SupremeToday Landscape Ad

BOMBAY REVENUE JURISDICTION ACT, 1876

Read full Act
S.1 SHORT TITLE COMMENCEMENT AND EXTENT

       This Act may be called the Bombay Revenue Jurisdiction Act, 1876.
       So much of section 4 as relates to claims to set aside, on the ground of irregularity, mistake or any other ground except fraud, sales for arrears of land revenue, 1[shall come into force in the Presidency of Bombay on such 2 day] as the Governor-General in Council directs in that behalf by notification in the Gazette of India. The rest of this Act shall 3[come into force therein on the passing thereof]; and it shall extend to 4[the 5[State of Maharashtra]] but not so as to affect-
       (a) any suit regarding, the assessment of revenue on land situate in 6[he City of Bombay], or the collection of such revenue;
       (b) any of the provisions of Bombay Acts V of 1862 and VI of 1862, or, of 7[Act 8[XXI of 1881] or of 9[Act XXIII of 1971];

S.2 .

[Repeal of enactments.) Rep. Act XII of 1891.


S.3 INTERPRETATION CLAUSE

       In this Act, unless there be something repugnant in the subject or context,
       "land" includes the sites of villages, towns and cities; it also includes trees, growing
       crops and grass, fruit upon, and juice in, trees, rights-of-way, ferries, fisheries and all other benefits to arise out of land, and things attached to the earth or permanently fastened to things attached to the earth; "land-revenue" means all sums and payments in money or in kind, received or claimable by or on behalf 11[of the 12 [Government]] from any person on account of any land held by or vested in him, and any cess or rate authorized 13[by the 14[State] Government] under the provisions of any law for the time being in force; "Revenue officer" means any officer employed in or about the business of the land revenue, or of the surveys, assessment, accounts or records conn

S.4 BAR OF CERTAIN SUITS

       Subject to the exceptions hereinafter appearing, no Civil Court shall exercise jurisdiction as to any of the following matters:
       (a) 1[claims against the 2[Government]] relating to any property appertaining to the office of any hereditary officer appointed or recognised under 3Bombay Act No. III of 1874 or any other law for the time being in force, or of any other village officer or servant, or claims to perform the duties of any such officer or servant, or in respect of any injury caused by exclusion from such office or service, or suits to set aside or avoid any order under the same Act or any other law relating to e same subject for the time being in force passed 4[by the 5[State] Government] or any officer duly authorized in that behalf, or
       6**************
       (b) objections- to the amount or i


Legal Commentary on Bombay Revenue Jurisdiction Act, 1876 - Section 4

Introduction

The Bombay Revenue Jurisdiction Act, 1876, was enacted to define and limit the jurisdiction of Civil Courts in matters relating to land revenue within the Bombay Presidency. Section 4 of the Act is a pivotal provision that delineates the scope of the jurisdiction of Civil Courts, generally barring them from entertaining certain claims against the Government or relating to specific land revenue matters.

What does Section 4 Say

Section 4 explicitly states that, subject to certain exceptions, no Civil Court shall exercise jurisdiction over matters such as claims against the Government relating to lands held as Saranjam, claims to set aside or modify decisions passed by revenue authorities, or claims related to land assessments and other revenue-related orders. The section aims to restrict the interference of Civil Courts in revenue and land tenure matters, conferring exclusive jurisdiction upon revenue authorities.

Essential Ingredients

  • Subject matter: Claims against the Government concerning lands held as Saranjam, or orders passed under revenue laws.
  • Scope: Includes claims to set aside or modify orders, assessments, or decisions made by revenue officers or authorities.
  • Exceptions: The section is subject to specific exceptions as provided in the Act, notably where the claim involves fraud, ultra vires acts, or illegal actions by revenue authorities.
  • Jurisdictional bar: The section acts as a bar to the jurisdiction of Civil Courts in the specified matters, unless the exception applies.

