The High Court of Judicature at Madras has issued a sweeping interim injunction restraining a Bengaluru-based hardware supplier from utilizing trademarks that were found to be deceptively similar to those of a prominent Chennai-based manufacturer. The ruling, delivered by Justice P.B. Balaji, effectively halts the respondent’s activities regarding the manufacturing, marketing, and distribution of metal hardware goods under the contested "NAKODA" branding. This decision provides critical relief to the applicant, who argued that its long-standing market reputation and registered intellectual property were being compromised by a competitor’s attempts to mirror its established brand identity.

Justice Balaji’s decision underscores the court's strict stance against the dishonest adoption of trade marks, particularly when the infringing party fails to substantiate its claims of bona fide usage. The dispute specifically involved the applicant’s marks, which include "NAKODA PROPLUS," "PRO NAKODA," and the acronym-derived "SNE NAKODA." The court found that the respondent’s attempt to enter the market with similar nomenclature was not an honest coincidence but a deliberate strategy to ride on the goodwill painstakingly built by the applicant over the better part of a decade.

Establishing Prior Rights and Market Presence

The applicant, operating as the sole proprietor of Kalptaru Enterprise, demonstrated to the court that his business has been active in the metal hardware sector since at least October 2017. A central element of his argument rested on the origin of the "SNE NAKODA" mark, which was established by drawing from the name of a predecessor partnership firm, "Sree Nakoda Enterprises." The applicant currently holds 14 registrations in Class 6, covering a wide array of fasteners, screws, and other metallic hardware. Throughout the proceedings, the applicant provided evidence of significant sales turnover, indicating that the brand had gained substantial recognition among consumers nationwide.

During the hearings, the court scrutinized the respondent’s counter-argument, which claimed that "NAKODA" was merely a descriptive term referencing a Jain deity and, therefore, should not be subject to private proprietary claims. However, Justice Balaji dismissed this line of reasoning, highlighting the lack of credible evidence from the respondent regarding its own usage history. While the respondent claimed its operations commenced in 2021, the court found no documentation to support this assertion, contrasting it sharply with the applicant’s documented and consistent market presence since 2017.

"The grant of injunction become necessary, if it prima facie appears that the adoption of the mark was itself dishonest," the court noted, citing established legal precedents regarding the necessity of protecting trademark holders from predatory market practices.

Deceptive Similarity and Lack of Bona Fides

A critical point of contention was the respondent's assertion that the use of the term "NAKODA" was an honest adoption based on religious nomenclature. The court, however, remained unimpressed, observing that the respondent did not possess any inherent or community-based connection that would justify the adoption of the name in a business context.

"Firstly, I see the user of the mark to be dishonest and not bonafide for the simple reason that though NAKODA is a descriptive word referring to a Jain god, the respondent does not even belong to the Jain community to claim to have adopted the mark NAKODA honestly," the court remarked. This finding proved pivotal, as it stripped away the respondent's claim of an honest, unintentional overlap, reinforcing the court's view that the infringement was a calculated move to deceive the marketplace.

The court further noted that the respondent’s post-notice behavior—which included filing for rectification of the applicant's long-standing registered trademarks—served as a clear indicator of mala fide intent. By attempting to challenge the applicant's existing rights only after being served a cease-and-desist notice, the respondent undermined its own credibility before the court.

Preventing Consumer Confusion in Hardware Markets

The potential for consumer confusion served as the final pillar of the court's decision. Because both parties are engaged in the identical business of selling metal screws and fasteners, the visual and phonetic similarity of the marks "SNE NAKODA" and "SNE NAKODA FASTENING SYSTEM" presented a direct risk to the marketplace. Justice Balaji emphasized that the average consumer, accustomed to the applicant's established products, would likely be misled into believing that the respondent’s goods originated from the same source.

"Considering the fact that the applicant as well as the respondent are in the same line of business, dealing with metal screws, clever and mischievous duplication of the name of the applicant, would be sufficient to confuse the consumers in market," the court explained.

The court also rejected the respondent’s attempt to downplay the applicant’s revenue, noting that a turnover of 25 crores in a low-value commodity business like hardware is indicative of significant market reach and consumer trust. The court concluded that if the interim injunction were denied, the applicant would face irreparable harm, not just in terms of monetary loss, but through the dilution of the reputation he had cultivated over twenty years of industry experience.

In its final order, the High Court allowed the original applications, granting an immediate interim injunction in O.A. Nos. 273 and 274 of 2026. The respondent is now legally barred from manufacturing, advertising, or selling any goods under the impugned labels. This decision effectively maintains the status quo, protecting the applicant’s intellectual property while the underlying commercial suit proceeds toward a full trial. The case serves as a stern reminder that courts will prioritize the rights of prior users who demonstrate legitimate business history over latecomers attempting to exploit existing goodwill.