1. Dispute over grant of Letters of Administration for intestate estate between two daughters. (Para 1 , 2 , 3 , 5 )
2026 MarsdenLR 112531
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MALAYA AT KUALA LUMPUR
NIXON ANAK KENNEDY KUMBONG, JC
NORSURIA BINTI MAT NURDIN – Appellant
Versus
SARAH BINTI MAT NURDIN – Respondent
ORIGINATING SUMMONS NO. WA-31NCvC-3594-12/2025
Important Points
Subject
Civil Law - Probate and Administration
Act Referred
Headnote
(B) Administration - Grant of - Co-administrators - Where both parties are children and beneficiaries of the deceased, they qualify as 'persons interested in the estate' under Section 30 - A court may grant administration to co-administrators to protect the interests of all beneficiaries and to enable cooperation in administering the estate in accordance with the faraid certificate - The court may limit the grant in any way it thinks fit to manage disputes and conflicts of interest. (Paras 23, 37-39)
(C) Administration - Grant of - Special circumstances - Hostility and friction between family members alone are insufficient to exclude a beneficiary from administration - The test is the due and proper administration of the estate, not personal preferences or family dynamics - Allegations of fraud, undue influence, or conflict of interest must be proven and have crystallised into misconduct or legal disqualification to constitute 'special circumstances' excluding a person from administration. (Paras 30-32)
Facts of the case:
The Applicant and the Objector are both daughters of the deceased, who died intestate. Two other siblings waived their right to administer the estate. The Applicant sought appointment as the sole Administrator. The Objector resisted, seeking appointment as co-administrator based on a hibah (gift) of a property to her minor children, which was confirmed by the Syariah High Court. The Applicant challenged the hibah's validity, raising allegations of fraud, undue influence, conflict of interest, and the Objector's improper handling of the deceased's finances. The main question was whether the Applicant alone, or jointly with the Objector, should be appointed as Administrators.
Findings of Court:
The Court held that both the Applicant and Objector are 'persons interested in the estate' under Section 30. The Court found that the Applicant had not established 'special circumstances' to exclude the Objector entirely from administration. The allegations, while serious, remained unproven allegations and did not amount to judicial findings of disqualification. The hibah and the Syariah judgment stood as subsisting instruments. To manage the conflict of interest regarding the hibah property, the Court ordered a limited grant: the Applicant as the general Administrator and the Objector as co-administrator limited to matters relating to the hibah property.
Issues: The main issues were whether the Applicant alone, or jointly with the Objector, ought to be appointed as Administrators, having regard to Section 30 of the Probate and Administration Act 1959; and whether there were special circumstances to exclude the Objector from administration due to allegations of conflict of interest, fraud, and improper conduct.
Ratio Decidendi: The court ruled that a party seeking to exclude a sibling of equal standing from administration bears the burden of demonstrating 'special circumstances' sufficiently compelling to justify the exclusion. Contested allegations that have not been proven or resulted in a finding of legal disqualification do not constitute such special circumstances. The court may manage conflicts of interest by limiting the grant of administration to specific assets or roles, thereby protecting all beneficiaries' interests.
Result: Letters of Administration granted to the Applicant as Administrator generally, and to the Objector as co-administrator limited to matters relating to the hibah property. Costs in the estate. (Paras 46-51)
Legal Category Hierarchy
- practice and procedure
- property law
- family law
For the Applicant: Solicitor: Farah Irina Binti Khairi Izwan
Farah, Farhana & Company
For the Objector/Aggrieved: Solicitor: Hirasini Mahadran
Yahya Anne Associates
Table of Contents
2. Applicant seeks sole appointment alleging fraud and unsuitability; Objector seeks co-administration based on confirmed hibah. (Para 4 , 6 , 9 , 10 , 11 , 12 , 13 , 14 , 15 , 16 , 17 , 18 )
3. Letters of Administration granted to applicant as general administrator and objector as co-administrator limited to hibah property. (Para 45 , 46 , 47 , 48 , 49 , 50 , 51 , 54 )
4. Under Section 30 of the Probate and Administration Act 1959, what is the default rule for grant of administration to persons interested in the estate?
