2022 Supreme(P&H) 2254
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH
Avneesh Jhingan, J.
State of Haryana – Appellant
Versus
Rajinder Parshad – Respondent
CRA-S No. 750-SB of 2005
Decided On : 15-11-2022
Subject
Criminal Law - Corruption
Act Referred
Headnote
(B) Principles regarding appeals against acquittal - Interference warranted only if judgment is perverse, unreasonable, or based on misreading of evidence - Appellate court must assess evidence and provide compelling reasons for overturning acquittal. (Paras 11.1, 11.2)
Facts of the case:
The respondent was accused of demanding bribes in exchange for releasing an electric connection, but the trial court found contradictory witness statements and determined recovery of money was not conclusive proof of guilt.
Findings of Court:
The court upheld the trial court's decision, stating no compelling reasons existed to interfere, given the evidence did not support the bribery claim.
Issues: The main issues were whether there was sufficient evidence to prove acceptance of the bribe and the standard for interference in acquittals.
Ratio Decidendi: The crux of the judgment emphasizes that mere recovery of money from a drawer accessible to many does not equate to acceptance of bribes, and reinforces the necessity of compelling evidence to overturn an acquittal.
Result: Appeal dismissed.
For the Parties : Mr. Gurmeet Singh AAG, Haryana, Mr. Jitender Nara
| Table of Content |
|---|
| 1. factual basis of corruption case (Para 1 , 2 , 3) |
| 2. defense challenges prosecution's claims (Para 4 , 9 , 10) |
| 3. discrepancies in witness testimonies noted (Para 6 , 7 , 8) |
| 4. parameters for appeal against acquittal (Para 11) |
| 5. court affirms trial court's judgment (Para 12 , 13 , 14) |
Judgment
Mr. Avneesh Jhingan, J.
The State has filed the appeal against acquittal of Rajinder Parshad (respondent) in FIR No. 15 dated 13.5.2002, under Sections 7 and 13 of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988, registered at Police Station State Vigilance Bureau, Gurgaon.
2. As per the case set up by the prosecution, complainant-Ganesh Sharma made a complaint on 13.5.2002 to the Vigilance Department. It was alleged that he visited the office of SDO-I of Electricity Department with regard to release of 20 KV electric connection for his plot situated in Kadipur Industrial Area, Gurgaon. He was asked to submit fresh test report though he had already submitted the test report. He met the respondent posted as Junior Engineer, who demanded Rs.20,000/- as illegal gratification for releasing the electric connection. He told the complainant to pay Rs.9,000/- immediately and remaining Rs.11,000/- after one or two days. Acting on the complaint, raiding team was constituted. PW2- Naib Tehsildar Man Mohan was appointed for the purpose. PW7-Aman Kumar, Head Constable was the shadow witness. Eighteen currency notes of Rs.500/- each were laced with Phenolphthalein Powder and initialled. The shadow witness was directed to give signal to the raiding party on acceptance of the illegal gratification. On receiving the signal, the raiding party recovered the tainted currency from the drawer of the table of the respondent. One receipt No. 16, book No. 2503 dated 3.3.2002 pertaining to Roop Chand was also seized. On the said receipt book, the tainted currency was put. On washing the receipt with Sodium Carbonate solution, the colour turned pink.
3. The prosecution to prove its case examined nine witnesses.
4. The respondent in his statement under Section 313 Cr.P.C. pleaded false implication and stated that the SDO had marked the application of the complainant to him and he had submitted his report raising objections. It was further stated that he was lifted from his office and later was implicated in the false case.
5. In his defence, the respondent examined four witnesses.
6. It was considered by trial Court that the laced currency was recovered from the drawer of the table of the respondent. He had not touched the tainted money. PW1-Ganesh Sharma deposed that hands of the respondent were also washed, whereas the statements of PW2-Man Mohan Naib Tehsildar, PW7-Aman Kumar (shadow witness) and PW9-Dhan Singh DSP (Investigating Officer) were to the contrary. DW4-Daljit Singh, SDO, Electricity Department deposed that the drawer of the table from which the laced currency notes were recovered was accessible to everyone. Further that the complainant had not approached DW4 (SDO) with a complaint of demand of illegal gratification made by the respondent. It was also noted that statements of PW1 and PW7 that the complainant had put the money in the drawer of the table of the respondent on his asking was an improvement from the previous statements (Ex. DA and Ex. DF). Reliance was placed by the trial court on the decision of the Supreme Court that recovery of the tainted currency in itself does not prove the acceptance of illegal gratification.
7. The trial court also considered the discrepancies in the testimonies of the prosecution witnesses. PW1-complainant stated that tainted money was lifted from the drawer of the table of the respondent by Naib Tehsildar. To the same effect was the statement of PW2-Naib Tehsildar but the shadow witness deposed that the laced currency was taken out by DSP-Dhan Singh from the drawer. The complainant stated that the raiding party reached the office of Complaint Centre at 3.00 pm and stayed there for fifteen minutes. His si