The Gauhati High Court has dismissed a petition filed by Renu Dangoria, who challenged the rejection of her technical bid for an India Made Foreign Liquor (IMFL) retail license in Tinsukia, Assam. The court ruled that the Bid Scrutiny Committee acted within its authority by disqualifying the applicant, as the site plan submitted with her proposal was prepared by an architect rather than an engineer. This decision affirms that the failure to adhere to specific technical requirements stipulated in a Notice Inviting Tender (NIT) provides legitimate grounds for the rejection of a bid during the technical evaluation phase.

The dispute arose following the issuance of an NIT on January 4, 2025, for the settlement of an IMFL Retail Off License for shop TSK 1, located at Dirak Chariali in the Sadiya Sub-Division. During the scrutiny process, the committee identified that the site plan provided by the petitioner lacked the necessary certification from an engineer—a condition clearly outlined in the “Checklist of Bidder Eligibility Criteria” contained in Annexure-C of the tender documentation. Consequently, the bid from the petitioner was rejected, while the bid from MPD Services, the private respondent, was accepted.

Challenging this decision, the petitioner argued that the certification requirement was not an essential condition of the tender. Her counsel contended that Clause 6 of the tender document, which defines the documents comprising the technical bid, did not explicitly reference Annexure-C, implying that the checklist might be supplemental rather than mandatory. Furthermore, the petitioner argued that the site plan provided, having been prepared by a qualified architect, satisfied the underlying purpose of the tender requirement. Additionally, the petitioner challenged the acceptance of the successful bidder, alleging that the respondent had failed to upload the required checklist online, producing it only in hard copy in violation of the submission procedures outlined in Clause 10.

The Excise Department and the representative for MPD Services countered these arguments by asserting that Annexure-C constitutes an integral part of the bid document and explicitly lists the certification of the site plan by an engineer as a requirement for bidder eligibility. They maintained that the rejection was a direct result of the petitioner’s failure to satisfy a substantive condition rather than a mere procedural technicality.

In the judgment delivered by Justice Arun Dev Choudhury, the court emphasized that a tender document must be interpreted as a unified whole, where individual provisions are harmoniously construed rather than isolated to negate specific obligations. The court noted that while Clause 6 outlines the primary documents for a technical bid, its language—“the technical bid shall primarily consist of”—demonstrates that the list is not intended to be exhaustive. Consequently, the absence of an explicit cross-reference to Annexure-C in the primary clause did not nullify the mandatory nature of the requirements listed in the checklist.

"A tender document must be read as a whole, and its different provisions must be harmoniously construed ," the court observed, highlighting that the criteria regarding the site information were not an internal administrative matter but a prescribed benchmark for eligibility. The court further noted that the document provided by the petitioner bore the credentials of an architect, which, while professional, did not satisfy the specific requirement for an engineer's certification. The court stated, "The document relied upon by her does not satisfy the substantive requirement prescribed by the tender."

Addressing the petitioner’s challenge regarding the successful bidder, the court acknowledged the stipulations under Clause 10, which require the online submission of documents and prioritize the digital version over hard copies in the event of discrepancies. However, the court found that this procedural framework does not supersede the foundational necessity of meeting eligibility criteria. Because the petitioner’s failure to provide an engineer-certified plan was a substantive defect in her own qualifications, the court held that she could not invoke the principle of equality under Article 14 of the Constitution to challenge the process based on the alleged procedural irregularities of another bidder.

The court reiterated the established limitations on judicial intervention in tender-related matters, clarifying that the judiciary does not function as an appellate authority over the specific assessments made by an expert tender committee. Interference is generally reserved for instances where a decision is shown to be arbitrary, irrational, mala fide, or contrary to the expressed terms of the tender. In this instance, the scrutiny committee’s actions were found to be directly aligned with the express requirements of the tender document.

"The court does not sit as an appellate authority over the tender committee's assessment," the court noted, reinforcing that courts cannot rewrite tender conditions or substitute their own judgment regarding the equivalence of professional certifications where the tender authority has clearly defined the standard. The court observed that the requirement for an engineer’s certification was not a superficial formality, as it relates to the suitability and safety of the proposed commercial premises.

By failing to produce the document as required, the petitioner did not merely stumble on a procedural hurdle but failed to meet a core eligibility threshold. Therefore, the court concluded that the rejection was neither illegal nor arbitrary. The writ petition was ultimately dismissed, and the parties were directed to bear their own costs, confirming the validity of the bid evaluation process conducted by the state authorities. This ruling reinforces the necessity for strict compliance with the technical specifications outlined in government tenders, underscoring that deviations from such requirements will likely lead to disqualification.