Back
Kerala High Court Issues Landmark Protecting Thirty Nine Captive Elephants In Thrissur
The , led by a comprising Justice Raja Vijayaraghavan V. and Justice K.V. Jayakumar, has issued comprehensive interim directions aimed at safeguarding the welfare of 39 elephants housed at Punnathur Anakkotta. This facility, managed by the , serves as a hub for elephants used in regional temple rituals. The court’s intervention follows petitions highlighting systemic failures in ensuring the dignity and physical health of these protected animals.
A Crisis of Confinement
The dispute revolves around allegations that the 11-acre facility, housing 39 captive elephants, fails to meet the minimum standards required under the and the . Petitioners argued that the elephants experienced overcrowding, lacked adequate exercise, and suffered from improper tethering practices, such as the use of iron chains, and poor sanitation. Legal experts have long maintained that the should extend fundamental protections to animals, recognizing their right to live without "unnecessary pain or suffering."
Legal Arguments and Expert Assessments
The Guruvayur Devaswom asserted that it adheres to statutory requirements and maintains an to monitor elephant health. However, independent assessments, including a report by an , pointed to critical deficiencies. These reports highlighted that Punnathur Anakkotta lacks the space required for such a large population and recommended shifting toward more natural environments and reducing reliance on restrictive chaining.
Key Observations from the Bench
Highlighting the constitutional imperative to prevent animal cruelty, the High Court remarked:
-
"Rights guaranteed to the animals under , etc. are only . The same have to be elevated to the status of , as has been done by few countries around the world, so as to secure their honour and dignity."
-
"The facility operates as a managed captive elephant population dedicated to providing elephants required for the temple rituals and festivals."
-
"Unless the number of elephants housed at the facility is brought into conformity with its , or the available area is substantially increased, the minimum standards contemplated... cannot be meaningfully achieved."
Court’s Mandate for Change
The High Court’s imposes immediate obligations on the . These include:
- Strict Dietary Standards : Adopting the "Model Feeding Schedule" as prescribed by the government.
- Infrastructure Upgrades : Replacing metal chains with softer materials and installing high-capacity CCTV systems for 24/7 monitoring to prevent mahout-related cruelty.
- Sanitation & Hygiene : Improving drainage, installing modern RO water systems, and ensuring adequate running water for bathing.
- Veterinary Care : Upgrading diagnostic tools, including portable X-ray technology, and requiring quarterly inspection reports to be submitted to the .
The court has ordered that these measures be implemented without delay, with the matter set for review on . This directive marks a significant move toward prioritizing animal welfare in cultural institutions, ensuring that the management of captive elephants remains strictly aligned with modern scientific standards and .
