2023 Supreme(J&K) 98
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JAMMU AND KASHMIR AND LADAKH AT SRINAGAR
Sanjay Dhar, J.
Mohd. Abdullah Bhat – Petitioner
Versus
Nazir Ahmad Bhat & Ors. – Respondents
CM(M) No. 96 of 2022
Decided On : 31-03-2023
Important Points
Subject
Civil Law - Property Dispute
Act Referred
CONSTITUTION OF INDIA : Art.227
Jammu and Kashmir Mediation and Conciliation Rules : R.20
Headnote
Amendment of Plaint - Property Dispute - J&K Mediation and Conciliation Rules 2019 - [Order VI Rule 18 of CPC, J&K Mediation and Conciliation Rules 2019]
Fact of the Case:
The petitioner filed a suit for permanent injunction against the respondents seeking to restrain them from infringing upon his property rights. The petitioner sought to amend the plaint to incorporate subsequent events of construction and a compromise between the parties.
Finding of the Court:
The court upheld the trial court's decision to allow the amendment regarding construction but set aside the decision to close the right of the petitioner to file the amended plaint, citing that the petitioner was justified in awaiting the decision of the petition challenging the trial court's order before filing the amended plaint.
Issues: The issues involved the petitioner's request to amend the plaint to include a compromise and subsequent construction events, and the trial court's decision to close the right of the petitioner to file the amended plaint.
Ratio Decidendi: The court held that the alleged compromise, not signed by the defendants, and the events during mediation proceedings were confidential and could not be used in court proceedings. Additionally, the court cited that the period for filing an amended plaint is not mandatory and the trial court should have awaited the decision of the petition challenging its order before closing the right of the petitioner to file the amended plaint.
Final Decision: The petition challenging the trial court's order allowing the amendment was dismissed, and the order was upheld. The petition challenging the trial court's decision to close the right of the petitioner to file the amended plaint was allowed, and the said order was set aside. The petitioner was directed to file the amended plaint by the next date of hearing before the trial court.
Advocate Appeared:
For the Petitioner: M.I. Qadiri, Avees Geelani
For the Respondent: S.N. Ratanpuri
JUDGMENT :
1. By this common order, afore titled two writ petitions under Article 227 of Constitution of India, filed by the petitioner/plaintiff, are proposed to be disposed of.
2. Vide CM(M) No. 73/2022, the petitioner/plaintiff has challenged order dated 26.03.2022, passed by the learned Sub Judge Chadoora (hereinafter referred to as 'the trial Court'), whereby application of the petitioner for amendment of the plaint has been partly declined.
3. Vide CM(M) No. 96/2022, the petitioner/plaintiff has challenged order dated 30.04.2022 passed by the learned trial Court, whereby the petitioner's right to file the amended plaint has been closed.
4. Briefly stated the facts of the case are that the petitioner/plaintiff filed a suit for permanent injunction against the respondents/defendants before the trial Court seeking a decree of permanent injunction restraining the defendants from infringing upon his rights and restraining them from raising the level of the suit property and the plinth therein over and above the level of the land and plinth of the plaintiff.
5. In the original plaint the petitioner/plaintiff has pleaded that he is owner in possession of land measuring 1 kanal 8 marlas under khasra No. 263, situated at Alamdar Colony Bugam Batapora Tehsil Chadoora and that he has constructed a residential house on the said land. It has been pleaded that the defendants have started construction of two residential houses in the land measuring 1 kanal 14 marlas under khasra No. 264 situated at Bogam Batapora Tehsil Chadoora and for this purpose they have commenced raising construction of two plinths.
6. It has been alleged that construction of two residential houses by the defendants in their property is detrimental to the rights and interests of the plaintiff, as the defendants have started to raise the level of their property by constructing the plinths of their residential houses over and above the level of land and plinth of residential house of the plaintiff. According to the petitioner/plaintiff this act of the defendants would cause damage to his property and infringe upon his rights, as it would result in percolation of rain and drain water towards the land and residential house of the plaintiff, which is located at lower level.
7. The suit has been contested by the defendants by filing their written statement. In their written statement the defendants have contended that the land of the plaintiff is not adjacent to the land of the defendants and that there is a road in between the properties of the parties.
8. During the pendency of the suit, the petitioner/plaintiff filed an application seeking amendment of the plaint. In the said application it has been submitted that during the pendency of the suit, defendant Nos. 2 to 4 have completed the construction of their plinths of their proposed houses and raised its height to more than 6 feet from the ground level, which is at par with the existing level of the road. It has been submitted that the said construction is required to be demolished, so as to restrict its height to 3 feet. On this ground it has been urged that the plaint needs to be amended.
9. Another amendment that has been sought by the petitioner/plaintiff in the said application is that during the pendency of the suit a compromise with respect to the subject matter of the suit has been entered into by the parties. According to the petitioner/plaintiff the said compromise was drafted by the counsel for the defendants and was signed by the counsel of both the parties. However, due to paucity of time the compromise could not be placed on record. It has been submitted that the dispute between the parties has been settled on 21.10.2021 but the defendants have retracted from the said compromise. Accordingly, the plaintiff has sought permission to plead these facts in the amended plaint with a relief of demolition of the construction raised by the defendants.
10. Learned trial Court vide the impugned order has partly allowed th