1. Suit seeking permanent injunction to restrain trademark and copyright infringement and passing off related to medicinal formulation marks and corresponding trade dress. (Para 1 , 6 , 10 , 11 , 12 )
2026 Supreme(Online)(Ker) 75870
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
Soumen Sen, CJ, Syam Kumar V.M., J
MRS. VINEETHA SURESH BABU – Appellant
Versus
DR. ROSE MARY WILSON – Respondent
Coml.A 4/2026
Important Points
Subject
Intellectual Property Rights - Trade Mark Law
Act Referred
Headnote
(B) Appellate Jurisdiction - Scope of interference with interim orders - An appellate court should not substitute its discretion for that of the trial court unless the order is arbitrary, capricious, perverse, or passed in ignorance of settled legal principles (Para 55).
Facts of the case:
The plaintiffs, who had used a specific word mark for medicinal tablets since 1989 and possessed registration in Class 5, sought a permanent prohibitory injunction against the defendants for using a deceptively similar mark in Class 30. The trial court granted an interim injunction, which was subsequently challenged. The defendants argued the mark was descriptive and common to the trade, and that the plaintiffs' prior use was insufficient to maintain the suit.
Findings of Court:
The court held that the essential feature of the registered mark was adopted by the defendants, creating a high likelihood of confusion for an average consumer. The plaintiffs' long-term and extensive use established a secondary meaning, making the mark distinctive regardless of its potential descriptive nature. The suit was maintainable as the plaintiffs demonstrated paramount rights through prior use and registration.
Issues: The primary issues were whether the suit was maintainable by a permitted user, whether the mark was common to the trade and descriptive, and whether the defendants' use of a similar mark constituted infringement and passing off.
Ratio Decidendi: Prior use of a mark confers paramount rights over subsequent registration. Distinctiveness acquired through extensive use overcomes objections regarding descriptive terms. The test for deception is based on the general impression of an average consumer with imperfect recollection. An appellate court will not interfere with a reasonable exercise of discretionary power by the trial court regarding interim injunctions.
Result: The appeal fails and accordingly dismissed.
Legal Category Hierarchy
For the Appellants/Petitioners: K. Radhakrishnan Nair, Sajen Thampan, Jinu Samyuktha Padmakumar, Ayoona P. M., Athil Jamal, Ashmy Lal G., Sarika Krishna A.
For the Respondents: P. Abraham Cherian, Nimmy K. Joseph, Joe Joseph, Jaison S. Rozario, Aravind Varghese, Pooja Jose, V. Varun, Haritha Mohan, Amal John Sabu
Table of Contents
2. Defendants disputed infringement, citing registration in different classes, alleged non-use by plaintiffs, and the descriptive, common-to-trade nature of the disputed trademark. (Para 17 , 18 )
3. The court observed that the plaintiffs established a prima facie case of goodwill through historic, exclusive, and continuous use, rendering the defendants' subsequent adoption deceptive and injurious. (Para 24 , 25 , 31 , 36 , 41 , 46 )
4. Prior use of a trademark, sufficient to establish secondary meaning and acquired distinctiveness, prevails over subsequent registration, justifying an injunction to prevent passing off and confusion. (Para 32 , 42 , 45 , 48 , 53 )
5. The Appellate Court dismissed the appeal and sustained the trial court’s interim order restraining the defendants from using the plaintiffs' mark or deceptively similar variations. (Para 54 , 56 , 57 )
6. Can a plaintiff successfully maintain an action for infringement or passing off even if the disputed mark arguably appears descriptive or common to the trade?
Yes. A mark that is descriptive or common to the trade may acquire distinctiveness through long, extensive, and exclusive use, resulting in a secondary meaning that identifies the goods with a particular source. Once this secondary meaning is established, the proprietor is entitled to protection against infringement and passing off. (Para 25 , 45 , 46 )
7. Does the registration of a trademark in a different class automatically insulate a defendant from an action for passing off?
