The () has affirmed the rejection of an submitted by Shobhit J. Rajan, the of , ruling that an does not grant a blanket exemption from mandatory . The New Delhi bench, comprising Justice Mohammad Faiz Alam Khan and Member (Technical) Naresh Salecha, held that while a (CoC) possesses the discretionary power to relax eligibility conditions for an MSME , no judicial body can compel the creditors to grant such waivers.
, a real estate development firm, was admitted into the on . As part of the resolution process, the sole financial creditor and committee member, , established clear eligibility parameters for prospective . These criteria included a mandatory minimum standalone net worth of ₹400 crore to ensure that potential applicants possessed the necessary financial strength to oversee a high-value project with an asset potential estimated at ₹5,000 crore.
Mr. Rajan, the original , submitted an EOI within the designated timeline and deposited an of ₹5 crore. However, he failed to provide the required , opting instead to mark the requirement as “not applicable” in his submission. His argument rested on the premise that , which provides relief to MSME promoters by exempting them from certain , should also shield him from the standalone net-worth requirement. The Resolution Professional, , granted Mr. Rajan an opportunity to cure this deficiency, but after he maintained his position regarding the exemption, the EOI was formally rejected on .
In his appeal before the , the contended that the mechanical application of the net-worth criterion ignored his financial bona fides, his past contributions to the company’s debt servicing, and his willingness to provide alternative forms of financial transparency. He further suggested that the unique circumstances of an MSME warranted a more flexible approach to ensure value maximization for the .
The Appellate Tribunal, however, drew a firm distinction between the negative outlined in and the positive eligibility requirements mandated by the CoC under Section 25(2)(h). The bench clarified that Section 240A is narrow in scope and explicitly limited to . The court emphasized that the legislature had not provided for a universal waiver of eligibility criteria for MSME promoters, and it was not the role of the tribunal to rewrite the statute.
Regarding the appellant's claim of exceptional circumstances, the noted that the ’s status and the company’s MSME registration were standard features of such proceedings and did not qualify as grounds to bypass financial scrutiny. The bench observed, “We make it clear that we are not holding that a CoC can never relax the net worth criterion for an MSME . A CoC may do so, if it thinks fit in the interest of a better resolution. All we hold is that no tribunal can compel it to do so on the basis of .”
The Tribunal further scrutinized the appellant's attempt to substitute the with income tax returns and credit scores. It ruled that such documents, while indicative of certain financial behaviors, could not replace a certified statement of net worth, which provides a verifiable assessment of an individual’s assets and liabilities. The court remarked, “The CoC chose the net worth certificate as the test, because it is an independent and verifiable document. A tribunal cannot replace it with another test of its own choosing. The CoC is not barred from accepting other forms of comfort, but it is not bound to.”
Addressing the appellant’s contention that the CoC lacked the opportunity to consider his proposal, the court highlighted the operational framework of the . Under the current regime, the Resolution Professional is tasked with verifying EOIs against the criteria previously approved by the CoC. Since the CoC had already determined the net-worth threshold and collectively decided against granting waivers during the EOI stage, the Resolution Professional acted in strict accordance with the committee's mandate. The also addressed the appellant's concerns regarding the re-computation of claims against the company, noting that the ongoing legal challenges related to debt calculation were distinct from the eligibility thresholds applicable to .
The bench concluded that the financial criteria were proportionate to the scale of the company’s real estate assets and were applied uniformly to all prospective applicants. Because the appellant failed to satisfy the essential documentary requirements stipulated in the invitation for expression of interest, the rejection of his EOI was determined to be legally valid. The appeal was subsequently dismissed, leaving the current resolution process to proceed as per the terms approved by the . No order as to costs was passed in the proceedings.
resolution applicant eligibility - committee of creditors commercial wisdom