afore-advertised post. The essential qualification(s), as prescribed in Annexure A-1, for theirs becoming imperatively possessed by the aspirants concerned, hence, for theirs becoming awarded pro rata marks, in consonance therewith, is/are, qua theirs possessing BE/B.Tech. and ME/M.Tech. in the relevant branch of Engineering with first class or equivalent either in BE/B.Tech. or ME/M.Tech.
2. A reading of Annexure A-1, discloses that the last date, for submission of applications, as, appertaining to the afore advertised posts becoming recited therein, to be 20.8.2014. Consequently, the possession(s), if any, of the afore essential qualification(s), by the aspirants concerned, for theirs being awarded pro rata marks in consonance therewith, were enjoined to be possessed or were enjoined to be submitted, before the recruiting agency concerned, hence on or before 20.8.2014, (i) or in other words, after expiry of the afore set forth deadline, in Annexure A-1, upon, the aspirants concerned acquiring the afore apposite essential qualification(s), thereupon, they became debarred to canvass, for any entitlement, for pro rata marks in consonance therewith, becoming awarded to them.
3. The learned counsel representing the writ petitioner, contends with much vigor, before this Court that since co-respondent No. 3, as, become(s) unfolded by Annexure R3-C, rather, became awarded a provisional degree certificate, personifying qua his successfully qualifying the degree, of, Master of Technology in Computer Science & Engineering, from Bahara University (i) and also, when it became issued on 26.8.2014, (ii) thereupon when obviously its issuance emanated after expiry of the afore set-forth deadline in Annexure Al, inasmuch as 20.8.2014, (iii) thereupon the awarding of pro rata marks in consonance therewith to co-respondent No. 3, was grossly illegal and unmeritworthy, and obviously, hence his selection and appointment, to the apposite advertised post, becomes amenable for being quashed and set-aside. The afore made submissions made, before this Court, by the learned counsel appearing for the writ petitioner, does, hold immense weight, and legal vigor, as it becomes completely succored, by a verdict made by the Hon'ble Apex Court in Rakesh Kumar Sharma v. State (NCT of Delhi) and Ors, (a/w connected matter) (2013) 11 SCC 58, apposite para 11 whereof stands extracted hereinafter:-
4. Thereins, a, trite principle of law becomes cast qua the selection process or recruitment process, hence commencing from the date of the applications becoming invited through issuance of an advertisement notice, and the eligibilities of the aspirants concerned, becoming tested, on the anchor vis-a-vis, on the deadline/timeline, hence, prescribed for the relevant purpose, in the apposite advertisement notice, rather thereat, each of the aspirant(s) concerned, satiating the th
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.