1. Accused persons in a terrorism-related case under the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act and Indian Penal Code appeal against the rejection of their bail applications by the trial court. (Para 01 , 02 , 06 , 08 )
2026 Supreme(Online)(J&K) 966
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH AT SRINAGAR
Rajnesh Oswal, Sanjay Parihar, JJ
Mohammad Rafiq Phaloo – Appellant
Versus
UT of J&K – Respondent
CrlA(D) No.1/2025 | CrlA(D) No.114/2025
Important Points
Subject
Criminal - Bail
Act Referred
Indian Penal Code: S.121-A, S.201
NIA Act
Headnote
(B) Medical Grounds for Bail - Health condition - Non-urgent elective surgery or medical conditions that can be managed with medication while in custody do not constitute sufficient grounds for the grant of bail in cases involving serious offences. (Para 12)
Issues: Whether the appellants are entitled to bail under Section 43-D(5) of the UAPA given the nature of the evidence, the stage of the trial, and their criminal antecedents.
Result: Appeals dismissed.
Legal Category Hierarchy
For the Appellants/Petitioners: Z. A. Qureshi, Rehana, Wajid Haseeb
For the Respondents: Maha Majeed, Mohsin Qadiri
Table of Contents
2. Appellants contend there is insufficient prima facie evidence of conspiracy and reliance on inadmissible material, while the prosecution asserts the charges are grave and evidence is strong. (Para 03 , 04 , 05 , 06 )
3. The court observed that material witnesses concerning disclosure and recovery of incriminating evidence remain to be examined, necessitating judicial restraint on assessing the merits of the evidence now. (Para 09 , 10 , 11 , 13 )
4. Bail under the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act cannot be granted when material witnesses regarding key incriminating evidence are yet to be examined by the prosecution. (Para 09 , 10 , 13 )
5. The court dismissed the appeals while granting liberty to the appellants to move for bail again after the material witnesses have been examined. (Para 14 , 15 )
6. Does the requirement of prima facie truth under Section 43-D (5) of UAPA compel the court to evaluate the merits of evidence if material witnesses are unexamined?
No. The court maintains that evaluating the merits of the prosecution's evidence, specifically regarding disclosures and seizures, is premature until material witnesses have been fully examined at trial. (Para 09 , 10 , 13 )
7. Can medical grounds justify bail under UAPA if the condition is manageable while in custody?
No. When medical reports indicate that an accused's health condition can be managed with medication or treatment while in custody, bail on medical grounds is not warranted. (Para 12 )
JUDGMENT
OSWAL-J
01. Mohammad Yaseen Bhat (appellant in CrlA(D) No.114/2025) and Mohammad Rafiq Phaloo (appellant in CrlA(D) No. 01/2026) figure as accused No.1 and 2 along with 10 others in chargesheet titled “State vs. Mohammad Yaseen Bhat and others” arising out of FIR No. 23/2023 for commission of offences under Sections 10, 13, 18 of UA(P) Act and Sections 121-A , 201 of IPC registered with Police Station Kothibagh pending before the Court of learned Special Judge designated under NIA Act , Srinagar (for short “the Trial Court”).
02. The appellants had filed their respective bail applications before the learned Trial Court and the learned Trial Court, by way of two separate orders each dated 12.12.2025, dismissed the said bail applications. The appellants have now come up with these two separate appeals thereby assailing the orders supra whereby their prayer for grant of bail has been rejected.
03. Mohammad Rafiq Phaloo (appellant in CrlA(D) No.01/2026 has assailed order dated 12.12.2025 passed by the learned Trial Court on the grounds that the protected witnesses, whose statements have been recorded, have not supported the prosecution case vis-a-vis the appellant and also they have not spoken anything about the conspiracy allegedly hatched by the persons attending the Eid Milan party for revival of the JKLF-Y. It is also contended that the learned Trial Court has rejected the application by pressing into service Section 43-D of UAPA despite the fact that no prima facie case existed against the appellant for promoting unlawful activities and waging war against the Union of India. It is also urged that the evidence so collected and relied upon by the learned Trial Court for rejection of the bail application comprises the alleged recovery of mobile phone, forensic analysis, seizure of resolution, identification of financial transactions and recovery of alleged anti-India propagandistic material, but there is no evidence on record to show or prove that the phone allegedly recovered from the possession of the appellant contains any material to establish the alleged conspiracy. Despite absence of any such evidence, the learned Trial Court has drawn a presumption that the appellant wanted to revive the activities of JKLF-Y.
04. It is also contended that the learned Trial Court has gravely erred in law by not considering the settled principle that the test of prima facie true under Section 43-D (5) of UAPA requires a careful, objective and judicious evaluation of the material on record and not a mere reproduction or acceptance of prosecution’s allegations.
05. Mohammad Yaseen Bhat (appellant in CrlA(D) No.114/2025) has also assailed order dated 12.12.2025 on the identical grounds by contending that the prosecution case is based on hearsay evidence which is wholly inadmissible under law and cannot constitute the material so as to satisfy the requirements in order to attract the rigour of Section 43-D of Unlawful Activities Prevention Act and on the face of story as projected by the police, the appellant deserves to be given concession of bail. Besides, the appellant has also cited his health condition for release on bail.
06. The respondent has filed its response stating therein that appellant-Mohd. Yasin Bhat had acquired arms training and exfiltrated POK a number of times to return only in 1992 along with Yasin Malik, whereas the appellant-Mohd. Rafiq Pahloo was involved in FIR No. 339/1989 of P/S Sadder regarding kidnapping of Rubiya Sayed and in FIR No. 22/1990 of P/S Sadder regarding killing of Airforce Officials. It is further stated that on 09.07.2023, Police Station, Kothibagh received reliable information that some persons along with the appellants had organized a meeting at Habib Restaurant. While ostensibly organized as an “Eid Milan party”, the gathering served as a front for ex-members of the banned organization JKLF-Y and other separatist activists to coordinate unlawful activities. The primary objective was t