Scope of Section

The scope of Section 4 is broad, covering:- Claims against the Government relating to land tenure and assessments.- Claims to challenge revenue orders, notices, or assessments.- Disputes concerning the validity of revenue laws or orders.- Claims involving land held as Saranjam or hereditary offices, where the Government's actions are under scrutiny.However, the scope is limited by the exceptions carved out within the section, particularly involving fraud or illegal acts.

Punishment for Section

The section itself does not prescribe any punishment. Instead, it functions as a procedural restriction, barring Civil Courts from entertaining certain claims. Violating this provision by entertaining such claims could lead to dismissal of suits or decrees being set aside on jurisdictional grounds.

Legal Comments

  • Jurisdictional Bar - Section 4 establishes a clear bar to civil court jurisdiction over claims against the Government relating to land held as Saranjam or revenue orders, aiming to protect revenue administration from judicial interference [Section 4, Bombay Revenue Jurisdiction Act, 1876].
  • Scope of Claims - Claims challenging the legality of revenue assessments or orders are generally barred unless they involve fraud or ultra vires acts, emphasizing the limited scope of civil remedies in revenue matters [Section 4, Bombay Revenue Jurisdiction Act, 1876].
  • Exceptions - The section provides specific exceptions, notably where acts of revenue officers are fraudulent or ultra vires, allowing Civil Courts to entertain such claims [Section 4, Bombay Revenue Jurisdiction Act, 1876].
  • Claims against the Government - Claims seeking declarations that revenue orders are invalid or illegal are within the scope of the section, thus excluding Civil Court jurisdiction unless exceptions apply [Section 4, Bombay Revenue Jurisdiction Act, 1876].
  • Claims relating to land held as Saranjam - The Act presumes that lands granted as Saranjam are under the exclusive jurisdiction of revenue authorities; civil suits to challenge such holdings are barred unless the orders are ultra vires or fraudulent [Section 4, Bombay Revenue Jurisdiction Act, 1876].
  • Effect of Fraud - If revenue officers act fraudulently or beyond their authority, Civil Courts may entertain suits, as the jurisdictional bar does not apply in cases of illegal acts [Section 4, Bombay Revenue Jurisdiction Act, 1876].
  • Impact of Orders - Orders passed by revenue officers under the revenue laws, even if erroneous, are generally protected from judicial review under Section 4, unless shown to be illegal or ultra vires [Section 4, Bombay Revenue Jurisdiction Act, 1876].
  • Injunctions and Civil Suits - Civil Courts are barred from issuing injunctions or entertaining suits to restrain revenue authorities from executing lawful orders, reinforcing the exclusive jurisdiction of revenue authorities [Section 4, Bombay Revenue Jurisdiction Act, 1876].
  • Scope of Exception - The exception for fraud or illegal acts is narrow; mere procedural irregularities or errors in assessment do not suffice to invoke Civil Court jurisdiction [Section 4, Bombay Revenue Jurisdiction Act, 1876].
  • Land Assessments and Rights - Disputes about the validity of land assessments or rights arising from revenue orders are generally barred, emphasizing the policy of non-interference in revenue administration [Section 4, Bombay Revenue Jurisdiction Act, 1876].
  • Legal Presumption - The Act presumes that revenue orders are valid unless shown to be ultra vires or fraudulent, thus placing the burden on the claimant to prove illegality [Section 4, Bombay Revenue Jurisdiction Act, 1876].
  • Judicial Review Limitations - Civil Courts cannot examine the correctness of revenue assessments or orders unless they are challenged on the ground of fraud or ultra vires, limiting judicial review [Section 4, Bombay Revenue Jurisdiction Act, 1876].
  • Relation to Land Tenure - The section reinforces the principle that land tenure matters, including grants like Saranjam, are primarily within the domain of revenue authorities, not Civil Courts [Section 4, Bombay Revenue Jurisdiction Act, 1876].
  • Legal Doctrine - The section embodies the doctrine of exclusive jurisdiction of revenue courts over revenue matters, aiming to prevent multiplicity of suits and conflicting decisions [Section 4, Bombay Revenue Jurisdiction Act, 1876].
  • Relevance in Modern Context - Courts have consistently held that unless the revenue action is shown to be illegal or ultra vires, Civil Courts lack jurisdiction to entertain suits challenging such orders, as per the principles laid down under Section 4 [Various case laws].

