SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2025 Supreme(Online)(Kar) 30645

KARNATAKA HIGH COURT
S.R.KRISHNA KUMAR, J
SMT CHANNAMMA W/O LATE MUNINARAYANAPPA SINCE DECEASED HER LRs ARE APPELLANT 1 TO 81 – Appellant
Versus
SMT THIPPAMMA ALIAS JAYAMMA AGED ABOUT 73 YEARS D/O LATE ANNAYYAPPA – Respondent
REGULAR FIRST APPEAL NO. 1969 OF 2022 (PAR/DEC)|OS No.8503/2019



Important Points

The court ruled that a partition suit filed after a 40-year delay is barred by limitation and individuals cannot claim rights to ancestral property sold by their ancestors during their lifetime.

Subject

Civil Law - Property Law

Act Referred

CPC: Order 41 Rule 1, Order VII Rule 11

Headnote

(A) Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 - Order VII Rule 11(a) and (d) - Appeal against rejection of plaint - Suit for partition barred by limitation - Plaintiffs filed a suit for partition after 40 years of the alleged alienation, which the trial court found to be vexatious and frivolous due to unexplained delay in filing - The court dismissed the plea, holding it failed to disclose a cause of action and affirmed that grandchildren cannot claim inheritance from an alienated property by their paternal grandfather after his death during lifetime of their father. (Paras 10-13)

(B) Limitation - Doctrine of Limitation - Delay of 40 years in filing the suit is significant and has resulted in the court ruling that suit is barred by law of limitation - Plaintiff's claim deemed meritless and false given their long delay in asserting any rights. (Paras 10-10.12)

Facts of the case:
The appellants filed a suit for partition regarding ancestral property which was allegedly mismanaged and sold off without their consent by the defendant family members from 1978. The trial court held the suit as barred due to limitation and lacking a legitimate cause of action, given the legal standings of the parties involved and historical transactions of the property. (Paras 4-8)

Findings of Court:
The court upheld the trial court's decisions stating the plaintiffs did not hold a valid claim over the property, which had been alienated long ago and was thus barred by limitation. (Paras 10-13)

Issues: The primary issues involved whether the trial court was justified in rejecting the plaint and if the suit was indeed barred by limitation. (Paras 5-6)

Ratio Decidendi: The court concluded that grandchildren could not legally reclaim ancestral property alienated during the lifetime of their parent. Additionally, there were legal precedents cited concerning the statutes that govern property disputes within joint families, reinforcing the expectation of timely claims in property matters. (Paras 11-16)

Result: Appeal dismissed, affirming the trial court's decision. (Para 13)

Advocates:
For the Appellants/Petitioners: SRI. RAVI L VAIDYA
For the Respondents: SRI. SRINATH P, SRI JAGADEESHWAR J, SRI M MOHAN KUMAR, SRI R HARSHA

Table of Content
1. details of plaintiffs and suit history. (Para 1 , 4)
2. court's analysis on facts and jurisprudence. (Para 2 , 5 , 7 , 12)
3. arguments related to limitation and right to sue. (Para 6 , 11)
4. legal principles concerning partition and limitations. (Para 10 , 13)

ORAL JUDGMENT

This appeal by the plaintiffs in O.S.No.8503/2019 is directed against the impugned order/judgment and decree dated 13.10.2022 passed by the XLII Additional City Civil and Sessions Judge, Bengaluru, whereby the application I.A.No.3 filed by the respondent No.8-defendant No.8 under Order VII Rule 11 (a) and (d) of CPC was allowed by the Trial Court which proceeded to reject the plaint and consequently, dismissed the suit filed by the appellants/plaintiffs.

2. Heard learned counsel for the appellants and learned counsel for the respondents and perused the material on record.

3. With the consent of both sides, the lower court records have been procured from the Trial Court and the matter is taken up for final disposal.3

4. The material on record discloses that the appellant-plaintiffs instituted the aforesaid suit seeking partition, declaration and other reliefs in relation to the suit schedule immovable property. In the said suit, the respondent No.8-defendant No.8 not only contested the suit by filing his written statement but also filed the instant application, I.A.No.3 seeking rejection of the plaint under Order VII Rule 11 (a) and (d) of CPC . The said application having been opposed by the plaintiffs, the Trial Court proceeded to pass the impugned order allowing the application and thereby rejecting the plaint and consequently, dismissing the suit filed by the appellants-plaintiffs, who are before this Court by way of the present appeal.

5. The following points arise for consideration in the present appeal:

i) Whether the Trial Court was justified in rejecting the plaint and consequently, dismiss the suit filed by the appellants-plaintiffs in the facts and circumstances of the instant case?

ii) Whether the impugned order/judgment and decree passed by the Trial Court warrants interference in the present appeal?

6. Since both the points are interlinked with each other, they are taken up together for consideration.

Re:Point Nos.(i) and (ii):-

7. Before adverting to the rival submissions, it would be necessary to refer to the relevant portion of the plaint as under:

“1. It is submitted that, one Sonnappa alias Annayyappa of Dasarahalli Village had 4 sons namely (i) Sri. Munibellappa, (ii) Sri. Chowdaiah, (iii) Sri.Sonnappa alias Maddannappa and (iv) Sri. Munishamappa, all of them were constituted Hindu Undivided Joint Family of which Sri.Sonnappa alias Annayyappa was the Kartha. Under a registered partition deed dated 05.11.1945 vide document No.2204/1945-46, all the aforesaid 4 sons of Sri. Sonnappa alias Annayyappa have partitioned all the joint family properties, under which an extent of 25 Guntas out of the total extent of 1 Acre 36 Guntas of land in Sy No.31 of Dasarahalli Village was allotted to the share of his third son Sri.Sonnappa alias Maddannappa along with other properties. Certified copy of the registered deed dated 05.11.1945 is herewith produced for kind perusal of this Hon'ble court.

2. It is submitted that, Sri.Sonnappa alias Maddannappa has 4 children namely (i) Sri.Annayyappa, (ii) Sri. Muninarayanappa, (iii) Munichowdappa and (iv)Sri.Muniramaiah. All of them constituted Hindu Undivided Joint Family, of which Sri Sonnappa alias Maddannappa was the Kartha till his death. Among the aforesaid sons, the first son Sri.Annayyappa died leaving behind him the Defendant Nos. 1 to 4 herein to succeed to his estate. The second son Sri Muninarayanappa died leaving behind him the Plaintiffs herein to succeed to his estate. The third son Sri. Munichowdappa died as a Bachelor, and the fourth son Sri. Muniramaiah died leaving behind the Defendant Nos.5 to 7 herein to succeed to his estate. Whereas the Defendant Nos.8 to 21 are unconnected to the

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top