The has granted to the directors of the , Basudeb Bagchi and Avik Bagchi, in connection with a long-standing . In a significant ruling, Justice Sujit Narayan Prasad emphasized that the stringent conditions prescribed under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act (PMLA), 2002, cannot override the fundamental constitutional guarantee of . The court held that when reaches a stage where trial conclusion remains a remote possibility, continued detention violates the protections enshrined in .
The petitioners, who had been in , challenged their continued detention by highlighting an aggregate of approximately 40 months of across multiple related proceedings. The case, initiated by the , originated from an Enforcement Case Information Report (ECIR) registered on , following several cases linked to the ’s business activities. The prosecution alleged that two of the group's entities, and , had collected approximately ₹2,862.84 crore from about 38.71 lakh investors through unauthorized schemes. As of , an outstanding liability of roughly ₹1,906.22 crore was reported.
Balancing Statutory Rigor and Constitutional Rights
The central issue before the court was the applicability of , which mandates strict conditions for granting , in the context of the petitioners' extensive pre-trial detention. The ED had strongly opposed the application, arguing that the petitioners had previously evaded the court’s process for years, necessitating a cautious approach to their release. However, Justice Prasad observed that while the objectives of the PMLA regarding are vital, the statutory framework cannot be interpreted in a way that turns pre-trial detention into a .
"The stringent
conditions prescribed under Section 45 of the
(PMLA), cannot override the constitutional guarantee of
under
,"
the court noted in its judgment. The bench further remarked,
"The criminal process cannot be permitted to operate as a
prior to
."
The court analyzed the procedural timeline, noting that although the was filed as early as , charges had not been framed as of late 2026. With 19 witnesses cited and thousands of pages of documentary evidence involved, the court concluded that the trial was unlikely to conclude within a reasonable timeframe. The judge highlighted that where the investigation is largely complete and evidence is already in the custody of the prosecuting agency, indefinite detention fails the test of necessity.
Overlapping Proceedings and Precedent
A crucial factor influencing the decision was the fact that the had already granted to the same petitioners in a related ECIR registered by the ED in Kolkata. The acknowledged this as a material circumstance in assessing the necessity of continued custody. The court noted that the current proceedings, while technically distinct, arose from the same underlying financial transactions that have been subject to years of legal scrutiny.
The defense had pointed out that in the registered by the CBI in , no charge-sheet had been filed even after the lapse of 11 years. This absence of progress in the added weight to the argument that the continued detention of the petitioners in the PMLA case was disproportionate. The High Court drew upon recent judicial trends established by the Supreme Court in cases involving similar prolonged incarceration, noting that courts are duty-bound to intervene when the judicial process itself loses its efficiency.
The judgment further clarified that the petitioners had not been arrested during the investigation phase from 2016 to 2019 and had only been taken into custody following the initiation of subsequent proceedings. During the period of their liberty, the petitioners had participated in multiple court hearings across different jurisdictions, demonstrating a pattern of cooperation with the investigating agencies.
Conditions and Procedural Safeguards
While allowing the application, the court imposed strict conditions to ensure the petitioners remain available for the trial. The directors are required to furnish bonds of ₹1,00,000 each, along with two sureties of the same amount. They have been ordered to surrender their passports to the special judge and are prohibited from tampering with any evidence or inducing any witnesses acquainted with the facts of the case. Furthermore, the court mandated that the petitioners must attend every hearing unless exempted by the trial court.
The High Court emphasized that the observations made in the order were strictly limited to the application and should not influence the merits of the ongoing trial. The trial court has been directed to proceed with the matter independently, keeping in mind the need for a fair and expeditious conclusion. This ruling reinforces the judiciary's stance that the complexities of economic offense cases do not grant the state an unlimited license to detain individuals without the realistic prospect of an early trial conclusion. The petitioners are now set to be released, provided they comply with the stipulated conditions and finalize the necessary documentation with the .
pre-trial incarceration - constitutional personal liberty