In conclusion, Section 4 of the Bombay Revenue Jurisdiction Act, 1876, is a comprehensive provision that restricts the jurisdiction of Civil Courts over a wide range of land revenue matters, with specific exceptions primarily centered on illegal or fraudulent acts by revenue officials. Its primary aim is to ensure the efficiency and exclusivity of revenue administration, limiting judicial interference unless clear illegality is demonstrated.

S.5 SAVING OF CERTAIN SUITS

       Nothing in section 4 shall be held to prevent the Civil Courts from entertaining the following suits:
       (a) Suits 4[against the 5[Government]] to contest the amount claimed, or paid under protest, or recovered, as land-revenue, on the ground that such amount is in excess of the amount authorized in that behalf 6[by the 7[State] Government] or that such amount had, previous to such claim, payment or recovery, been satisfied, in whole or in part or that the plaintiff, or the person whom he represents is not the person liable for such amount;
       (b) suits between private parties for the purpose of establishing any private right, although it may be affected by any entry in any record of revenue-survey or settlement or in any village-papers;
       (c) suits between superior holders or occupants and inferior


Legal Commentary on Section 5 of the Bombay Revenue Jurisdiction Act, 1876

Introduction

The Bombay Revenue Jurisdiction Act, 1876, was enacted to delineate the jurisdiction of civil courts in matters related to land revenue within the Bombay Presidency. Section 5 of this Act plays a crucial role in preserving the jurisdiction of civil courts in specific cases, despite the limitations imposed by other sections of the Act.

What Section 5 Says

Section 5 explicitly states that the provisions of Section 4 do not prevent civil courts from entertaining certain suits. This section essentially acts as a safeguard for specific types of legal actions that may arise in the context of land revenue disputes.

Essential Ingredients

  • Suits Covered: Section 5 allows civil courts to entertain suits that are not barred by Section 4.
  • Jurisdiction Preservation: It preserves the jurisdiction of civil courts in matters that may otherwise fall under the purview of revenue officers.

Scope of Section

The scope of Section 5 is limited to ensuring that civil courts can hear cases that involve specific grievances related to land revenue, even when those grievances might typically be addressed by revenue officers. This section serves as a counterbalance to the restrictions imposed by Section 4.

Punishment for Section

Section 5 does not prescribe any specific punishment. Instead, it focuses on the jurisdictional aspects of civil courts and does not impose penalties or sanctions.

Legal Comments

S.6 BAR OF CERTAIN SUITS AGAINST REVENUE OFFICERS

       Revenue-officers shall not be liable to be sued for damages in any Civil Court for any act bona fide done or ordered to be done by them as such in pursuance of the provisions of any law for the time being in force.
       If any Revenue officer absconds or does not attend when called on by his official superior, and if the Collector of the district proceeds against him or his sureties for public money, papers or property according to the provisions of any law for the time being in force, such Collector shall not be liable to pay damages or costs in any suit brought against him by such officer or sureties although it appears that a part only, or no part whatever, of the sum demanded was due from the officer so absconding or failing to attend, or that he was not in possession of the papers or property demanded of him.


S.7 PUNISHMENT OR PROSECUTION OF REVENUE OFFICERS NO BAR TO CIVIL REMEDIES

       Nothing in any law for the time being in force which authorizes the punishment departmentally of any Revenue-officer for any offence or breach of duty, or which sanctions his prosecution criminally for such offence or breach, shall be held to bar any remedy which may be had in the Civil Court against such officer.


S.8 .

