[1] Kes ini telah diputuskan oleh Pengerusi Mahkamah Perusahaan yang mendengar kes ini pada 4 Julai 2005 melalui Award No. 1299 tahun 2005 . Di dalam Award tersebut telah diperintahkan seperti berikut:

55. The company is ordered to reinstate the claimant as a machine operator in Roll Mill with effect from 1 August 2005 at a basic salary and on terms that he should be receiving on that date had he not been terminated from employment on 6 August 1999. And his service will be treated as being continuous from that date he commenced employment with the company, that is, 3 March 1983. Should the claimant fail to report for duty with the company on the designated date of 1 August 2005, this reinstatement order will lapse and he will thereafter lose this benefit of reinstatement.

56. The court further orders, independent of the order on reinstatement, that the company pays the claimant backwages to the sum of RM57,120 less statutory deductions if any, not later than 45 days from the date of this award.

[2] Pihak responden syarikat telah memfailkan semakan kehakiman terhadap Award tersebut. Pada 4 Ogos 2009, Y.A. Hakim Mahkamah Tinggi Malaya di Kuala Lumpur telah mengeluarkan satu perintah cer