Jaiswal, J. -- 1. In Writ Petition No.4414/2012, filed in public interest, petitioners, claiming to be public spirited citizens prayed for a writ in the nature of mandamus directing the respondents No.2 and 3 to remove the illegal encroachment of respondent No.4 from the land bearing survey No.269/1 of village – Palasia Hana Indore. They also prayed for writ of prohibition directing the respondent No.3 to ensure that no illegal construction or unauthorized construction is raised and to take proper and effective steps for removal of such illegal and unauthorized construction, if already made or is being made, on the ground that it is an illegal and against public interest.

2. Brief facts of the case are that the land bearing Survey Nos.269/1 and 269/2, are the land of Municipal Corporation, Indore, as is evident from Khasra Panchshala 1973-74 (Annexure P-4) and revenue records upto 2013-14 (Annexure P-4). One Vallabh Malviya son of Ganga Bishan Malviya, real brother of Rajesh Ganga Bishan Malviya (respondent No.4) on 27.3.1998, executed sale deed (Annexure P-5) in favour of his brother – Rajesh Malviya (respondent No.4.) in respect of 2900 sq. fts of Survey No.269, for a consideration of Rs.1,00,000/-. On 27.3.2005 a corrigendum (amended deed) to the sale deed dated 27.9.1998 was executed by Shri Vallabh Malviya, in favour of respondent No.4 – Rajesh Malviya (Writ petitioner in Writ P.No.5998/2014). By this amendment in place of survey No.269, Khajrana Kankad, Indore, the Survey No.264, village Palasiya Hana, Indore has been mentioned. Clause “A” and “B” is sale deed (Annexure P-6) :-

^^¼,½ ;g fd] foØsrk us iathd`r foØ; foys[k Øekad 1v@6078@1998] fnukad 28-3-1998 ds }kjk vius LokfeRo dh laifÙk tks fd xzke & iykfl;kgkuk ds losZ uacj 264] isfd Hkkx 2900 oxZQhV ij fLFkr Fkh] Øsrk dks foØ; dh Fkh rFkk blds izfrQy dh lEiw.kZ /kujkf'k Øsrk ls izkIr djds bldk fjDr vkf/kiR; Øsrk dks rRle; gh ekSds ij ns fn;k x;kA

¼ch½ ;g fd] fyfidh; =qfV ,oa Vk;fiax dh Hkwyo'k mDr foØ; foys[k ds pj.k 1 esa foØhr laifÙk ^^[kljk uacj 269] [ktjkuh dkdM] bUnkSj^^ Vkbi gks x;k Fkk tcfd okLrfod :i ls foØhr laifÙk ^^[kljk uEcj 264] xzke iykfl;kgkuk] bUnkSj^^ ij gSA laifÙk dk lEiw.kZ fooj.k layXu vuqlwph esa fn;k x;k gSA**

3. On 31.12.2010 another corrigendum (amended deed) was executed by Shri Vallabh Malviya “son of Ganga Bishan Malviya, in favour of Ratnesh @ Rajesh Malviya son of Vallabh Malviya, through power of attorney Sri Shri Vallabh Malviya son of Ganga Bishan Malviya. By this second amended deed, the number of survey land as well as name of the father of the respondent No.4 was also changed. Paras 6 to 11 of the amended sale deed dated 31.12.2010, which has been executed after a period of more than 12 years from the original sale deed reads as under :

^^6- izFkei{k ds }kjk] f}rh;i{k ds fgr esa fu"ikfnr ,oa iathd`r foØ; ys[k Øekad 1v@6078 ¼,p½ ds i`"B Øekad 2 ds pj.k Øekad 1 dh f}rh; iafDr esa Hkwyo'k ,oa Vad.k =qfV ds QyLo:i xzke iyklh;k gkuk ds LFkku ij [ktjkuk dkadM Vafdr gksdj mYysf[kr gqvk gSA

7- izFkei{k ,oa f}rh;i{k us fu"ikfnr la'kks/ku ys[k esa mfpr ,oa lgh xzke LFkku ds leFkZu esa ekuuh; mPp U;k;ky;] e-iz- bUnkSj ds }kjk fd;s x, dfe'uj egksn; ds }kjk iznRr dh xbZ dfe'ulZ fjikVZ dh Nk;kizfr layXu dh gSA

8- izFkei{k ,oa f}rh;i{k us fu"ikfnr la'kks/ku ys[k esa mfpr ,oa lgh xzke LFkku ds leFkZu esa ljiap xzke iapk;r [ktjkuk ftyk bankSj ds fnukad

18-7-1971 ds nk[kyk dh Nk;kizfr layXu dh gSA

9- izFkei{k ,oa f}rh;i{k us fu"ikfnr la'kks/ku ys[k esa mfpr ,oa lgh xzke LFkku ds leFkZu esa fnukad 20-12-2005 ds ekSdk iapukek dh Nk;kizfr layXu dh gSA

10- izFkei{k ,oa f}rh;i{k us fu"ikfnr la'kks/ku ys[k esa mfpr ,oa lgh xzke LFkku ds leFkZu esa fnukad 25-2-2006 ds ekSdk iapukek dh Nk;kizfr layXu dh gSA

11- izFkei{k ,oa f}rh;i{k us fu"ikfnr la'kks/ku ys[k esa mfpr ,oa lgh xzke LFkku ds leFkZu esa iVokjh egksn; ds lR;kfir V