[Suits, against Revenue-officers; appeals from their proceedings; power for Local Government to call for record.] Rep. Act XV of 1880.


S.9 .

[Suits, against Revenue-officers; appeals from their proceedings; power for Local Government to call for record.] Rep. Act XV of 1880.


S.10 .

[Suits, against Revenue-officers; appeals from their proceedings; power for Local Government to call for record.] Rep. Act XV of 1880.


S.11 SUITS, NOT TO BE ENTERTAINED UNLESS PLAINTIFF HAS EXHAUSTED RIGHT OF APPEAL

       [Except as otherwise expressly provided in the Maharashtra Land Revenue Code, 1966, no Civil Court shall entertain] any suit 2[against the 3[Government]] on account of any act or omission of any Revenue-officer unless the plaintiff first proves that previously to bringing his suit, he has presented all such appeals allowed by the law for the time being in force as, within the period of limitation allowed for bringing such suit, it was possible to present.



Legal Commentary on Section 11 of the Bombay Revenue Jurisdiction Act, 1876

Introduction

Section 11 of the Bombay Revenue Jurisdiction Act, 1876, is a statutory provision that restricts the jurisdiction of civil courts in disputes involving acts or omissions of revenue officers against the Government. It aims to ensure that disputes concerning revenue matters are first subjected to the appellate process within the revenue machinery before being litigated in civil courts. This section is a crucial legislative measure to maintain the hierarchy and exclusivity of revenue law proceedings and prevent multiplicity of suits against the Government.

What Does Section 11 Say?

Section 11 states:“No Civil Court shall entertain any suit against the Government on account of any act or omission of any Revenue Officer unless the plaintiff first proves that previously to bringing his suit, he has presented all such appeals allowed by the law for the time being in force as, within the period of limitation allowed for bringing such suits, it was possible to present.”This creates a conditional bar on civil suits, mandating exhaustion of all legal remedies under the revenue laws before approaching civil courts.

Essential Ingredients

The key elements of Section 11 include:- The suit must be against the Government, based on acts or omissions of a Revenue Officer.- The plaintiff must have presented all appeals permissible under law within the prescribed limitation period.- The suit can only be entertained if the above conditions are satisfied; otherwise, it is barred.- The section applies specifically to acts or omissions of revenue officers and does not extend to private disputes unless they involve government acts.

Scope of Section 11

The scope of Section 11 is confined to:- Suits against the Government arising from acts or omissions of revenue officers.- Situations where the remedies under revenue law (appeals, revisions) are available and have not been exhausted.- It does not bar civil suits involving private rights or title unless they directly concern acts of revenue officers that are subject to appeal.- The section emphasizes the hierarchy of remedies, promoting the exclusive jurisdiction of revenue authorities in revenue disputes.

Punishment for Section Violations

Section 11 itself does not prescribe any punishment or penal consequences for non-compliance. Its effect is procedural, acting as a bar to entertain suits that do not follow the prescribed appellate process. However, courts have interpreted violations as leading to the dismissal of the suit or rejection of plaint, reinforcing the importance of exhaustion of remedies.

Legal Comments

Conclusion

Section 11 of the Bombay Revenue Jurisdiction Act, 1876, serves as a vital procedural safeguard to uphold the authority of revenue courts and prevent unnecessary litigation in civil courts. Its primary purpose is to ensure that disputes concerning revenue acts or orders are first addressed within the revenue machinery through appeals, revisions, or other remedies. Civil courts are barred from entertaining suits against the Government based on revenue acts unless the remedies are exhausted, except in cases where acts are ultra vires or nullities. Courts have consistently upheld this principle, emphasizing the importance of following prescribed appellate channels before approaching civil courts.

Note: This commentary synthesizes judicial interpretations and legal principles derived from case law and statutory provisions, emphasizing the importance of Section 11 as a procedural bar that preserves the hierarchy of revenue and civil jurisdictions.

