2026 Supreme(All) 1548
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD
YOGENDRA KUMAR SRIVASTAVA, J.
Neeraj Maheshwari – Petitioner
Versus
Shri Narayanlal Dharamshala Trust, Kasganj – Respondent
Matters Under Article 227 No. 12345 of 2025
Decided On : 02-09-2026
Important Points
Subject
Civil Law - Civil Procedure
Act Referred
Headnote
(B) Constitution of India - Article 227 - Scope of Supervisory Jurisdiction - The supervisory jurisdiction of the High Court under Article 227 is used to correct patent jurisdictional errors, perversity, or manifest illegality. It is not intended for the court to examine the merits of factual and legal defenses that are otherwise available to a party before the trial court (Paras 27, 28).
Facts of the case:
A landlord initiated an eviction suit against a tenant, alleging a landlord-tenant relationship and the tenant's failure to pay rent from a specific date despite demands and the issuance of three termination notices. The tenant filed a written statement admitting the tenancy but contested the rent arrears and the service of notices. The tenant moved an application under Order VII Rule 11 CPC seeking rejection of the plaint on the grounds that it failed to disclose a cause of action and lacked details regarding the plaintiff's authority to sue. Both the trial court and the revisional court refused to reject the plaint, leading the tenant to challenge these orders before the High Court.
Findings of Court:
The court found that the plaint specifically pleaded the landlord-tenant relationship, the exact date from which rent remained unpaid, the demands made, and the delivery of registered notices for termination. These averments, taken at face value, provided the necessary factual foundation for the relief of eviction. The objections raised by the tenant regarding the authority of the plaintiff and the actual payment of rent were matters of evidence to be decided at trial and did not render the plaint liable for rejection at the threshold.
Issues: Whether the plaint in the eviction suit failed to disclose a cause of action such that it warranted rejection under Order VII Rule 11(a) of the Code of Civil Procedure.
Ratio Decidendi: The determination of whether a plaint discloses a cause of action under Order VII Rule 11(a) CPC is confined strictly to the averments in the plaint. The court must not conduct a mini-trial, weigh the defense, or examine the truth of the allegations. If the plaint sets out the foundational facts required to seek the relief claimed, the objection for rejection of the plaint must fail, regardless of the defenses raised in the written statement.
Result: Petition disposed of.
For the Petitioner: Aarushi Birla, Utkarsh Birla
For the Respondent: Ashutosh Ganguli, Pranab Kumar Ganguli
JUDGMENT :
YOGENDRA KUMAR SRIVASTAVA, J.
1. Heard Sri Utkarsh Birla, learned counsel for the petitioner and Sri Pranab Kumar Ganguli, learned counsel appearing for the respondent.
2. The present petition has been filed assailing the order dated 29.05.2024 passed by the Civil Judge (Senior Division), Kasganj in S.C.C. Suit No. 2 of 2019 (Shri Narayanlal Dharamshala Trust, Kasganj Vs. Neeraj Maheshwari), as also the subsequent order dated 27.08.2025 passed by the District Judge, Kasganj in S.C.C. Revision No. 16 of 2024 (Neeraj Maheshwari Vs. Shri Narayanlal Dharamshala Trust, Kasganj), whereby the order passed by the trial court has been affirmed.
3. The controversy in the present petition relates to the tenancy of a shop situated at Bazaar Nadrai Gate, near Jain Mandir, Kasganj, which admittedly belongs to the respondent-Trust. The case set up by the petitioner is that the shop was originally let out to his grandfather, Shri Mormukut, and that the tenancy thereafter devolved upon his father, Shri Devendra Kumar Maheshwari. According to the petitioner, upon the death of his father, he succeeded to the tenancy in the year 2005 and has since been paying rent at the rate of Rs.1,000/- per month.
4. It appears that a dispute arose between the parties in the year 2017 with regard to the petitioner's occupation of the shop. The petitioner thereupon instituted Original Suit No. 218 of 2017 (Neeraj Maheshwari Vs. Pankaj Jain) before the Court of 2nd Additional Civil Judge (Junior Division), Kasganj, seeking a decree of permanent injunction restraining his alleged forcible eviction from the tenanted premises. The said suit was decreed ex parte by judgment and order dated 28.03.2019. The petitioner asserts that the said judgment was not assailed and, consequently, attained finality.
5. Thereafter, the respondent-Trust instituted S.C.C. Suit No. 2 of 2019 on 27.05.2019 before the Judge, Small Causes Court/Civil Judge (Senior Division), Kasganj, seeking eviction of the petitioner from the disputed shop.
6. Upon receipt of notice in the said suit, the petitioner deposited a sum of Rs.34,000/- towards the rent alleged to be outstanding, along with interest and other expenses, making a total deposit of Rs.44,000/- on 29.07.2019. The respondent thereafter filed its objections to the said deposit on 09.08.2019.
7. The petitioner filed his written statement in the SCC Suit on 13.11.2019, which was subsequently amended pursuant to an amendment application allowed on 26.04.2023. In the written statement, the petitioner disputed the allegations contained in the plaint and, inter alia, pleaded that the Secretary of the respondent-Trust had declined to accept rent on a monthly basis and had instead insisted upon payment at the end of the year. The petitioner also referred to Misc. Case No. 16 of 2018, wherein, according to him, rent for the period from 01.10.2016 to 31.05.2018 had been deposited under Section 30(1) of the U.P. Act No. 13 of 1972.
8. The petitioner also raised objections to the maintainability of the SCC Suit and invoked Order VII Rule 11 CPC. It was contended that the plaint did not disclose any cause of action and did not specify when, where or in what manner the alleged cause of action had arisen. It was further contended that the plaint did not contain the requisite particulars regarding the status and authority of the respondent-Trust, including the Trust Deed and the authority of its Secretary to institute the suit. The petitioner also questioned the applicability of the U.P. Act No. 13 of 1972, contending that the respondent had merely asserted that the premises were exempt from the operation of the said Act without placing the requisite material on record.
9. It has been pointed out by learned counsel for the parties that the trial court formulated the points for determination on 19.05.2023, wherein Point No. 6 was specifically framed to consider whether the suit was liable to be rejected under Order VII Rule 11 CPC.