SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2007 Supreme(All) 2877

[2008(3) ADJ 165]
ALLAHABAD HIGH COURT
BEFORE : SUDHIR AGARWAL, J.
DHIRENDRA SINGH ...........Petitioner
Versus
COLLECTOR, KANPUR DEHAT AND OTHERS ....Respondents
(Civil Misc. Writ Petition No. 39528 of 2006, decided on 29th November, 2007)

Subject

Employment Law - Disciplinary Action

Act Referred

UTTAR PRADESH GOVERNMENT SERVANTS DISCIPLINE AND APPEAL RULES : .

Headnote

(A) Suspension—Disciplinary proceedings—On ground of misconduct—Allegations that petitioner, inspite of directions of higher authorities, could not make recovery up to target, prescribed by authorities concerned—And did not take much interest in enhancing amount of recovery—And that he was guilty of poor recovery—And that he was a poor and inefficient official—Held, in absence of anything more, reflecting on conduct of petitioner, it cannot be said that he was guilty of any misconduct, warranting disciplinary proceeding—Hence, ipso facto, it would not amount to “misconduct”, warranting punishment under U.P. Government Servant (Discipline and Appeal) Rules, 1999—Hence, impugned order of suspension set aside—Respondents directed to reinstate petitioner with all consequential benefits—However, open to respondents to take such action against him, as permissible under law, in respect of such aspect of matter. [U.P. Government Servants (Discipline and Appeal) Rules, 1999—Preamble]. [Paras 14 to 17]

       (B) Words and phrases—Word “misconduct”—Meaning and interpretation of. [Paras 7, 8, 9 and 10]

       

Advocates:
Counsel :
R.C. Singh for the Petitioner; S.C. for the Respondents.

JUDGMENT

Honble Sudhir Agarwal, J.—Heard Sri R.C. Singh, learned Counsel for the petitioner and learned Standing Counsel for the respondents.

2. Despite time having been granted to the respondents, no counter affidavit has been filed till date. However, learned Counsel for the petitioner submitted that he is raising a legal issue that the impugned order of suspension dated 7.6.2006 and the charge-sheet cannot be sustained under law, inasmuch as assuming the charges mentioned in the charge-sheet to be true they do not constitute misconduct and, therefore, no disciplinary inquiry can be conducted against the petitioner. Learned Standing Counsel, in view of the nature of the arguments advanced by learned Counsel for the petitioner, stated that the writ petition may be heard on merits and he does not propose to file any counter affidavit. Therefore, with the consent of learned Counsel for the parties, under the Rules of the Court, this matter has been heard and is being decided finally.

3. Learned Counsel for the petitioner referring to the impugned order of suspension and the charge-sheet pointed out that the only allegation levelled against the petitioner is that he did not take interest in work as a result whereof the recovery of Government Revenue is not up to the target and he has failed to take effective steps to increase the same. He contended that the allegations, even if treated to be correct, at the best shows inefficiency on the part of the petitioner and do not constitute misconduct. Misconduct is something else than inefficiency or mere error of judgment on the part of the employee and, therefore, the petitioner cannot be suspended on the basis of the allegations mentioned in the impugned order of suspension.

4. Learned Standing Counsel, on the contrary, contended that the petitioner was working as a Collection Amin and his principal duty was to collect the Government Revenue and for the said purpose he had to take all possible steps to recover Government Revenue at least up to the target fixed by the authorities concerned. Since the petitioner has failed in discharge of his duties, this amounts to dereliction on duty and for the said purpose the inquiry can be conducted under U.P. Government Servant (Discipline and Appeal) Rules, 1999 (hereinafter referred to as the "1999 Rules").

5. It would be appropriate to reproduce the allegations on the basis of which the petitioner was placed under suspension and also the charges No. 1 and 2 contained in the charge-sheet to find out whether the allegations contained therein constitute a misconduct or not :

Suspension Order

^^uk;c rglhynkj] rglhynkj rFkk miftykf/kdkjh] jlwykckn dh vk[;k ,oa laLrqfr ds vk/kkj ij Jh /khjsUnz flag] laxzg vehu] rglhy jlwykckn dks eq[; rFkk fofo/k ns;ksa dh ekax rFkk ekud ds lkis{k vR;Ur fud`"V Js.kh dh olwyh fd;s tkus] olwyh c<+k;s tkus gsrq ckj&ckj fn;s x;s vknskksa@funsZkksa ds ckn Hkh dksbZ lq/kkj u ykus ds ifjis{; esa buds fo:) vuqkklfud dk;Zokgh izLrkfor gS] ,rn~}kjk rRdky izHkko ls fuyfEcr fd;k tkrk gSA**

Charge-sheet

^^vkjksi la0 &1 ;g fd vki rglhy jlwykckn ds {ks= usoknk nsojk; esa laxzg vehu ds in ij dk;Zjr gSaA vki }kjk 1413 joh esa fnukad 16-4-2006 ls 22-6-2006 rd Hkw jktLo dh ekax :0 6509-00 rFkk flapkbZ ns; dh ekax 2]18]480-00 dqy eq[; ns; dh ekax 2]24]982-00 :i;k ds lkis{k :0 29]758-00 ,oa fofo/k ns; dh ekax :0 2]10]840-00 ds lkis{k ek= :0 80]056-00 dh olwyh dh x;h gSA bl izdkj dqy ekax 4]35]822-00 ds lkis{k dqy :0 1]09]814-00 dh olwyh dh x;h gSA tcfd 2 ekg ls vf/kd ds le; esa fu/kkZfjr ekud ,d yk[k izfr ekg ds lkis{k de ls de 2-00 yk[k dh olwyh fd;k tkuk vkisf{kr FkkA ckj&ckj fyf[kr rFkk ekSf[kd :i ls fn;s x;s funsZkksa ds ckn Hkh vki }kjk olwyh c<+k;s tkus esa dksbZ :fp ugha yh x;hA vr% ekax rFkk ekud ds lkis{k fud`"V Js.kh dh olwyh fd;s tkus ds nks"kh gSaA

vkjksi la0&2 ;g fd uk;c rglhynkj }kjk fnukad 24-5-2006 dks olwyh c<+kus gsrq funsZk fn;s x;sA rglhynkj }kjk fnukad 15-5-2006 dks eq[; ,oa fofo/k ns; dh olwyh [kjkc gksus ds dkj.k





























1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top