The has of ₹5,000 against the state’s Additional Advocate General, , following continued frustration over the government's failure to provide critical environmental impact reports regarding limestone and boulder mining operations in the state's Dawki region. The bench, led by Chief Justice Revati Mohite Dere and Justice W. Diengdoh, issued the directive during a hearing on , marking a significant escalation in the court's oversight of a initially registered to curb unregulated mineral transportation.
The court’s decision follows a series of missed deadlines spanning back to . Despite numerous previous orders directing the state to submit a comprehensive environmental impact report regarding the effects of mining in Dawki, the state consistently requested adjournments, ultimately prompting the court to demand the immediate personal attendance of senior government officials to explain the administrative inertia.
Systematic Failure of Administrative Communication
The depth of the procedural failure became apparent when S.C. Sadhu, the Secretary of the for the , appeared before the court. During the proceedings, the Secretary candidly admitted that he had not been informed of a single passed by the High Court since the case’s inception in June. Furthermore, the Secretary confirmed that the reports submitted by the court-appointed , , had never been presented for his review, and he was entirely unaware of the mandate to file an environmental impact report.
The court expressed profound dissatisfaction with this lack of internal communication, emphasizing that the environmental implications of the mining activities in the region pose significant risks to the public. As the bench noted during the hearing,
"Matters that touch environment have to be taken seriously, since it impacts one and all."
The inability of the state machinery to effectively translate court directives into inter-departmental action was cited as the primary driver for the imposition of costs against the Additional Advocate General, whose office is tasked with facilitating the government's compliance with judicial mandates.
Oversight of Mineral Transportation Corridors
Since the registration of the , the High Court has been closely monitoring the logistics of mineral extraction and transit, particularly along the Dawki-Tamabil and Dawki-Amlarem-Jowai roads. The court initially intervened upon observing a massive influx of heavy-duty dumper trucks and goods vehicles transporting limestone and boulders toward the Bangladesh border without valid registration papers or visible number plates. This lawlessness was compounded by the poor condition of the infrastructure, which posed further safety risks to the local population.
While the court acknowledged that some course correction has occurred—resulting in more vehicles displaying registration plates and the improved functionality of weighbridges—serious gaps in law enforcement persist. Reports previously submitted by the Registry revealed a complete absence of police personnel along the critical stretch from the Nongtalang area to the Amjeha weighbridge. Even at the weighbridges themselves, which are meant to serve as regulatory checkpoints, the presence of law enforcement was notably absent. The court further observed that the traffic remains dangerously unregulated, with large trucks often causing bottlenecks as vehicles struggle to navigate narrow corridors while approaching from opposing directions.
Responding to these findings via video conference, Jagpal Singh Dhanoa, the Superintendent of Police for the West Jaintia Hills District, assured the bench that immediate steps would be taken to bolster police presence along the identified stretches. The court emphasized that the presence of police at weighbridges is essential to ensuring that mineral transport complies with weight limits and safety standards, thereby mitigating the ongoing environmental degradation.
Next Steps and Government Compliance
In addition to the monetary penalty imposed on the Additional Advocate General, the court has set a strict timeline for further action. The Secretary of the
and the Secretary of the
have been formally directed to file detailed
by the next hearing date. These affidavits must explicitly outline the government's intended policy response to the environmental damage caused by continuous limestone extraction and specify the measures being taken to manage the long-term impact on local livelihoods, as documented in the
"Study on Mining Affected Areas and its Impact on Livelihood of 2019"
by the
.
The case remains a central point of judicial focus, with the court stressing that the state’s continued reliance on repeated adjournments is no longer acceptable. The requested instruction from the government, which involves synthesizing the data provided by the with the state's own environmental mandates, must be ready for the court’s review when the matter is next heard on . This upcoming session is expected to serve as a litmus test for the administration's commitment to balancing industrial mineral transit with the essential preservation of Meghalaya's fragile environmental ecosystem. The costs imposed on the government counsel must be deposited with the within one week, serving as a firm reminder of the necessity for diligent legal representation and administrative transparency in matters of public interest.
judicial oversight - environmental accountability