2021 Supreme(All) 1743
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ALLAHABAD
Salil Kumar Rai, J.
Noor Ahmad @ Chand – Petitioner
Versus
Board Of Revenue And Others – Respondents
WRIT - B No. - 61837 of 2012
Decided On : 08-09-2021
Subject
Property Law - Succession Rights
Act Referred
Headnote
(B) Mutation Procedures - Recall of orders related to mutation must adhere to legal principles, and maintain the integrity of earlier orders pending valid challenges. (Paras 5, 6)
Facts of the case:
The petitioner claimed rights to land through a Will after the murder of Mehtab Ahmad, whose father and other relatives contested the validity of that Will; however, no objections were raised by the father during his lifetime.
Findings of Court:
The orders by the revisional courts were found to be unsupported by proper legal reasoning and thus quashed by the High Court.
Issues: The court addressed whether the Will was valid and the process through which revisions and recalls were sought by relatives of the deceased.
Ratio Decidendi: The High Court ruled that the rights to the land should devolve according to statutory preferences, emphasizing that the legality of a Will must be determined in appropriate legal proceedings, distinct from mutation applications.
Result: Writ petition allowed.
Advocate Appeared:
For the Petitioner: Ramesh Kumar Shukla
For the Respondent: C.S.C., Arvind Kumar Kanaujia, D.V. Jaiswal, Harsh Vikram, Jitendra Singh, M.A.Hasan, Rohit Nandan Pandey, Sanjeev Kumar Pandey, Shailendra Singh
| Table of Content |
|---|
| 1. facts of the case regarding mehtab ahmad's tenure. (Para 2) |
| 2. succession rights under the act, 1950. (Para 3 , 4) |
| 3. acquiescence by hazi ameer ahmad. (Para 5) |
| 4. legality of recall actions based on the will. (Para 6 , 7) |
| 5. final order quashing previous decisions. (Para 8 , 9) |
JUDGMENT :
Salil Kumar Rai, J.
1. Heard Shri Ramesh Kumar Shukla, counsel for the petitioner and Shri Sanjeev Kumar Pandey, Advocate, representing respondent Nos. 3 to 5.
2. The facts of the case are that one Mehtab Ahmad @ Afzal Ahmad was admittedly the tenure holder of Plot No. 3 (area 1.306 hectares), Plot No. 15 (area 0.517 hectares) and Plot No. 111 (area 0.549 hectares). Mehtab Ahmad was murdered and died on 9.8.1984. Mehtab Ahmad was survived by his father Hazi Ameer Ahmad, his mother and his brothers. The petitioner, respondent Nos. 3 to 5 and one Zameer Ahmad @ Abrar Ahmad are brothers of the deceased Mehtab Ahmad. After the death of Mehtab Ahmad, the petitioner got his name mutated in the revenue records relating to the disputed plots on the basis of a Will allegedly executed by Mehtab Ahmad. Hazi Ameer Ahmad, i.e., the father of Mehtab Ahmad died on 7.2.2003. In 2007, the respondent Nos. 3 to 5 alongwith Zameer Ahmad and mother of Mehtab Ahmad, i.e., the widow of Hazi Ameer Ahmad, instituted Case No. 10/2007 under Section 229 -B of the Uttar Pradesh Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act, 1950 (hereinafter referred to as, 'Act, 1950') for declaration of their rights as co-tenure holders of the disputed plots pleading that, after the death of Mehtab Ahmad, the plots devolved on his father Hazi Ameer Ahmad and after the death of Hazi Ameer Ahmad the plaintiffs alongwith the petitioner became co-tenure holder of the disputed plots. While the aforesaid case was still pending, the respondent Nos. 3 to 5 filed an application on 31.1.2011 before the Tehsildar, Nagina for recall of the order dated 28.10.1985. The Tehsildar vide his order dated 30.12.2011 recalled the order dated 28.10.1985 and restored the mutation case registered at the instance of the petitioner. The petitioner alleging that the order dated 30.12.2011 was an ex-parte order passed without giving any opportunity of hearing to him, filed a recall application for recall of the order dated 30.12.2011. The Tehsildar through his order dated 23.3.2012 recalled his order dated 30.12.2011on the ground that the recall application filed by respondent Nos. 3 to 5 was not maintainable as Case No. 10/2007 registered under Section 229 -B of the Act, 1950 was still pending. Against the order dated 23.3.2012 passed by the Tehsildar, the respondent Nos. 3 to 5 filed appeal before the Sub Divisional Magistrate, Nagina (hereinafter referred to as, 'S.D.M.'), who vide his order dated 30.6.2012 dismissed the said appeal. Consequently, the respondent Nos. 3 to 5 filed Revision No. 98/11-12 before the Commissioner, Moradabad Division, Moradabad (hereinafter referred to as, 'Commissioner') and the Commissioner vide his order dated 23.7.2012 allowed the revision and set aside the orders dated 30.6.2012, 23.3.2012 and 28.10.1985 passed by the subordinate revenue authorities and remanded back the matter to the Tehsildar to pass fresh orders in the mutation case. The order dated 23.7.2012 passed by the Commissioner was challenged by the petitioner before the Board of Revenue, U.P. at Lucknow (hereinafter referred to as, 'Board of Revenue') through Revision No. 2435/LR/2011-12. The said revision has been dismissed by the Board of Revenue vide its order dated 22.8.2012. The orders dated 23.7.2012 and 22.8.2012 have been challenged in the present writ petition.
3. It is the admitted case of the parties that Hazi Ameer Ahmad was alive when Mehtab Ahmad died. Succession to the disputed plots is governed by Section 171 of the Act, 1950. Under Section 171 of the Act, 1950, after the death of Mehtab Ahmad in 1984, Hazi Ameer Ahmad, i.e., the father of Mehtab Ahmad had preferential rights over the bro