SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Judicial Analysis Court Copy Headnote Facts Arguments Court observation
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2015 Supreme(Tri) 625

THE HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA, AGARTALA
DEEPAK GUPTA, S.C. DAS, JJ.
Pritis Kumar De - Petitioner
Versus
State Bank of India & Ors. - Respondents
W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2011
Decided on : 04.08.2015

Advocates:
Advocate Appeared:
Ms. S. Deb Gupta
Mr. S. Dutta

The main legal point established in the judgment is that overdrawal from the current account beyond the sanctioned limit constitutes gross misconduct under the Memorandum of Settlement dated 10.04.2002.

Headnote:

Misconduct - Overdrawal from Current Account - Memorandum of Settlement dated 10.04.2002 - The court upheld the dismissal of the petitioner from service for overdrawal from his current account, which was found to be gross misconduct under the Memorandum of Settlement dated 10.04.2002.

Fact of the Case:

The petitioner, a Senior Assistant at a bank, was dismissed from service for overdrawal from his current account beyond the sanctioned limit. The petitioner challenged the dismissal through a writ petition.

Finding of the Court:

The court upheld the dismissal of the petitioner, finding that the overdrawal constituted gross misconduct under the Memorandum of Settlement dated 10.04.2002. The court also found no violation of principles of natural justice and no evidence to support the petitioner's claim.

Issues: The main issue was whether the petitioner's overdrawal constituted gross misconduct under the Memorandum of Settlement dated 10.04.2002.

Ratio Decidendi: The court held that the overdrawal from the current account beyond the sanctioned limit amounted to gross misconduct under the Memorandum of Settlement dated 10.04.2002. The court also emphasized the limited scope of judicial review in such cases.

Final Decision: The court dismissed the writ petition and upheld the dismissal of the petitioner from service.

ORDER :

S.C. Das, J.

By filing this writ petition, the petitioner, inter alia, prayed for setting aside and/or quashing final order of punishment dated 25.09.2010, issued by respondent No.2, the disciplinary authority, dismissing him from service and also prayed for reinstating him in the service as Senior Assistant under the respondent No.1.

2. Heard learned counsel, Ms. S. Debgupta for the petitioner and learned counsel, Mr. S. Dutta for the respondents.

3. The petitioner was working as a Senior Assistant, attached with Kunjaban Branch of State Bank of India (for short ‘SBI’) at Agartala. He was availing overdraft facility to the tune of Rs.3,00,000/in connection with his Current Account No. 10221182291. During the period from September, 2005 to June, 2006, the petitioner resorted to overdrawal from his current account and as on 28.06.2006 the balance in his overdraft account stood at Rs.16,36,329.32. It is contended by the petitioner that after the overdrawal was noticed, with the permission of the respondent-Bank, on 03.07.2006 the overdraft account was brought within its limit. It is further contended by the petitioner that on 24.01.2007, the Branch Manager of Kunjaban Branch of SBI lodged an FIR against petitioner alleging criminal offence by way of overdrawal and that FIR was registered as East Agartala P.S. Case No.19 of 2007, which was subsequently registered as G.R. No.84/2007 under Section 409 of IPC. A copy of the FIR is annexed as Annexure1 to the writ petition. Thereafter by Memo dated 09.07.2007 (Annexure-2 to the writ petition) a show cause notice was issued proposing a disciplinary proceeding against the petitioner for gross misconduct on the following article of charges :-

“SHOW CAUSE NOTICE

It is alleged that while working as Senior Assistant at Kunjavan Branch during the period from 01.09.2005 to 03.07.2006 certain irregularities of serious nature have been observed in your activities.

You are, therefore, charged as under :

CHARGE 1

You have fraudulently withdrawn an excess amount of Rs. 13,36,329.32 from your personal overdraft account (No.1022118229) against sanctioned limit of Rs.3.00 lacs maintained at Kunjavan Branch over a period of time.

CHARGE 2

You have posted the following debit/credit transactions on various dates into your personal overdraft account (No.1022118229) under your own ID & Password:-

Date

Amount

Date

Amount

05.09.2005

Rs.2000

06.01.2006

Rs.9000

14.09.2005

Rs.2000

07.01.2006

Rs.2000

27.09.2005

Rs.4000

09.01.2006

Rs.6000

06.10.2005

Rs.4000

10.01.2006

Rs.32000

08.10.2005

Rs.2500

12.01.2006

Rs.10000

13.10.2005

Rs.5000

14.01.2006

Rs.2000

15.10.2005

Rs.3000

16.01.2006

Rs.5000

21.10.2005

Rs.10000

18.01.2006

Rs.10000

31.10.2005

Rs.7000

25.01.2006

Rs.7000

31.10.2005

Rs.8000

27.01.2006

Rs.3000

03.11.2005

Rs.3500

28.01.2006

Rs.5000

07.11.2005

Rs.2500

02.02.2006

Rs.13000

 

 

04.02.2006

Rs.10000

10.11.2005

Rs.8000

07.02.2006

Rs.4000

14.11.2005

Rs.9000

08.02.2006

Rs.10000

17.11.2005

Rs.3000

10.02.2006

Rs.10000

19.11.2005

Rs.3000

13.02.2006

Rs.10000

20.11.2005

Rs.7000

15.02.2006

Rs.12000

28.11.2005

Rs.5000

16.02.2006

Rs.15000

28.11.2005

Rs.75000

17.02.2006

Rs.6500

31.12.2005

Rs.10000

20.02.2006

Rs.6500

04.01.2006

Rs.8000

02.05.2006

Rs.15000

24.02.2006

Rs.10000

03.05.2006

Rs.15000

25.02.2006

Rs.13000

04.05.2006

Rs.25000

28.02.2006

Rs.13000

05.05.2006

Rs.6000

03.03.2006

Rs.12000

06.05.2006

Rs.6000

09.03.2006

Rs.30000

27.05.2006

Rs.30000

11.03.2006

Rs.10000

29.05.2006

Rs.10000

13.03.2006

Rs.30000

03.06.2006

Rs.30000

18.03.2006

Rs.99000

05.06.2006

Rs.10000

18.03.2006

Rs.99000

10.06.2006

Rs10000

18.03.2006

Rs.30000

13.06.2006

Rs.40000

24.03.2006

Rs.30000

15.06.2006

Rs.14000

10.04.2006

Rs.25000

 

 

1



















































































Click Here to Read the rest of this document

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top