2009 Supreme(Mad) 3098
High Court of Judicature at Madras
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE M. VENUGOPAL
N. Kathirvel
Versus
N. Kalimuthu Gounder & Another
C.R.P.(N.P.D) No.2158 of 2008 & M.P. No.1 of 2008
Decided on: 11-08-2009
Important Points
Subject
Civil Law - Limitation Act
Act Referred
CONTRACT ACT : S.3
LIMITATION ACT : S.5, Art.123
Headnote
Section 5 - Limitation Act - 1993 Supp (3) Supreme Court Cases 256, 2009 (1) CTC 638, 2003-2-L.W.25, 2009-1-L.W.439 - The court discussed the application of Section 5 of the Limitation Act and cited various legal provisions and interpretations from previous cases to support its decision to dismiss the application filed under Section 5 of the Limitation Act.
Fact of the Case:
The petitioner filed a civil revision petition against the order of the trial Court, which dismissed the application filed under Section 5 of the Limitation Act, praying to condone the delay of 268 days in filing the application to set aside the exparte decree dated 03.01.2006. The petitioner claimed that the exparte decree was passed without their knowledge and that they had settled the suit property in favor of their wife. The respondent argued that the petitioner had not explained the delay and had not participated in the trial of the case.
Finding of the Court:
The court found that the petitioner's reasons for the delay were not sufficient and that the application under Section 5 of the Limitation Act lacked bonafides. The court also noted that the petitioner had not taken concrete steps to set aside the decree and had shown a laissez-faire/lackadaisical attitude.
Issues: The main issue was whether the delay in filing the application to set aside the exparte decree could be condoned under Section 5 of the Limitation Act.
Ratio Decidendi: The court held that the reasons for the delay were not sufficient and that the application lacked bonafides. The court also emphasized the importance of taking concrete steps to set aside the decree and participating in the trial proceedings.
Final Decision: The civil revision petition was dismissed, and the order passed by the trial Court in I.A. No.231 of 2007 was confirmed. The parties were directed to bear their own costs.
For the Petitioner:V.V. Sathya, M.V. Venkateseshan, Advocates.
For the Respondent:Anandha Gomathi, Advocate.
1. The revision petitioner/petitioner/first defendant has filed this civil revision petition as against the order dated 14.02.2008 in I. A. No.231 of 2007 in O.S. No.488 of 1999 passed by the Learned Principal Subordinate Judge, Coimbatore in dismissing the application filed under Section 5 of the Limitation Act, praying to condone the delay of 268 days in filing the application to set aside the exparte decree dated 03.01.2006.
2. The trial Court while passing orders in I.A. No.231 of 2007 has among other things observed that on 03.01.2006 after full trial a decree has been passed, based on an appreciation of oral and documentary evidence adduced on both sides and it transpires from records that on 20.09.2005 the revision petitioners/first defendants, Advocate has reported no instructions and hence revision petitioner/first defendant has been called absent and set exparte decree etc., and also that no explanation has been offered for each and every days delay and inasmuch a decree has been passed after full contest and trial of the case an application filed is not maintainable and ultimately dismissed the same without costs".
3. According to the learned counsel for the revision petitioner/petitioner/first defendant the order of the trial Court in dismissing the Section 5 application of the Limitation Act, is contrary to law and the same is without jurisdiction and as a matter of fact an exparte decree has been passed totally without the knowledge of the petitioner only on the basis of memo dated 20.09.2005 filed by the then counsel on record and hence the delay that has occurred is neither on account of the petitioners negligence or deliberate intention on his part and this important aspect has not been appreciated by the trial Court and the revision petitioner has come to know of the exparte decree only when he has received notice in Execution Petition No.374 of 2006 and soon filed an application and even in the written statement filed by the revision petitioner/first defendant he has stated that he has settled the suit property in favour of his wife on 15.03.1999 and that the suit has been filed in April 1999 and because of these reasons the plaintiff themselves have impleaded the wife of the revision petitioner and her purchasers as party to the suit and these aspects have not been adverted to by the trial Court in a pragmatic manner which has caused serious prejudice to the petitioner and therefore prays for allowing the civil revision petition to promote substantial cause of justice.
4. Per contra, the learned counsel for the respondent/decree holder submits that the revision petitioner has not explained each and every days delay and the petitioners learned counsel reported no instructions before the trial Court on 20.09.2005 and therefore he has been set exparte and a judgment has been passed by the trial Court after full contest by means of examining the witnesses and marking the exhibits on respective sides and that the trial Court has come to the right conclusion in not accepting the reasons ascribed for the delay and the same need not be interfered with by this Court.
5. This Court has heard the respective contentions of the learned counsel appearing for the parties and noticed the same.
6. The learned counsel for the revision petitioner cites the decision of Honble Supreme Court in Tahil Ram Issardas Sadarangani and Others Vs. Ramchand Issardas Sadarangani and Another reported in 1993 Supp (3) Supreme Court Cases 256 at page 257 wherein it is held as follows:
"It is not disputed in the present case that on March 15, 1974 when Mr. Adhia, advocate withdrew from the case, the petitioners were not present in court. There is nothing on the record to show as to whether the petitioners had the notice of the hearing of the case on that day. We are of the view, when Mr. Adhia withdrew from the case, the interests of justice required, that a fresh notice for actual date of hearing should have been sent to the parties.