High Court Of Madhya Pradesh
C. P. Sen and Y. B. Suryavanshi, JJ.
K G ANSARI
Versus
S P AGARWAL
Decided On : Oct 26,1988
( 1. ) THIS is a petition under Article 215, Constitution of India read with Section 10 of the Contempt of Courts Act for taking suitable action against the two non-applicants/contemners for flagrant violation of the orders, particularly the orders dated 4-7-1988 passed by Registrar, Co-operative societies, Bilaspur.
( 2. )
(i) It is common ground that the petitioner/applicant is a member of the managing Committee of the Bilaspur Grah Nirman Sahkari Samiti Maryadit (for short Society ). It has 13 elected and 5 nominated members on its Managing committee. The Managing Director of the Society is also one Ex-Officio Member. The society has large membership and has built number of colonies. (ii) The Chairman of the Society viz. Shri D. P. Choubey expired on 19-6-1988. According to Rule 43 (2-A) of the Co-operative Societies Rules (for short Co-op. Soc. Rules) read with Bye-law 28 of the Bye-laws of the Society, that vacancy could be filled up by the remaining members of the Managing Committee after co-opting a person in the said vacancy of the Managing Committee. (iii) It is undisputed that N. A. No. 1 Shri S. P. Agarwal, Vice-Chairman convened the meeting of the Managing Committee by notice dated 30-6-1988 for filling the casual vacancy. The Deputy Registrar, on an application made to him by some members of the Society, passed an order dated 2-7-1988 staying the meeting to be held on 4-7-1988 till further orders. On the basis of that order, Managing director cancelled the meeting dated 4-7-1988 and sent a communication to all the members. (iv) It is further undisputed that N. A. No. 1 Shri S. P. Agarwal, Vice-Chairman, then wrote a letter to the Managing Director stating "that the Deputy Registrar has no legal authority to pass such stay order and therefore, the meeting would be held as scheduled and all the members and the Deputy Registrar be also informed accordingly". (Ann. C ).
( 3. ) AT that, the applicant Shri K. G. Ansari and one Shri Badri Prasad, also a member of Managing Committee (for short M. C.) moved Deputy Registrar, which is an application purporting to be under Section 64 of the M. P. Cooperative societies Act (for short Coop. Soc. Act) challenging the validity of the meeting convened on 4-7-1988 said to be in violation of Rule 43 (2-A) read with Bye-law 28 and Ordinance No. 3 of 1988 besides some other allegations (Ann. D ). The Deputy registrar then passed orders dated 4-7-1988 staying conduction of the meeting scheduled on 4-7-1988 till further orders (Ann. E ).
( 4. ) BUT admittedly the meeting was held on 4-7-1988 and as per minutes (Ann. F) the subjects included co-option of a member due to sudden demise of Shri D. P. Choubey, Chairman; secondly the election of the Chairman; thirdly, discussion on the communication by the Deputy Registrar dated 2-7-1988. Apropos the subjects in this meeting, N. A. No. 2 Shri Shri Kumar Agarwal was unanimously coopted as a member; secondly he was also elected as Chairman; thirdly it was resolved that the deputy Registrar had no jurisdiction to pass stay orders; that Shri B. P. Dubey expressed the contrary view; whereas one Shri Ramashankar Tiwari remained neutral. The Chairman and other members were of the opinion that the election programme was already issued and therefore, no such stay order could have been passed.
( 5. ) ACCORDING to the applicant, N. A. No. 1, in order to get his son-in-law i. e. N. A. No. 2 Shri Shri Kumar Agarwal to be co-opted and later to be elected as president, convened the meeting, which is in contravention of Rule 43 (2-A) of the coop. Soc. Rules read with Bye-law 28 of the Society; that the D. R. had passed the official order on 2-7-1988, and further stay orders dated 4-7-1988 under Section 64 of Coop. Soc. Act; that despite having received the certified copy of the stay order through Shri Badri Prasad Dubey, Member of the M. C. before the commencement of the meeting, all that has been stated above, was wilfully done; that the convening and
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.