Administration shall be granted to some one or more persons interested in the residuary estate unless insolvency or special circumstances justify departure. (Para 7 , 8 , 21 , 23 , 24 )
5. What constitutes 'special circumstances' sufficient to exclude a person interested from administration?
Unproven allegations of fraud or conflict do not constitute special circumstances; clear and cogent justification is required. (Para 19 , 20 , 25 , 26 , 30 , 31 , 32 )
6. Can the court limit a grant of administration to specific assets to manage conflict of interest?
Yes, under Section 30 administration may be limited in any way the court thinks fit, including co-administration limited to a specific property. (Para 22 , 33 , 34 , 35 , 36 , 37 , 38 , 39 , 40 , 41 , 42 , 43 , 44 )
7. What is the relevance of a Syariah Court confirmation of a hibah in civil administration proceedings?
The confirmed hibah stands as a subsisting instrument; the civil court cannot disregard it until successfully challenged in Syariah Court. (Para 9 , 10 , 27 , 28 )
JUDGMENT
Introduction
1. This is my decision on the Applicant’s Originating Summons dated 10.12.2025 for the grant of Letters of Administration in respect of the estate of the late Habibah binti Abu Bakar, who passed away on 20.7.2024.
2. The Applicant and the Objector are both daughters of the deceased.Two other siblings, Irfan Nurdin bin Mat Nurdin and Izzy Peter Nurdin, have filed Afidavit Penolakan waiving their right to administer the estate pursuant to Order 71 rule 31 of the Rules of Court 2012.
3. The dispute before this Court does not concern whether a grant of Letters of Administration ought to issue — that much is uncontroversial. The real question is to whom, and on what terms such authority should properly be entrusted. The Applicant seeks appointment as the sole Administrator of the estate.
4. The Objector resists this and instead presses for her own appointment as co-administrator, grounding her position principally on the status of a particular property which she asserts had been transferred by way of hibah to her minor children.
5. The Objector’s case is anchored on a Surat Ikatan Hibah & Amanah dated 16.2.2022, under which the deceased, as registered proprietor of a double-storey terrace house at No. 2, Jalan USJ 6/6L, Subang Jaya, is said to have gifted “the entire Hibah Property including all proceeds and income therefrom” to the Objector’s four children, with the Objector named as trustee.
6. The Applicant, on the other hand, challenges the hibah’s validity and raises serious allegations touching on fraud, undue influence, conflict of interest and the Objector’s handling of the deceased’s finances.
7. The question that ultimately matters is this: whether the Applicant alone, or jointly with the Objector, ought to be appointed as Administrators of the deceased’s estate, having regard to section 30 of the Probate and Administration Act 1959 and the authorities.
The statutory framework
Section 30 of the Probate and Administration Act 1959 provides: “In granting administration the Court shall have regard to the rights of all persons interested in the estate of the deceased person or in the proceeds of sale thereof… Provided that, where the deceased died wholly intestate as to his estate, administration shall, if application is made for the purpose, be granted to some one or more of the persons interested in the residuary estate of the deceased, unless by reason of the insolvency of the estate or other special circumstances the Court thinks it expedient to grant administration to some other person.”
Order 71 rule 5 of the Rules of Court 2012 requires, among others, that the originating summons state “whether, and if so, in what manner all persons having a prior right to a grant have been cleared off, and whether any minority or life interest arises under the will or intestacy.”
8. Once objections are filed, the matter ceases to be purely non-contentious. The Court’s discretion under section 30 is engaged in a real, practical way: it must decide who should administer, in a manner that protects the rights of all persons interested in the estate and promotes expeditious and economical administration.
The competing narratives
The Objector’s position
9. The Objector’s written submissions emphasise that the hibah property has already been gifted to her children, and that the deceased’s intention has been confirmed by the Syariah High Court in Shah Alam on 24.8.2022.
10. She points to paragraphs 6 and 8 of the Surat Ikatan Hibah &Amanah, where the deceased undertook not to transfer or change the name of the hibah property without the written consent of the trustee and/or the hibah recipients, and further undertook that upon her death, “waris-waris beliau yang lain tidak berhak untuk menuntut atau memiliki Harta Hibah tersebut”.
11. The Objector also relies on the Syariah High Court’s judgment sealing the hibah, in which the deceased personally appeared before the Syarie Judge and the hibah was confirmed as valid and in accordance with