The government of Maharashtra has officially withdrawn its constitutional challenge against the Union Ministry of Health and Family Welfare and the Food Safety and Standards Authority of India (FSSAI) before the Bombay High Court. The decision, which marks a significant de-escalation in a high-profile administrative tug-of-war, was conveyed to a division bench comprising Chief Justice Mahesh C. Tripathi and Justice Advait Sethna during proceedings held on November 21. The state’s move effectively ends a judicial intervention that had questioned the fundamental structure of food safety enforcement in the country.

The withdrawal follows a period of targeted outreach by the central food safety regulator, which sought to address the state's grievances through alternative dispute resolution mechanisms. Government Pleader Neha Bhide, acting on specific instructions from the state Food and Drug Administration (FDA), informed the bench that the state intended to cease litigation. The court subsequently recorded the statement and disposed of the petition as withdrawn, bringing the matter to a definitive close.

Origins of the Jurisdictional Dispute

The controversy, which originated in September, stemmed from allegations that the FSSAI had gradually dismantled the decentralized framework established by the Food Safety and Standards Act, 2006. At the time of filing, the state government, led by Food Safety Commissioner Tukaram Mundhe, argued that the central authority had unlawfully established a parallel enforcement regime. The petition contended that the Act had originally envisioned a power structure where licensing and enforcement duties primarily resided with state commissioners and designated officers, ensuring that local authorities maintained oversight of ground operations.

The petition specifically challenged the validity of the 2011 Licensing Regulations, the 2018 Recruitment Regulations, and the 2026 Amendment Regulations. The core of the state's argument was that the FSSAI had bypassed the spirit of the legislation by creating new roles—such as ‘Central Food Safety Officer’ and ‘Central Licensing Authority’—without clear legislative authorization. According to the state’s filings, the enforcement mandate of the FSSAI CEO was historically intended to be limited to imported food items rather than the domestic, state-based food business environment.

Escalation and Regulatory Friction

The conflict intensified in May 2023 when the FSSAI issued a directive explicitly barring state officers from inspecting businesses that held central licenses. The Maharashtra government maintained that this directive, coupled with the implementation of the online Food Safety Compliance System (FoSCoS) portal, was designed to systematically consolidate control under the central government, thereby sidelining state officials. Furthermore, the state challenged notifications from March 2026 that revised licensing turnover thresholds, arguing that these changes were executed without inviting the mandatory public objections required for significant regulatory shifts.

The FDA claimed that these administrative actions hindered the state's ability to protect consumer interests effectively. By preventing local inspectors from raiding or monitoring establishments that were centrally licensed, the state argued that the central authority had effectively created a vacuum in enforcement, particularly where local safety standards were concerned. This friction led to a rare public legal confrontation between the state and the federal government, both of which are governed by the same political party, highlighting the depth of the procedural disagreement.

Shift Toward Administrative Reconciliation

The sudden pivot toward withdrawal has been attributed to the success of bilateral discussions between the state and central regulatory bodies. Sources familiar with the developments suggest that the FSSAI reached out to the state administration to address concerns regarding the overlap of responsibilities and the potential for a more integrated, cooperative regulatory environment. This outreach served as the catalyst for the government to reassess its legal position, leading to an October directive that instructed officials to withdraw the pending petition.

For legal observers, the case serves as a notable example of how structural tensions within federalized regulatory frameworks can be addressed through administrative negotiation rather than protracted litigation. The reliance on the original Statement of Objects and Reasons of the Food Safety and Standards Act, 2006, had formed the bedrock of the state’s legal challenge. The state’s insistence that the Act explicitly prioritized decentralization provided a strong basis for their initial claims, asserting that the FSSAI’s actions were "clandestinely" adding regulations that encroached upon the state's constitutional duties.

Next Steps for Food Safety Enforcement

With the petition withdrawn, the focus now shifts to how the FSSAI and state authorities will implement a more collaborative framework. The resolution is expected to clarify the roles of Central Food Safety Officers and state-designated officers, potentially streamlining the enforcement process for centrally licensed entities without entirely stripping state authorities of their oversight capacity.

While the constitutional questions regarding the validity of the 2026 regulations remain unaddressed by a judicial ruling, the move toward an out-of-court resolution provides a pragmatic pathway for stakeholders. The current procedural position is that the matter is now fully disposed of by the Bombay High Court, leaving the respective administrations to formalize an agreement that preserves the decentralization envisioned in the 2006 legislation while accommodating the operational requirements of a central regulatory body. Business owners and consumers will be looking for clear guidelines on how these inspections will be conducted moving forward under the reconciled regulatory approach.