The has ruled that the for Engineering, Procurement, and Construction (EPC) contracts in the solar power sector is not mandatory for transactions executed prior to . In a significant relief for renewable energy developers, the bench of Justice Sanjay Kumar and Justice Sanjeev Sachdeva held that tax authorities erred in compelling taxpayers to a valuation formula that was only introduced in the later regime. The judgment effectively quashed tax demands and associated penalties imposed on Sterling and Wilson Pvt. Ltd. for the period between and .
The dispute arose after the attempted to the 70:30 split—which dictates that 70 percent of a contract value is deemed to be the supply of goods and 30 percent the supply of services—to contracts completed before the , deadline set by the government. The authorities had argued that this ratio, clarified by a subsequent circular in , should be the standard for all solar EPC projects regardless of the date of execution. However, the Supreme Court rejected this, characterizing the authorities’ interpretation of the circular as a misreading of its voluntary nature.
"There was no mandate, either in the Notification or in the Circular, that the 70:30 ratio had to be compulsorily applied to all the past transactions prior to 01.01.2019, irrespective of whether or not the assessee concerned chose to adopt it,"
the Court observed in its verdict. The bench emphasized that the use of the term "can" in the official notification indicated that the mechanism was an optional facility provided to assessees to streamline their tax liability, rather than a retroactive obligation imposed by the state.
Defining the Nature of Solar Assets
Central to the legal battle was the classification of solar power generating systems (SPG). The tax authorities had attempted to categorize these systems as "," arguing that the installation process—which includes civil foundation work—rendered the solar systems . Under the , the classification of a transaction as a works contract vs. a significantly alters the tax liability and the applicable rates.
The Supreme Court dismantled this argument by applying established tests of permanency, functionality, and intent. The Court noted that solar modules and panels are typically attached to civil foundations solely to ensure stability and operational efficiency rather than to create a permanent addition to the land. Drawing upon established precedents, the justices clarified that the mere attachment to a base does not automatically convert equipment into , especially when the item can be detached and relocated without causing damage to the primary goods.
"The fact that a SPG system has to be fixed on a civil foundation for stability and to ensure proper functioning would not, by itself, convert it into
,"
the Court held. By determining that the solar installation did not constitute an immovable asset, the Court invalidated the
's contention that the supply should be strictly classified as a works contract. This classification is critical because it removes the obligation to apply specific service-heavy tax rates that the authorities had sought to impose on the company.
Rejection of Extended Limitation
The Court also addressed the 's invocation of Section 74 of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, which permits the government to seek tax recovery over an extended period in cases involving fraud, willful misstatement, or the suppression of facts. The department had alleged that Sterling and Wilson deliberately suppressed information to minimize tax payments. However, the Court found these allegations entirely unfounded.
Because the 70:30 ratio was introduced only as a prospective measure in 2019, the Court reasoned that it was logically impossible for a taxpayer to have engaged in fraud or willful suppression regarding this formula for the preceding years. The judges noted that the foundational facts supporting an allegation of fraud must be clearly articulated in the and cannot merely be inferred through a change in policy or a disagreement over tax categorization. By setting aside the demand notice, the Court emphasized that to demand taxes through an requires a high threshold of evidence that the failed to meet in this instance.
The ruling marks a definitive conclusion to a long-standing point of contention between the renewable energy industry and the GST authorities. By clarifying that the government’s 2021 circular offered an option rather than a mandate, the Supreme Court has provided much-needed regulatory certainty for companies that had executed solar projects during the initial phase of the GST rollout.
As a result of this judgment, the dated , and the consequential summary order from , were set aside in their entirety. The Court directed both parties to bear their own costs, ending the protracted legal dispute that had originated from the assessment of tax liability for the fiscal period. The judgment serves as a vital reminder of the necessity for tax authorities to strictly observe the prospective nature of amendments and to respect the choices afforded to taxpayers under statutory circulars.
tax valuation - renewable energy