Searching Case Laws & Precedent on Legal Query.....!
Analysing the retrieved Case Laws
Scanned Judgements…!
Searching Case Laws & Precedent on Legal Query.....!
Analysing the retrieved Case Laws
Scanned Judgements…!
In Malaysian law, ex gratia payments are voluntary and are made over and above any other legal entitlements, serving as a gesture of goodwill rather than a legal obligation ["CONTRAVES ADVANCED DEVICES SDN BHD vs LIM SIEW HONG - Industrial Court"].
Legal context and application
Analysis and ConclusionIn Malaysian law, ex gratia payments are voluntary, non-legally mandated payments made as a favour or act of grace, distinct from contractual or statutory entitlements. They are often used to provide immediate relief, settle claims, or demonstrate goodwill, and are not considered wages or legally enforceable obligations unless explicitly specified. Their purpose is primarily humanitarian or policy-driven, and they serve as acts of grace rather than legal rights ["Lakshi Das, W/o. Lt. Nanda Das VS Gyanendra Dev Tripathi - Gauhati"] ["Sharda Devi VS General Manager, State Bank of India - Allahabad"] ["CONTRAVES ADVANCED DEVICES SDN BHD vs LIM SIEW HONG - Industrial Court"].
In the realm of employment, settlements, and compensation, the term ex gratia frequently arises, especially in disputes or terminations. But what exactly does ex gratia mean under Malaysian law? If you've searched for the definition of ex gratia Malaysian law, you're likely seeking clarity on whether such payments create legal obligations or remain purely voluntary. This blog post breaks it down, drawing from key judicial interpretations and legal principles to provide a comprehensive overview.
Ex gratia payments are common in Malaysia for avoiding litigation, fostering goodwill, or addressing grievances without admitting fault. However, their non-binding nature is crucial. We'll explore the definition, legal implications, court precedents, and exceptions—always remembering this is general information, not specific legal advice. Consult a qualified lawyer for your situation.
The term ex gratia, derived from Latin meaning by favor or out of grace, refers to payments made voluntarily without any legal obligation or liability on the payer's part A. Mohendra Singh VS Chiarman, Board Of Trustee Prbc Trust - 2021 0 Supreme(Gau) 201. These are gratuitous acts, given as a matter of kindness or favor, and do not inherently admit liability or create enforceable rights A. Mohendra Singh VS Chiarman, Board Of Trustee Prbc Trust - 2021 0 Supreme(Gau) 201Gunalata Das VS State of Assam - 2019 0 Supreme(Gau) 1068.
In essence:- Voluntary nature: No legal duty compels the payment A. Mohendra Singh VS Chiarman, Board Of Trustee Prbc Trust - 2021 0 Supreme(Gau) 201.- Non-binding: Recipients generally cannot enforce them as a matter of right unless intent to bind is proven A. Mohendra Singh VS Chiarman, Board Of Trustee Prbc Trust - 2021 0 Supreme(Gau) 201MLGH (SABAH) SDN BHD & ANOR vs RAINBOW BAY SDN BHD & ANOTHER APPEAL - 2023 MarsdenLR 1289.- Purpose: Often used to settle disputes amicably, reduce costs, or show generosity, without conceding legal responsibility MLGH (SABAH) SDN BHD & ANOR vs RAINBOW BAY SDN BHD & ANOTHER APPEAL - 2023 MarsdenLR 1289.
Legal dictionaries reinforce this: Ex gratia signifies a payment done as a favor, not because of a legal duty A. Mohendra Singh VS Chiarman, Board Of Trustee Prbc Trust - 2021 0 Supreme(Gau) 201. Malaysian courts align with this, viewing such payments as acts of grace rather than mandated entitlements Gunalata Das VS State of Assam - 2019 0 Supreme(Gau) 1068.
Malaysian jurisprudence consistently emphasizes the gratuitous character of ex gratia payments. Courts have held that they are not wages or enforceable obligations unless explicitly characterized otherwise Gunalata Das VS State of Assam - 2019 0 Supreme(Gau) 1068.
In employment contexts, such as retrenchments, ex gratia may be offered to Malaysian employees without extending to non-Malaysians, as no legal or contractual entitlement exists. For instance: Although the company has paid the Malaysian employees the ex gratia payments it does not follow that such payments should also be made to the non-Malaysian employees. The union has not established that they were entitled in law or in contract to these payments DYNAMIC PLANTATIONS BHD vs KESATUAN KEBANGSAAN PEKERJA-PEKERJA LADANG (NUPW). This highlights that voluntariness trumps equality claims absent rights.
Public policy also plays a role. Enforcement of related foreign judgments must align with Malaysian law, avoiding impositions contrary to local statutes like the Road Transport Act 1987 MOTOR INSURERS BUREAU OF SINGAPORE vs PACIFIC & ORIENT INSURANCE CO BERHAD. While not directly defining ex gratia, this reinforces that voluntary payments remain outside mandatory frameworks.
