SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2018 Supreme(Mad) 2205

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
T. RAVINDRAN, J.
Parasuraman & Anr. - Appellants
Vs.
Sekar & Ors. - Respondents
S.A. No. 2087 of 2004
Decided On : 06-08-2018

Important Points

The plaintiff's failure to establish a valid marriage and the nature of the suit properties as separate, not available for partition during the first defendant's lifetime, influenced the court's decision.

Subject

Civil Law - Property Law

Headnote

judgment - challenge to judgment and decree - substantial questions of law - judgment and decree of the learned appellate Judge - satisfactory proof of marriage - valid marriage - family properties - separate properties - joint family properties

Fact of the Case:

The plaintiff filed a suit for partition claiming to be the son of the first defendant and seeking half share in the suit properties. The trial Court dismissed the suit, but the first appellate Court entertained the suit. The second appeal challenged the reversal of the trial Court's judgment.

Finding of the Court:

The first appellate Court held that the plaintiff had established his legitimacy as the son of the first defendant and thus entitled to claim partition in the suit properties. However, the second appeal set aside the first appellate Court's judgment and confirmed the trial Court's decision.

Issues: Validity of marriage, entitlement to claim share in family properties, and nature of suit properties for partition.

Ratio Decidendi: The plaintiff failed to establish a valid marriage between his mother and the first defendant, and the suit properties were found to be the separate properties of the first defendant, not available for partition during his lifetime.

Final Decision: The second appeal was allowed, and the judgment and decree of the first appellate Court were set aside, confirming the trial Court's decision.

Advocates:
Advocate Appeared:
For the Appellants : Mrs. Mythili Suresh for M/s. Sarvabhauman Associates

JUDGMENT :

Challenge in this second appeal is made to the judgment and decree dated 27.02.2003, passed in A.S. No. 21/2002, on the file of the Additional District & Sessions Judge, Fast Track Court, Kallakurichi, reversing the judgment and decree dated 23.09.1998, passed in O.S. No. 958/89, on the file of the First Additional District Munsif Court, Kallakurichi.

2. The second appeal has been admitted on the following substantial questions of law:

“1. Whether in law, the judgment and decree of the learned appellate Judge reversing the judgment of the trial Court without assigning reasons is sustainable?

2. In the absence of any satisfactory proof of marriage in the manner known to law, has not the lower appellate Court committed a grave error in law in accepting and acting upon a reply notice alleged to have been issued by the second respondent which has not been proved in accordance with law?”

3. Considering the scope of the issues between the parties as regards the subject matter lying in a narrow compass, it is unnecessary to dwell into the facts of the case in detail.

4. Suffice to state that the plaintiff has laid the suit for partition contending that he is the son of the first defendant born out of the wedlock with the plaintiff's mother Jayalakshmi and further, according to the plaintiff, the first defendant developed illicit relationship with one Ponnammal and out of the same, the second defendant and the ninth defendant were born to Ponnammal and thus, according to the plaintiff, the defendants 2 and 9 are not entitled to claim any share in the suit properties as such and further, according to the plaintiff, the defendants 7 and 8 are his sisters and they had been added as a necessary parties in the event of they seeking any claim of share in the suit properties as per the amended Succession Act and alleging that the first defendant had alienated certain properties belonging to the family to the defendants 3 to 6 and contending that the suit properties are the family properties belonging to the first defendant and the plaintiff and as such, the plaintiff being entitled to half share in the suit properties, accordingly, it is the case of the plaintiff that he has been necessitated to lay the suit for partition.

5. The third defendant has filed the written statement admitting that the plaintiff is the son of the first defendant and however, according to the third defendant, his wife had purchased certain properties from the first defendant and as the said sale is effected for legal necessity and for the welfare of the first defendant's family, the sale is binding upon the plaintiff and the plaintiff is not entitled to question the same and accordingly, prayed for the dismissal of the plaintiff's suit.

6. Similarly, the sixth defendant has also filed the written statement contending that the first defendant for discharging his antecedent debts, alienated the third item of the suit properties in his favour and accordingly, the said sale is binding upon the plaintiff and hence, prayed for the dismissal of the suit.

7. The ninth defendant, through her mother, has filed the written statement contending that the plaintiff is not the son of the first defendant and that no marriage took place between the first defendant and the plaintiff's mother Jayalakshmi as claimed in the plaint and on the other hand, it is the case of the ninth defendant that the marriage had taken place only between the first defendant and her mother Ponnammal and out of the wedlock, the ninth defendant and the second defendant were born and accordingly contending that the plaintiff not being the legitimate son of the first defendant, put forth a case that the plaintiff is not entitled to lay any claim of share in the suit properties as such. Further, according to the ninth defendant, the suit properties are not the family properties belonging to the first defendant and the plaintiff as claimed in the plaint and further, it is stated that Periasamy had alienated t











1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top