2018 Supreme(P&H) 1452
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.
Maan Jain - Appellant
Versus
Suraj Parkash Jain and others - Respondents
RSA No.6253 of 2014 (O&M)
Decided On : 26-06-2018
Important Points
Ancestral Property – Once in a case of intestate succession, the property is succeeded under Section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, the same shall be individual property of the heir.
Subject
Property Law - Hindu Succession Act
Act Referred
HINDU SUCCESSION ACT : S.19, S.4, S.8, S.6
SUCCESSION ACT : S.19, S.4, S.8, S.6
Headnote
(B) Hindu Succession Act,1956, S.6 & S.8 – Ancestral Property – On the death of a common ancestor, the property was mutated in favour of seven class-I heirs – Hence, on the death of common ancestor, the property did not devolve upon the heirs under Section 6 of the Hindu Succession Act,1956 and there is no dispute about the same – Therefore, property inherited shall be individual property of the heir (Para 20)
For the Appellant : Mr. Keshav Partap Singh, Adv.
For the Respondent: Mr. Adarsh Jain, Adv.
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.
CM-14893-C-2014
Prayer in the application is for condonation of delay of 259 days in filing the appeal.
For the reasons given in the application which is supported by an affidavit, the delay is condoned and the application is allowed.
CM-14894-C-2014
Delay of 15 days in re-filing the appeal is condoned and the application is allowed.
Main Case
2. Defendant No.2-appellant is in the regular second appeal against the concurrent finding of fact arrived at by the Courts below.
3. In the considered opinion of this Court, the following substantial question of law arise for determination:-
“Whether the property received by a common ancestor of the parties to the litigation from his father under Section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 is a co-parcenary property?”
4. Fakir Chand was having three sons namely Rattan Singh, Sajjan Singh and Jawahar Singh. Fakir Chand died and mutation of inheritance was sanctioned in favour of his three sons on 10.06.1935. Rattan Singh died issueless, so share of Rattan Singh also devolved upon Sajjan Singh and Jawahar Singh in equal share. Sajjan Singh died intestate leaving behind Balwant Singh and other class I heirs including daughters. The property of Sajjan Singh was succeeded as per Section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 and the mutation was entered on 05.06.1967 which was ultimately sanctioned on 12.11.1967.
5. Dispute now is with regard to the estate of Balwant Singh who inherited the property from his father Sajjan Singh under Section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956. Balwant Singh has left behind three sons namely Suraj Parkash Jain-plaintiff No.1, Om Parkash Jain-defendant No.1 and Anil Parkash Jain-defendant No.4. It is undisputed that Balwant Singh was serving in Indian Railways and after retirement, he settled in Charkhi Dadri, District Bhiwani and started working as a Typist in the Court Complex. It is also admitted fact that Suraj Parkash Jain, the plaintiff No.1 is settled from very beginning in Bikaner (Rajasthan) whereas Om Parkash Jain, defendant No.1 son of Balwant Singh is settled in Canada for the last 20 years and Anil Parkash Jain, the third son was earlier residing in Canada, is presently residing in United States of America since 1998.
6. Balwant Singh has left behind five daughters and all the daughters are married and settled in their respective matrimonial homes outside Charkhi Dadri. Balwant Singh executed a Will dated 28.04.1997 bequeathing his property mentioned in the plaint in favour of defendant No.1 (Om Parkash Jain, son) and defendant No.2 (Maan Jain, daughter-in-law and wife of Om Parkash Jain). The plaintiff claimed that in fact defendant No.2 is not married wife of defendant No.1. Sh. Balwant Singh died on 10.06.1998 and the Will was got registered after the death of Balwant Singh on 28.08.2000 after publication of a notice in the newspaper calling for objections, if any. Originally, the suit was filed by Suraj Parkash Jain, plaintiff No.1. Subsequently, proforma defendants namely daughters of Balwant Singh got themselves transposed as plaintiffs. The Will dated 28.04.1997 was claimed to be forged and fabricated and defendant No.2 was asserted to be not related to Sh. Balwant Singh.
7. The defendant No.2-appellant contested the suit and claimed that she is legally wedded wife of defendant No.1-Om Parkash Jain and Balwant Singh, the testator whose property is in dispute used to reside with her after the death of his wife in the year 1991-1992. She claimed that the property is not a co-parcenary property. She further claimed that Om Parkash Jain was previously married to Smt. Mridula Rani but such marriage was dissolved by a decree of divorce on 01.08.1978 and marriage between defendant No.1 and 2 was solemnized on 16.08.1987 and since then, she is performing her matrimonial obligations.
8. Both the Courts below have held that the property in the hands of Balwant Singh was Hindu Mitakshra co-parcenary property and therefore, Balwant Singh