Typically non-enforceable, ex gratia payments' status can shift based on context and intent:- Clear intent to bind: If stated as a settlement acknowledging liability, courts may deem it enforceable A. Mohendra Singh VS Chiarman, Board Of Trustee Prbc Trust - 2021 0 Supreme(Gau) 201.- Schemes or policies: Under statutory or contractual setups, they might carry different weight, though still voluntary at core Gunalata Das VS State of Assam - 2019 0 Supreme(Gau) 1068.- Evidence scrutiny: Courts examine circumstances; absent proof of legal relations, they remain gratuitous A. Mohendra Singh VS Chiarman, Board Of Trustee Prbc Trust - 2021 0 Supreme(Gau) 201.
For example, in voluntary retirement schemes, ex gratia is calculated on retirement-month salary, with no later enforceable claim for revisions post-retirement, as no jural relationship persists K. Ajitkumar Gadiyar, Mangalore VS Corporation Bank, Represented by its General Manager, Mangalore - 2011 Supreme(Kar) 502. This mirrors Malaysian views on finality.
While ex gratia is broadly non-binding, exceptions include:- Explicit settlements: Where payments recognize obligations A. Mohendra Singh VS Chiarman, Board Of Trustee Prbc Trust - 2021 0 Supreme(Gau) 201.- Government or policy-driven: Like disaster relief, but still framed as favors, not rights (e.g., ex gratia for accidents under notifications, distinct from compensation) [Rofiqul Islam @ Rafikul Islam, S/o-Chukumuddin VS Union of India Ministry of Home Affairs [Disaster Management Division] Represented by its Secretary, ‘C’ Wing, 3rd Floor, NDCC, Jai Singh Road, New Delhi - 2023 Supreme(Gau) 370](https://supremetoday.ai/doc/judgement/01400032539).- No deduction from awards: In motor accident claims, ex gratia from employers (e.g., police) isn't deductible from statutory compensation Fuleshwari Tamrakar v. Varun Kumar Sinha - 2025 Supreme(Online)(Chh) 10620.
Courts stress: Ex gratia does not mean without consequence, but rather... without legal obligation, and enforceability depends on... intent A. Mohendra Singh VS Chiarman, Board Of Trustee Prbc Trust - 2021 0 Supreme(Gau) 201. In tax or ESI contexts, they may be excluded from 'wages' if treated as favors R. Meenakshi Ammal VS Velusamy & Others - 2002 Supreme(Mad) 705.
Employers often use ex gratia in:- Retrenchments: To ease transitions without liability admission.- Disputes: Avoiding costly suits MLGH (SABAH) SDN BHD & ANOR vs RAINBOW BAY SDN BHD & ANOTHER APPEAL - 2023 MarsdenLR 1289.- Compassionate cases: Like bank schemes offering lumpsums instead of appointments Jogindro VS Oriental Bank of Commerce - 2024 Supreme(P&H) 5.
Recipients should note: Acceptance doesn't waive other claims, as ex gratia doesn't curtail rights to just compensation M. Arulappan VS Secretary to Government - 2014 Supreme(Mad) 342.
In summary, understanding ex gratia empowers better negotiations. For tailored advice, engage a Malaysian legal professional. This post draws from established precedents for educational purposes only.
Although the company has paid the Malaysian employees the ex gratia payments it does not follow that such payments should also be made to the non-Malaysian employees. The union has not established that they were entitled in law or in contract to these payments. ... The company argues that the fact the ex gratia payments had been paid and wage revisions given to its Malaysian employees is irrelevant for the purpose of this dispute because the union must first show that the said employee....
![Rofiqul Islam @ Rafikul Islam, S/o-Chukumuddin VS Union of India Ministry of Home Affairs [Disaster Management Division] Represented by its Secretary, ‘C’ Wing, 3rd Floor, NDCC, Jai Singh Road, New Delhi - 2023 Supreme(Gau) 370](https://supremetoday-s3.b-cdn.net/Gauhati_3.png)
The definition of the term, ‘Disaster’ has been provided in Section 2[d] of the Disaster Management Act, 2005. ... The Disaster Management Act, 2005 has been enacted as a law on disaster management to provide requisite institutional mechanisms for drawing up and monitoring the implementation of the disaster management plans, ensuring measures by various wings of Government for prevention and mitigating effects of ... Gunalata Das vs. the State of Assam] and similar other writ petitions, by observing that the dominant purpose of the policy is to provide som....
Circular No.HO/Recovery&Law/14/2006-07/602 dated 26.03.2007, HO/REC & Law Circular No.02/2015-16/40 dated 01.04.2015 are to be obtained from the claimants in proof of their being the legal heir of the deceased kept on record. 2. ... All papers/documents as required in case of settlement of claims of deceased depositor as circulated vide Recovery and Law Deptt. ... Ensure to confirm the authenticity of the claimant being the lawful legal heir of the deceased and he/she falls under the definition of “Family” as circulated ....
