SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2026 Supreme(Online)(Tri) 484

HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA AGARTALA
S. Datta Purkayastha, J
Pranajit Paul – Appellant
Versus
Tripura Gramin Bank – Respondent
WP(C) No.721 of 2026



Important Points

A transfer order passed in lieu of punishment, containing aspersions on an employee's conduct without following the principles of natural justice (show cause/enquiry), is illegal and liable to be quashed, regardless of the availability of an alternative remedy.

Subject

Service Law - Transfer

Act Referred

Tripura Gramin Bank (Officers and Employees) Service Regulations, 2010: Reg.74(1), Reg.39, Reg.49
Constitution of India: Art.226

Headnote

(A) Service Law - Transfer - Punitive Transfer - An order of transfer that contains aspersions on the efficiency, behavior, and skill of an employee, and is passed in lieu of punishment without a prior enquiry or show cause notice, is illegal and arbitrary. (Para 13, 15)

(B) Principles of Natural Justice - Right to be heard - Issuance of a transfer order based on allegations of misbehavior without providing the employee an opportunity to explain the conduct constitutes a gross violation of natural justice. (Para 13)

(C) Writ Jurisdiction - Alternative Remedy - The existence of an alternative remedy under a statutory scheme is a rule of prudence and not an absolute bar to the exercise of jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution. (Para 16)

Issues: Whether the transfer order was punitive in nature and passed in violation of the principles of natural justice.

Result: Writ petition allowed; transfer order quashed.

Legal Category Hierarchy

  • administrative law
    • service law
    • principles of natural justice (Para 13, 15)
  • practice and procedure
    • writ jurisdiction (Para 10, 16)

Advocates:
For the Appellants/Petitioners: P. Roy Barman, Kawsik Nath
For the Respondents: Prabir Saha

Table of Contents

1. Employee challenged a transfer order issued following alleged unprofessional conduct toward a customer, contending the transfer was punitive and lacked prior inquiry or natural justice. (Para 1 , 3 , 4 )

2. The petitioner contended the transfer was illegal and punitive without an inquiry, while the respondent argued the transfer was a routine administrative exigency due to professional misconduct. (Para 7 , 9 , 10 , 11 )

3. The court observed that the transfer was punitive in nature, lacked adherence to natural justice, and the alleged misconduct remained unsubstantiated, rendering the order arbitrary and illegal. (Para 13 , 14 , 15 )

4. A transfer order passed in lieu of punishment without following natural justice or establishing the underlying allegations is illegal and liable to be set aside. (Para 8 , 15 )

5. The transfer order is quashed, and the respondents are directed to restore the petitioner to his original posting and regularize his absence. (Para 17 )

6. Does the availability of an alternative statutory remedy for a service grievance bar a High Court from exercising jurisdiction under Article 226?

No, the rule of exclusion is one of prudence and not compulsion. Where a writ petition is already entertained, pleadings completed, and the matter heard on merits, relegating the petitioner to an alternative forum would defeat the ends of justice. (Para 16 )

7. Can a transfer order issued in guise of administrative exigency be quashed if it is found to be punitive?

Yes. When a transfer order is passed in lieu of punishment for alleged misconduct without following the principles of natural justice—such as issuing a show cause notice or conducting an inquiry—it is considered malicious in law and illegal. (Para 8 , 13 , 15 )

JUDGMENT & ORDER

The petitioner has filed this petition challenging the transfer order dated 09.09.2026 issued by the Chairman of Tripura Gramin Bank, Agartala.

[2] Though in this writ petition, no counter affidavit is submitted from the side of respondents but they have submitted 2 (two) nos. of detailed affidavit-in-opposition in the connected stay matter divulging their entire defence. Accordingly, both the parties were heard at length on the merit of the writ petition.

[3] The petitioner was promoted to the post of Chief Manager, Scale IV on 01.04.2025 and was posted at Tripura Gramin Bank, Agartala Branch w.e.f. 01.07.2025. On 09.09.2026, an order of transfer has been issued by the Chairman of the Bank on the ground that on 26.08.2026, indifferent attitude and poor customer service was provided to one Senior Executive of the State Government by him which was a serious departure from the standards of courtesy, promptness and professionalism and considering that lapses and in view of the interest of public and Bank’s administrative exigencies, he has been transferred to Poangbari Branch with immediate effect. He has been also directed to join his new place of posting forthwith without availing joining time.

[4] On the following day i.e. on 10.09.2026, the petitioner submitted a representation to the Chairman, Tripura Gramin Bank disclosing that on 26.08.2026, one customer namely, Tapas Roy, Secretary to the State of Tripura visited Bank branch asking for a personalized cheque book in relation to a joint account of himself and his son. Then he politely informed him that it will take time as the cheque book is required to be printed and posted to his home address from outside the State and he also entered the said requisition of personalized cheque book in CBS at that moment but said customer was not satisfied and insisted for immediate delivery of such cheque book. The KYC documents of his son as was submitted by him was also not having signatures of his major son and therefore, the petitioner informed him that such KYC documents are required to be attested and signed by the person concerned but the said gentleman said that he being father would sign the said documents. The petitioner then replied that if requires, he would send staff from his Bank branch for obtaining signature of his son from his house and he never misbehaved with him. Therefore, he requested for revoking said transfer order. Thereafter on 14.09.2026, a show cause notice was issued to him on that ground asking him to show cause in writing as to why disciplinary action should not be initiated against him.

[5] He submitted his reply to said show cause notice on 18.09.2026 denying the allegations and asserting that insistence for compliance with KYC requirements cannot constitute indifferent behavior and the customer was dealt with politely and with courtesy. It is also stated by him that compliance with banking requirement is also obligatory on his part which cannot be diluted at the customers’ request.

[6] The Bank authority in their counter affidavit has asserted that after promotion to the post of Chief Manager, it was noticed that the attitude of the petitioner became unprofessional towards customer services and he was verbally cautioned to rectify himself in this regard and on 26.08.2026, he misbehaved with said Secretary of Labour Department, Government of Tripura and failed to provide customer service towards a customer like a Senior Executive of the State Government and therefore, exercising the power under the provision of Section 74(1) of the Tripura Gramin Bank (Officers and Employees) Service Regulations, 2010 and considering administrative exigency he was transferred as such. It is also stated that it has been the Bank’s policy that misbehavior/rude behavior with customers shall be treated with zero tolerance and immediate action will be taken. It is further stated that since the petitioner failed to provide banking service towards the customers

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top