SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2004 Supreme(Mad) 1219

High Court of Judicature at Madras
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE M. KARPAGAVINAYAGAM
Pandurangan - Appellant
Versus
Sakkubai & Others - Respondents
S.A.No.949 of 1993
Decided On : 24 September 2004

Important Points

Claim of title by adverse possession must be proved.

Subject

Property Law - Adverse Possession

Headnote

Adverse Possession-Claim of title by adverse possession has to be proved by cogent evidence because concept of adverse possession contemplates a hostile possession-only suggestion given in the relief clause is not crucial.

Advocates Appeared: For The Appellant:Hema Sampath, Advocate. For The Respondents:R1 & R2, N.Manokaran for S.Kunalan, Advocates, R3 to R7, No appearance.

Judgment :-

The plaintiff in the suit is the appellant herein.

2. The plaintiff filed the suit against the defendants for declaration and injunction. The suit was decreed by the trial Court. However, in the appeal filed by the defendants before the first appellate Court, the appeal was allowed, setting aside the judgment and decree of the trial Court. Hence, this second appeal by the plaintiff.

3. The case of the plaintiff is as follows:

The suit property was originally settled in favour of the mother of the plaintiff. After her death, the plaintiff has been in possession and enjoyment of the suit property. When the defendants disturbed the possession, the plaintiff earlier filed the suit in O.S.No1434 of 1974 for declaration and injunction. Ultimately, that suit was dismissed, holding that the plaintiff would be entitled to 1/3 share and the defendants therein would be entitled to 2/3 share. Even after the dismissal of the earlier suit, the plaintiff has been in possession and enjoyment of the suit property, openly to the knowledge of the defendants. No steps have been taken by the defendants to recover the property. Hence, the plaintiff filed the present suit for declaration and injunction on the ground that any right which accrued to the defendants stood extinguished by efflux of time and as such, the plaintiff prescribed his title by adverse possession.

4. The case of the defendants is as follows:

The plaintiff cannot claim title to the suit property. In the earlier suit in O.S.No.1434 of 1974, similar relief was sought for against the defendants and the same was dismissed and as such, the finding given in the earlier suit that the defendants 1 and 2 would be entitled to 2/3 share, has become final, as the said decree in the earlier suit has not been appealed against. As such, the present suit is hit by the doctrine of 'res-judicata'.

5. During the course of trial, the plaintiff examined himself as P.W.1 besides three others as P.Ws.2, 3 and 4 and marked Exs.A-1 to A-38 and the second defendant examined herself as D.W.1 and third defendant examined himself as DW2, besides one another person as DW3 and marked Exs.B1 to B3.

6. The trial Court, on analysing the evidence available on record, rejected the case of the defendants and decreed the suit in favour of the plaintiff. As indicated above, the first appellate Court, while allowing the appeal, held that the suit is barred by the doctrine of "res-judicata" and consequently, the plaintiff would not be entitled to the relief sought for. Challenging the same, the second appeal has been filed by the plaintiff.

7. At the time of admission of the second appeal, by the order dated 26.8.1993, the following substantial question of law has been formulated by this Court for consideration:

"Whether the lower appellate Court was right in holding that the decision in O.S.No.1434 of 1974 operates as 'res-judicata' without appreciating the fact that the plea of adverse possession was not taken by the appellant but by the 3rd defendant in that suit?"

8. In elaboration of the above substantial question of law, learned counsel for the appellant/plaintiff would contend that even after the disposal of the earlier suit in O.S.No.1434 of 1974, the defendants did not take steps to take possession of their share in the suit property and the appellant/plaintiff's possession of the entire suit property became adverse and as such, the lower appellate Court ought to have confirmed the trial Court's judgment and decree for declaration and injunction, which was a well-considered one.

9. It is further contended by learned counsel for the appellant/plaintiff that the issues involved in the earlier suit in O.S.No.1434 of 1974 and the present suit in O.S.No.513 of 1988, are different and the causes of action also differ and therefore, the principle of 'res-judicata' will not get attracted.

10. In justification of the judgment and decree rendered by the lower appellate Court, learned counsel for the respondents 1 an































1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top