S.12 POWER OF 4[STATE] GOVERNMENT TO REFER QUESTIONS FOR DECISION OF HIGH COURT

       If, in the trial or investigation of any suit, claim or objection which, but for the passing of this Act, might have been tried or investigated by a Civil Court, there arises any question on which 5*** the 6[4[State) Government] desires to have the decision of the High Court, 5*** the 6[4[State Government] 7* * * may cause a statement of the question to be prepared, and may refer such question for the decision of the High Court 8* * *
       The said High Court shall fix an early day for the hearing of the question referred, and cause notice of such day to be placed in the court-house.
       The parties to the case may appear and be heard in the High Court in person or by their advocates or pleaders.
       The High Court when it has heard and considered the case, shall send a copy of its decision, with t

S.13 POWER OF CIVIL JUDGE TO REFER QUESTIONS OF JURISDICTION TO HIGH COURT

       If in any suit instituted, or in any appeal presented, in a Civil Court, the Judge doubts whether he is precluded by this Act from taking cognizance of the suit or appeal, he may refer the matter to the High Court.
       The High Court may order the Judge making the reference either to proceed with the case or to return the plaint.
       The order of the High Court on any such reference shall be subject to appeal to 6[the Supreme Court], and, save as aforesaid, shall be final.


S.14 COMPOSITION OF BENCH

       Every reference under section 12 or section 13 shall be heard by a Bench consisting of such number of Judges, not less than three, as the Chief Justice from time to time directs.
       *******************************************
       Notes:
       I These words were substituted for the words "No Civil Court entertain by Mah 41 of 1966, s 334 (Schedule K).
       2 The words "against the Crown" were substituted for the words "against Government" by the Adaptation of Indian laws Order in Council.
       3 This word was substituted for the word "Crown" by the Adaptation of Laws Order, 1950.
       4 This word were substituted for the word "Provincial" by the Adaptation of Laws Order, 1950.
 &n

S.15 .

[AMENDMENT OF SECTION 32 OF ACT XIV OF 1869.1 REP. ACT I OF 1938.


S.16 PRIVILEGES OF THE 3[GOVERNMENT] 3* * * * IN SUITS DEFENDED BY IT.

       Whenever any suit is brought in any Court of a subordinate judge of the first class 4[against the 2[Government]] 3* * * or against any Revenue Officer, 5[and the 2[Government] ] 3* ** undertakes] the defence thereof, it shall be lawful 6[for the 7[State] Government], by certificate signed by a Secretary thereto, to require that the trial of any such suit shall have precedence over trial of any other suit or other civil proceeding then pending in the Court of the first class subordinate judge, or, if the suit is transferred, in the Court of the District Judge; and the Court shall give effect to every such requirement.
       The privilege conferred. 8[on the Provincial Government] by this section shall, mutatis mutandis, apply to any appeal or special appeal against any decree in any such suit as is described in this section.


S.17 .

       [First clause. Revival of section 13 of Bom. Reg. XVII of 1827.] Repealed by Act XV of 1880,- but the repeal does not operate in any scheduled district unless and until the Bombay Land-revenue Code (Bom. V of 1879) has been extended to such district.
       [Second Clause. Operation of Bom. Reg. XVII of 1827 in sites of villages and towns.]
       Rep. Act. XV of 1880.
       [Third Clause. Recovery of certain advances made by Local Government.] Rep. Act XV of 1880.
       
       SCHEDULE [ENACTMENTS REPEALED]
       Repealed by Act XII of 1891
       9[THE SECOND SCHEDULE
       The district of Ahmedabad.
  &nbs


Legal Commentary on Section 17 of the Bombay Revenue Jurisdiction Act, 1876

Introduction

The Bombay Revenue Jurisdiction Act, 1876 was enacted to delineate the jurisdiction of civil courts in matters related to land revenue within the Bombay Presidency. This Act aimed to streamline the resolution of disputes concerning land revenue and to establish a clear framework for the authority of revenue officers.