The company is involved in manufacturing including the final assembly and factory acceptance test of the radar systems of the off-shore patrol vessels for the Royal Malaysian Navy in order to achieve the local contents to execute the Malaysian industrial participation of the Malaysian Government. ... In Soonavala's " The Supreme Court On Industrial Law " Vol. ... In Rideout's Principles of Labour Law, 5th edn, at p 181 the learned author had this to say: Statutory defination of " redundancy ". ... It ....
Ex-gratia payment under the law is a payment made as a favour in a circumstance where there is no legal necessity to make any such payment. ... of ex-gratia would be over and above that such person may be entitled as a compensation under any other law including the provisions of the Act of 1988. ... Upon determination by the authorities, if the aforesaid four conditions are held to be in favour of the claimant, we see no reason why under the law, the ex-gratia payment of Rs. 2,00,000....
The ex-gratia sum shall be paid by the Company to the Claimant through Malaysian Trades Union Congress vide a cheque ("the said cheque" ) made in favour Malaysian Trades Union Congress on or before 30.11.2010; 4. ... The Claimant has agreed to accept the ex-gratia sum; 3. ... The Company has agreed to pay an ex-gratia sum of RM20,000.00 (Ringgit Malaysia Twenty Thousand Only) to the Claimant as full and final settlement of this case ("the ex-gratia sum") without any admission of liabil....
Under such circumstances, the accident which led to the death of the husband of the Petitioner on account of repairing of the LT Line cannot come within the ambit of the wide definition of ‘public place’ as mentioned hereinabove. 20. ... Therefore, not all accidents would entitle a claimant to the ex gratia vide notification dated 15.11.2014. 14. ... As the petitioner has not been paid the ex gratia amount, the present writ petition has been filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India. 5. ... Principle of loss and gain has to be ....
Continuity and certainty is a highly desirable feature of law. (v) Interest pendente lite is not a matter of substantive law, like interest for the period anterior to reference (pre-reference period). ... These are acts of pure grace by the State, where the payment made to victims is ex gratia in the true sense of the term. There is no right to it nor a law to provide for it. The ex gratia lump sum involved here is completely different from how the term is generally understood. ... This Court is in who....
Rs.10,00,000 and Rs.20,000 paid for funeral expenses by the State Government, which is not permissible in law. ... The case - law which has been relied upon by the State counsel would not help the respondent No. 2 for the reason that the statutory rule referred to above clearly provides for the ex gratia amount to be in addition to any other compensation which the appellants / claimants are entitled to get ... Manjula Kabiraj Das , 2023 (2) RCR (Civil) 796, as held as under: "(9) In respect of issue ex gratia amount. The....
(ii) In determining what constitutes Malaysian public policy, a Malaysian Court should consider: (a) Malaysian law; (b) the policy of the law; (c) the policy in relation to the administration of the law; (d) fundamental principles of substantive ... [32] Therefore, it is not the duty of a Malaysian insurer under Malaysian law to pay for passenger risks which the insured himself has chosen not to cover and pay an additional premium....
Black's Law Dictionary, Sixth Edition defines ex gratia and ex gratia payment as under:- Out of grace; as a matter of grace, favour, or indulgence; gratuitous. A Latin expression, it literally means from favour or as a favour.
In law, ex-gratia payment is a payment made without the giver recognising any liability or legal obligation. Something has been done, ex-gratia, it has been done voluntarily, out of kindness or grace. Merely because an ex-gratia payment has been made by the Hon'ble Chief Minister, extending her goodwill that would not curtail the rights of minor Judith Rani to claim a just compensation from the respondents. At the time, when ex-gratia payment is made by the government, the giver may not recognise the liability or the legal obligation to pay just compensation to the accident....
In addressing the question arising for consideration, the definition of ex gratia as found in the several Dictionaries, can be usefully noted:- According to Advanced Law Lexicon, Third Edition, by P. Ramanatha Aiyar: Ex gratia. Ex/VR Employees/Officers Welfare Association, Bangalore and another, the opinion expressed that ex–gratia payment is to be calculated based on the revised pay scale given effect to retrospectively, after such ex-gratia payment was made is without reference to any principle of law and in the absence of any discussion on the factual matrix, in that cas....
As to the liability to tax of an ex gratia payment.’ A term applied to anything accorded as a favour; as distinguished from that which may be demanded ex debito, as a matter of right. According to Jowitt’s Dictionary of English Law, Second Edition, ‘ex gratia’ is defined as follows:- ‘Ex gratia (as of favour). (Investment) According to Webster’s Third New International Dictionary, “ex gratia – as a favour; not compelled by legal right (ex gratia pension payments)” Concise Oxford English Dictionary defines ‘ex gratia’ as follows:- “ex gratia – (with reference to pa....
In Black's Law Dictionary, 5th Edition, the meaning of the word "ex gratia" is given as follows: A term applied to anything accorded as a favor, as distinguished from that which may be demanded as ex debito, as a matter of right. "Out of grace; as a matter of grace, favor, or indulgence; gratuitous.
An indispensable Tool for Legal Professionals, Endorsed by Various High Court and Judicial Officers
Please visit our Training & Support
Center or Contact Us for assistance
Scan Me!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
For Daily Legal Updates, Join us on :
Back to top
