SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2025 Supreme(Online)(Bom) 1155

HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY
N.J. Jamadar, J
PRALHAD BALKRISHNA BALGHARE AND ANR – Appellant
Versus
SURYAKANT BALKRISHNA BALGHARE – Respondent
WP/1501/2024



Important Points

A gift by a coparcener of undivided interest in joint family property is void; joint family properties do not cease to be joint upon the death of a coparcener.

Subject

Property Law - Hindu Succession

Act Referred

Hindu Succession Act, 1956 : S.6,S.8

Headnote

(A) Hindu Succession Act, 1956 - Sections 6 and 8 - Joint family property - The court upheld the injunction against the alienation of joint family properties based on Gift Deeds executed by a coparcener, affirming that such gifts are void. The learned District Judge found that the properties remained joint family properties and that the defendants had no right to transfer undivided interests. (Paras 2.7, 6, 30)

(B) Legal principles - The court reiterated that a gift by a coparcener of his undivided interest in joint family property is void. The principle of notional partition does not equate to actual partition, and joint family properties do not cease to be joint family properties upon the death of a coparcener. (Paras 7, 30)

Facts of the case:
The petitioners challenged the dismissal of their appeal against an injunction order that restrained the alienation of joint family properties based on Gift Deeds executed by one of the coparceners. The properties were claimed to be ancestral and subject to ongoing partition proceedings. (Paras 2.1, 2.6)

Findings of Court:
The court found that the injunction was justified to protect the subject matter of the suit until the rights of the parties were adjudicated. The properties were determined to be joint family properties, and the gifts were deemed illegal. (Paras 30, 31)

Issues: The main issues included whether the properties were joint family properties and the legality of the Gift Deeds executed by a coparcener. (Paras 2.7, 30)

Ratio Decidendi: The court ruled that the Gift Deeds executed by a coparcener were void as they attempted to transfer undivided interests in joint family properties, which cannot be legally done. The court emphasized that the properties remained joint family properties despite the claims of individual ownership. (Paras 7, 30)

Result: Writ Petition dismissed.

Advocates:
Mr. A.V. Anturkar, Sr. Advocate with Mr. Drupad Patil with Mr. Yatin Malvankar, for Petitioners. Mr. Anurag Mishra i/by Mr. Avinav R., for Respondent.

JUDGMENT :

1. Rule. Rule made returnable forthwith. With the consent of the parties, heard finally.

2. The Petitioners – Defendants take exception to a judgment and order dated 27 October 2023 passed by the learned District Judge, Pune in Misc. Civil Appeal No.221 of 2022, whereby the appeal preferred by the Petitioners came to be dismissed affirming the order dated 11 April 2022 passed by the learned Civil Judge, Sr. Division, Pune in RCS No.2034 of 2019, thereby restraining the Petitioner – Defendant No.2 from selling, transferring, assigning or alienating the suit property on the basis of Gift Deed dated 25 April 2013 and 17 June 2013 in any manner, till further orders.

3. The background facts leading to this Petition can be stated, in brief, as under :

2.1 Shivram Laxman Balghare was the common ancestor. Shivram had acquired a number of properties, including the agricultural lands bearing No.203/2B of Village Lohegaon, Gat No.533 of Village Ambegaon and Gat No.385 of Village Ambegaon (suit properties). Shivram passed away on 13 August 1978, leaving behind Laxmibai, the widow, who passed away in the year 1979; three sons, namely, Shankar, Haribhau and Balkrishna and two daughters Nirabai and Shantabai. Balkrishna passed away on 2 March 1989, leaving behind Yashodabai, the widow, who passed away on 21 August 2001; two sons, Pralhad – Defendant No.1 and Suryakant – Plaintiff, and three daughters Hirabai, Pushpalata and Sharda. Vidya – Defendant No.2 is the wife of Pralhad – Defendant No.1.

2.2 Ashok and Maruti, the sons of Haribhau, had instituted suit No.1273 of 1990 for partition and separate possession of their share in the joint family properties, including the suit properties. The successors in interest of Balkrishna, including Pralhad – Defendant No.1 and Suryakant – Plaintiff were impleaded as Defendant Nos.9 to 14 therein.

2.3 By a judgment and order dated 31 October 2000, the said suit was decreed and each of the Plaintiffs therein, were declared to be entitled to get 6/80th share out of the suit properties. Defendant Nos.9 to 14 therein (including Pralhad – Defendant No.1 and Suryakant – Plaintiff) were declared to be entitled to 6/20th share together out of the suit properties.

2.4 An appeal against the said decree, being Appeal No.193 of 2001, came to be dismissed on 9 January 2003. Final decree proceedings in the said suit are pending.

2.5 Pralhad and Vidya – Defendant Nos.1 and 2, instituted a suit, being RCS No.254 of 2018, for declaration, injunction and separate possession of their share of the joint family properties, including the suit properties, which were described at paragraph Nos.1B, 1C and 1D of the plaint. Defendant Nos.1 and 2 asserted that in Suit No.1273 of 1990, the individual shares of Pralhad – Defendant No.1 and Suryakant – Plaintiff and the other successors in interest of Balkrishna, were not declared by the Court. Till date, the suit properties have not been divided by meets and bounds, except the land located at Survey No.211, Lohegaon (suit property 1A therein). Defendant Nos.1 and 2, thus, prayed for separate possession of their share of the suit properties. In the alternative, the suit properties be sold by auction and the sale proceeds be divided, if partition by meets and bounds was not possible, and further consequential reliefs.

2.6 Suryakant instituted RCS No.2034 of 2019 asserting that the persusal of the plaint in RCS No.254 of 2018 instituted by Defendant Nos.1 and 2 revealed that the Defendant No.1 had transferred undivided share out of the suit property 1A i.e. Survey No.203/2B of Village Lohegaon by way of gift under the Registered Gift Deed dated 25 April 2013 in favour of Defendant No.2. Likewise, Another Gift Deed has been executed in favour of Defendant No.2 in respect of the suit properties 1B and 1C i.e. Gat Nos.533 and 385 situated at Ambegaon. The Plaintiff in RCS No.2034 of 2019, thus, averred that the Gift of undivided interest by the Defendant No.1 in favour of Defendant No.

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top