No. Passing off is an action in deceit predicated on protecting goodwill and preventing misrepresentation. Even if a defendant holds a trademark registration in a different class, the court can grant an injunction where the prior user establishes that the mark has acquired significant reputation and the defendant’s usage is likely to cause confusion. (Para 14 , 42 , 47 , 48 )
8. Is a trademark owner required to pursue every minor infringer to preserve the validity of their mark or their right to injunction?
No. The proprietor is not expected to pursue petty, insignificant, or trivial infringements that do not threaten the distinctiveness of the mark or harm its business interests, and failure to sue all small-scale infringers does not constitute abandonment of rights. (Para 49 , 51 , 52 )
JUDGMENT
(Dated this the 12th day of November, 2026)
Soumen Sen, C.J.
1.The suit has been filed by the plaintiffs praying, inter alia, for a permanent prohibitory injunction restraining the defendants from using the trade mark ELADI, ELADI THRILL and/or device mark given in Schedule B of the plaint or any other trade mark similar to the device marks of the plaintiffs given in Schedule A of the plaint, in relation to chewable tablet/candy and thereby infringing the trade mark registration and copyright of the plaintiff No.1 and passing off their chewable tablet/candy as and for that of the plaintiffs.
2. In the suit, an interlocutory application was filed in which, the impugned order was passed.
3. The learned Additional District Judge, after hearing the parties, was satisfied that a case has been made out for restraining the said defendants from using the said device mark as well as the trade name, has passed an interim order and disposed of the application under Order XXXIX Rule 1 of CPC by restraining the defendants from passing off or infringing the registered trade mark of the respondents/ plaintiffs ‘ELADI’; and from using the names ‘ELADI’ and ‘ELADI THRILL’ or using any other trade name and a trade mark as part of it, identical or deceptively similar to it, till the disposal of the suit.
4. This order is under challenge.
5. A brief summary of facts and circumstances leading to the filing of the suit are stated hereinafter.
6. Plaintiff No.1 is an ayurvedic doctor by profession and also carrying on business related to manufacture and sale of ayurvedic medicinal preparations under the name and style “M/s. K.P. Pathrose Vaidyan's Kandamkulathy Vaidyasala” (in short, ‘Vaidyasala’) since 1989. Plaintiff No.2 is a private limited company incorporated by plaintiff No.1 and her husband Mr. K.P. Wilson in the year 1995. The said company manages and runs ayurvedic hospital as well as treatment centres and is also engaged in the manufacture and sale of ayurvedic medicinal preparations. Defendant No.1 is, inter alia, engaged in the business of manufacture and sale of chewable tablet/candy under the trademark ELADI/ELADI THRILL and a device mark closely similar to that of the plaintiffs. Defendant No.2 is a business entity managed by defendant No.1.
7. The Vaidyasala earned substantial reputation and goodwill for its authentic ayurvedic formulation derived from the family's traditional palm-leaf manuscripts. Due to the old age and ill health of K.P. Pathorse Vaidyan, the activity of the Vaidyasala gradually slowed down. Thereafter, in order to revive the business and to preserve the legacy built by the late K.P. Pathorse Vaidyan, plaintiff No.1, the daughter-in- law and a qualified ayurvedic physician, combined her professional knowledge and skill with the family's traditional formulations and established the business in the year 1989 as a sole proprietorship and carried on business under the name and style of K.P. Pathrose Vaidyan's Kandamkulathy Vaidyasala.
8. The ayurvedic medicinal preparations of the plaintiffs are being sold in India and exported to various foreign countries like UAE, Australia, New Zealand, Kuwait and Russia. The plaintiffs over the past three decades have been conducting various activities connected with research, pursuant to which they either develop and/or manufacture the ayurvedic medicinal preparations which they market, export and/or sell. The niche of the plaintiffs lies in their research and development activities besides the consistency in manufacturing, marketing and/or selling quality products of the said ayurvedic medicinal preparations.
9. Plaintiff No.1 is the proprietor of well-known trademarks in relation to ayurvedic medicinal preparations developed, manufactured and sold by the plaintiffs. Plaintiff No.2 is a company promoted by plaintiff No.1 and the said plaintiff manufactures and sells various ayurvedic medicines under the trademarks of which plaintiff No.1 is the proprietor with due permission of p