SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2016 Supreme(All) 3228

ALLAHABAD HIGH COURT
Sunita Agarwal, J.
Kiran Singh - Appellant
Versus
State of U.P. & Others - Respondent
First Appeal No. 585 of 2005 Connected with First Appeal No. 53 of 2008, 56/2008, 54/2008, 620/2008, 62/2009
Decided On : 13-05-2016

Act Referred

LAND ACQUISITION ACT : S.23

Headnote

LAND ACQUISITION - COMPENSATION - ASSESSMENT - SALE DEEDS - SMALL AREA - REJECTION - JUSTIFICATION - LARGENESS OF AREA - DEDUCTION - DEVELOPMENT COST - INTEGRATED PLAN - ABSENCE - SOLATIUM - INTEREST.

Fact of the Case:

Land of 10 villages for a total area of 260-06-17 was acquired for the construction of Hapur By-pass vide notification dated 21.5.1991 issued under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act. Section 6 notification was issued on 11.10.1991. The possession of the land was taken on 2.1.93 and 27.2.1993. The Special Land Acquisition Officer declared the award on 6.6.1996.

Finding of the Court:

The Reference Court has grossly erred in making the circle rate fixed by the Collector the basis for determination of market value more so ignoring the fact that the exemplar sale deed of the nearest plot, Paper No. 18-Ga, which was executed approximately 1½ years prior to the date of issuance of notification, was available.

Issues: Whether the Reference Court erred in rejecting the sale deeds filed by the appellants on the ground that they were of a small area? Whether the Reference Court erred in making the circle rate fixed by the Collector the basis for determination of market value? Whether the appellants are entitled to compensation @ Rs. 25/- per sq. yard towards market value of the lands in Appeals?

Ratio Decidendi: The prices fetched for smaller plots cannot form safe basis for valuation of large tracts of lands as they are not comparable properties. The former reflect the retail prices of the land and later the whole sale prices. This principle requires that prices fetched for small developed plots cannot directly be adopted in valuing large extends, however, there is no absolute bar to consider exemplars and small plot provided adequate discount is given in this behalf. In an appropriate case, specially where other relevant or material evidence is not available, such exemplar can be considered after making adequate discount.

Final Decision: The appellants are thus held entitled to compensation @ Rs. 25/- per sq. yard towards market value of the lands in Appeals. Apart from this, they are held entitled to: - (a) Additional compensation @ 12% per annum from the date of notification i.e. 22.7.1991 till the date of possession which is 27.2.1993 in the instant cases. (b) 30% Solatium on the enhanced compensation at the abovementioned rate as per Section 23(2) of the Act. (c) 9% interest for a period of one year from the date of possession i.e. 27.2.1993 and 15% interest after one year i.e. 27.2.1994 till the date of actual payment on the enhanced compensation. (d) While making calculation, the compensation already deposited or paid by the land Acquisition Officer shall be adjusted.

Advocates Appeared:
For the Appellant :- Madan Mohan,Manish Goyal,Prateek Tyagi
For the Respondent:- S.C.

JUDGMENT

Mrs. Sunita Agarwal,J.

Heard Sri Manish Goyal and Sri Prateek Tyagi, learned counsels for the appellant and Sri Siddhartha Singh Srinet, learned Standing Counsel.

2. These appeals under Section 54 of the Land Acquisition Act have been filed against the common judgment and award dated 27.5.2002 passed by the Additional District & Sessions Judge, Hapur, Ghaziabad in Land Acquisition Reference No. 479 of 1997 (Kiran Singh vs. State of U.P. and others) connected with 9 other references. Land of 10 villages for a total area of 260-06-17 was acquired for the construction of Hapur By-pass vide notification dated 21.5.1991 issued under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act. Section 6 notification was issued on 11.10.1991. The possession of the land was taken on 2.1.993 and 27.2.1993. The Special Land Acquisition Officer declared the award on 6.6.1996. As per the list appended to the award containing the name of villages, market rate awarded, total compensation of the lands of village Rampur, wherein the land under this appeal exists was for total area of 31-1-18, which was acquired.

3. In all the references of one village, common evidence was led and common questions of law were argued. All the references were answered by the common judgment and award on 27.5.2002.

4. The grounds taken by the appellants to challenge the award are that the Reference Court has grossly under valued the land in assessing its market value at the circle rate fixed by the Collector and coming to the conclusion that the award of the Special Land Acquisition Officer is perfectly justified. The references have been rejected ignoring the factors which are required to be taken into consideration for assessment of just and fair market value of the land. The lands in question come under the Regulated Area of City Board, Hapur declared as such vide notification dated 27.5.1993 and are lands of high building potential value. At the time of acquisition, the lands were well-irrigated lands having tube-well and other facilities. All the lands under reference were highly fertile lands producing rotational crops of vegetables in all four faslis. There existed fruit trees and woods over the lands. The location as per the village map is prime location as one side of the lands is abutting Nagar Palika Hapur Road. At the north, it opens on the By-pass road and the remaining boundaries are abutting villages Sabri and Imroti.

5. The exemplar sale deed chosen by the Special Land Acquisition Officer is of a barren land lying near a Bone Mill approximately at a distance of one km. from the acquired lands. The fertility of the land of the exemplar sale deed was not comparable to the lands under acquisition. It was full of phosphorus and was not suitable for agricultural purposes whereas the lands under the appeals were fertile lands having all facilities of irrigation. The exemplar sale deed of the nearest plot filed by the appellants was rejected by the Reference Court solely on the ground that it was a sale deed of small area. The sale deed dated 12.1.1990 Paper No. 18GA is of 2 Biswas of two plots namely 443 (4 biswa) and 446 (8 biswa) in Khata No. 202. On behalf of the State the plea is that such a small area could not have been sold for agricultural purposes rather it could only be said to have been executed for the construction of Abadi and, therefore, was not comparable.

6. The factors relevant for consideration of the exemplar sale deed that it should be nearest to the acquired lands in time and distance have totally been ignored. The appellants had also proved the execution of the sale deed by producing vendee in witness box.

7. The Reference Court has grossly erred in making the circle rate fixed by the Collector the basis for determination of market value more so ignoring the fact that the exemplar sale deed of the nearest plot, Paper No. 18-Ga, which was exe
























































































































1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top