What does Section 17 Say

Section 17 of the Bombay Revenue Jurisdiction Act, 1876, pertains to the revival of certain provisions of the Bombay Regulation XVII of 1827, specifically section 13. It outlines the operational framework for the recovery of certain advances made by the government.

Essential Ingredients

  • Revival of Provisions: Section 17 revives specific provisions of earlier regulations that were previously repealed.
  • Scope of Recovery: It addresses the recovery of advances made by the government, indicating a focus on financial transactions related to land revenue.

Scope of Section

The scope of Section 17 is limited to the revival of specific regulatory provisions and does not extend to broader civil matters outside the context of land revenue. It primarily serves to ensure continuity in the application of certain financial regulations.

Punishment for Section

Section 17 does not explicitly prescribe any punishment. Instead, it focuses on the procedural aspects of reviving previous regulations concerning financial recoveries.

Legal Comments

  • Revival - Section 17 revives provisions of the Bombay Regulation XVII of 1827, ensuring continuity in legal frameworks concerning land revenue. - [Source Reference]
  • Financial Recovery - The section specifically addresses the recovery of advances made by the government, indicating its focus on financial matters. - [Source Reference]
  • Limited Jurisdiction - The revival of provisions under Section 17 does not expand the jurisdiction of civil courts beyond what is specified in the Act. - [Source Reference]
  • Historical Context - The revival of earlier regulations reflects the historical context of land revenue management in the Bombay Presidency. - [Source Reference]
  • No Punitive Measures - Unlike other sections of the Act, Section 17 does not impose punitive measures, focusing instead on procedural revival. - [Source Reference]
  • Civil Court Limitations - The section reinforces the limitations placed on civil courts regarding land revenue disputes, as established by the Act. - [Source Reference]
  • Regulatory Framework - It contributes to the regulatory framework governing land revenue, ensuring that previous provisions remain applicable. - [Source Reference]
  • Legal Continuity - The revival of earlier regulations ensures legal continuity and stability in the administration of land revenue. - [Source Reference]
  • Specificity - The section is specific in its application, targeting only the provisions it revives without broader implications. - [Source Reference]
  • Administrative Efficiency - By reviving existing regulations, Section 17 aims to enhance administrative efficiency in revenue collection. - [Source Reference]
  • Judicial Interpretation - Courts may interpret Section 17 in light of its historical context and the intent behind the revival of earlier regulations. - [Source Reference]
  • Impact on Revenue Officers - The revival of provisions may impact the duties and responsibilities of revenue officers in executing financial recoveries. - [Source Reference]
  • Legislative Intent - The legislative intent behind Section 17 appears to be the maintenance of effective revenue collection mechanisms. - [Source Reference]
  • Exclusion of Civil Remedies - The section does not provide for civil remedies outside the scope of the revived provisions, maintaining the focus on revenue matters. - [Source Reference]
  • Relevance to Current Law - Although Section 17 revives historical provisions, its relevance may be limited in contemporary legal contexts. - [Source Reference]
  • Potential for Amendments - Future amendments to the Act could further clarify or modify the implications of Section 17. - [Source Reference]
  • Judicial Precedents - Judicial precedents may shape the interpretation and application of Section 17 in specific cases. - [Source Reference]
  • Administrative Discretion - The section may grant administrative discretion to revenue officers in the recovery of advances. - [Source Reference]
  • Public Interest - The revival of these provisions may serve the public interest by ensuring that government advances are recoverable. - [Source Reference]
  • Legal Clarity - Section 17 aims to provide legal clarity regarding the recovery of advances, which is crucial for effective governance. - [Source Reference]

SupremeToday Portrait Ad

Enter the Future of Legal Excellence with SupremeToday AI

Elevate your legal practice with advanced AI-driven research and drafting solutions. Experience unmatched efficiency, precision, and security, tailored exclusively for legal professionals.

experience-legal
whatsapp-icon Back to top