1. Quashing of order rejecting compassionate appointment for dependent of deceased government employee. (Para 1 , 2 )
2025 Supreme(Online)(P&H) 6055
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH
Sandeep Moudgil, J
Chander Mohan – Appellant
Versus
State of Haryana – Respondent
CWP-19615-2012
Important Points
Subject
Service Law - Compassionate Appointment
Act Referred
Haryana Compassionate Assistance to the Dependants of Deceased Government Employees Rules, 2006: R.5, R.6
Headnote
(B) Compassionate Assistance - Interpretation of Welfare Schemes - Humanitarian Approach - Compassionate appointment or financial assistance is a social welfare measure intended to cushion immediate hardship; such schemes must be construed with a humanitarian and purposive approach rather than a rigid or hyper-technical interpretation. (Para 4)
(C) Administrative Law - Reasoned Orders - Non-speaking Order - An administrative authority exercising statutory discretion must record reasons to demonstrate application of mind; a non-speaking and perfunctory order is arbitrary and violative of Article 14 of the Constitution of India. (Para 4)
(D) Haryana Compassionate Assistance Rules, 2006 - Application to Pending Cases - Rule 6 expressly provides that all pending cases of ex-gratia assistance shall be covered under the 2006 Rules. (Para 4)
Issues: Whether the petitioner is entitled to financial assistance under the 2006 Rules despite the initial dismissal of his father and subsequent quashing of said dismissal.
Legal Category Hierarchy
- service and labour laws
- administrative law
-
constitutional law
-
fundamental rights
- article 14 - equality before law (Para 4)
-
fundamental rights
For the Appellants/Petitioners: GPS Bal
For the Respondents: Ruchi Sekhri
Table of Contents
2. Dispute over applicability of 2003 policy versus 2006 Rules and effect of delay. (Para 3 )
3. Petition allowed – rejection quashed – financial assistance directed under 2006 Rules. (Para 5 )
4. What is the effect of quashing a dismissal order on the employee's status for compassionate appointment?
The employee is deemed to have been in continuous service and to have died while in service, bringing the case under compassionate assistance rules. (Para 4 )
5. Do the 2006 Rules extinguishing compassionate appointment apply to pending claims that arose earlier?
No, Rule 6 covers pending cases and provides financial assistance; the claim cannot be denied by invoking subsequent restrictive amendments. (Para 4 )
6. What is the requirement for an administrative order rejecting a compassionate claim?
The order must be speaking and demonstrate meaningful application of mind; a non-speaking order is arbitrary and violates Article 14. (Para 4 )
7. Can administrative delays by the employer defeat a claim for compassionate assistance?
No, the employer cannot defeat a legitimate claim by relying on its own delays or subsequent restrictive amendments. (Para 4 )
SANDEEP MOUDGIL, J
1. Prayer
The petitioner seeks quashing of the impugned order dated 14/16.08.2012 (Annexure P-4) whereby his claim for compassionate appointment was rejected by the respondents.
2. Brief Facts
The petitioner is the son of late Shri Ram Kishan, who served as an Inspector in the Food and Supplies Department. Shri Ram Kishan was initially convicted in a criminal case, but his conviction was later set aside by this Court vide order dated 04.05.1981, and the dismissal of the Special Leave Petition by the Supreme Court vide order dated 10.12.1982 which led to his reinstatement on 02.02.1984.
Subsequently, he was dismissed from service on 04.12.1989 after departmental proceedings. He challenged the dismissal in CWP No. 11786 of 1993, but during its pendency, he passed away on 22.02.1995. The writ petition was ultimately allowed vide order dated 22.02.2010 (Annexure P-1), quashing the dismissal and directing release of all retiral benefits.
Following the judgment, the widow of the deceased employee submitted representations seeking release of dues and compassionate appointment for the petitioner. While the pensionary benefits were released during contempt proceedings, the petitioner’s request for compassionate appointment was rejected on 14/16.08.2012 on the basis of the Haryana Compassionate Assistance Rules, 2006.
Aggrieved by the rejection, he has filed the present writ petition.
3. Contentions
On behalf of Petitioner
Learned counsel for the petitioner contends that the rejection of his claim for compassionate appointment is wholly arbitrary and unsustainable, as the authorities have incorrectly applied the Haryana Compassionate Assistance Rules, 2006. It is urged that his claim had arisen much earlier and was required to be considered under the policy/notification dated 31.03.2003 providing for ex-gratia compassionate appointment.
The counsel submits that he had applied as far back as 1996, but the respondents kept the matter pending solely on the ground of the pending writ filed by his father, a delay attributable entirely to the department.
It is asserted that once this Court quashed the dismissal order of his father in 2010 and deemed him reinstated for all purposes, the petitioner became entitled to be considered as a dependant of a deceased employee who died while in service.
Lastly it is argued that the impugned order is non-speaking, ignores the 2003 policy altogether, and suffers from misapplication of law. The petitioner, therefore, seeks quashing of the order dated 14/16.08.2012 and a direction for compassionate appointment or, alternatively, financial assistance as available under the applicable policy.
On behalf of Respondents
Per contra, learned counsel for the respondents submit that the petitioner is not entitled to compassionate appointment, as such appointments stand abolished by virtue of the Haryana Compassionate Assistance Rules, 2006, which were in force when the petitioner’s request was considered in 2012.
It is contended that compassionate appointment is not a vested right but a concession, and therefore the policy prevailing on the date of consideration i.e., the 2006 Rules must govern the field.
It is further argued that the petitioner’s father was not in service at the time of his death in 1995, as he had been dismissed in 1989, and hence the petitioner cannot claim benefits available to dependants of employees who die in harness.
It is also emphasised that the petitioner’s application was submitted after an inordinate delay and that earlier government instructions required dependants to apply within three years of the employee’s death. They assert that all retiral benefits have already been released to the family and that no further right accrues to the petitioner, rendering the writ petition liable to dismissal.
4. Analysis
Having considered the rival submissions and examined the record, this Court is of the considered view that even under the Haryana Compassionate Assistance to the Dependants of Deceas