The in Mumbai has officially admitted a petition to initiate the against , citing an unpaid of over Rs 2.23 crore. This decision, delivered by a bench comprising Member (Technical) Prabhat Kumar and Member (Judicial) Sushil Mahadeorao Kochey, highlights the tribunal's stance that pending criminal complaints under the do not serve as a bar to when the requirements for an are otherwise satisfied.
The insolvency application, filed by , stems from a series of unpaid invoices related to the supply of geared motors, planetary motor brakes, and other mechanical components throughout the . The demonstrated that despite repeated payment demands and the subsequent totaling Rs 61.34 lakh, the failed to clear its outstanding liabilities. In its formal response, the tribunal emphasized that the mere institution of complaints in respect of dishonored cheques does not preclude a creditor from triggering the insolvency code, provided the statutory conditions are met.
Scrutinizing the Alleged
Spartan Engineering Industries had vehemently opposed the petition, asserting that a " " regarding the quality of supplied goods absolved it of the immediate payment obligation. The company claimed that mechanical deficiencies, including overheating and gear misalignment, had resulted in significant production losses and that these issues were raised prior to the issuance of the formal .
However, the tribunal dismissed these contentions after finding that the specific grievances raised by the did not pertain to the invoices under current litigation. The bench observed that the alleged defective goods involved two invoices that were not part of the present petition, and that the value of these specific items—approximately Rs 4.23 lakh—amounted to only 2.13% of the total claimed amount. Crucially, the court noted that the had addressed these complaints by conducting a technical inspection on , which concluded that the issues were caused by external factors such as insufficient lubrication and were not covered under warranty.
In its detailed order, the tribunal noted, “The absence of any subsequent objection to the inspection report meant that the complaints relied upon by Spartan Engineering could not establish a subsisting dispute under .” The bench further observed that the failed to offer any evidence of ongoing communication challenging the findings of that report between the time it was issued and the filing of the insolvency application.
Reaffirming Statutory Jurisdiction and Process
The also challenged the territorial jurisdiction of the , arguing that the contractual documents stipulated that all transactions should be subject to the courts of Coimbatore. The tribunal categorically rejected this argument, clarifying that the jurisdiction of the is governed by , which ties jurisdiction to the location of the registered office of the corporate entity. Given that Spartan Engineering’s registered office is situated in Mumbai, the tribunal affirmed its authority to adjudicate the matter.
Furthermore, the court scrutinized the evidence of the default, including the dishonored cheques and the lack of any significant communication from the regarding the payment status after . The tribunal described the allegations of defective products as a potential “afterthought” intended to forestall the inevitable initiation of the insolvency process, rather than a genuine, that would merit the rejection of the section 9 petition. As the tribunal noted in its ruling, “All that the adjudicating authority is to see at this stage is whether there is a plausible contention which requires further investigation and that the ‘dispute’ is not a patently feeble legal argument or an assertion of fact unsupported by evidence.”
Appointment of
Following the admission of the petition, the bench initiated a on the under . This measure prevents the institution of new suits or the continuation of pending proceedings against the company, ensuring the protection of its assets during the resolution process.
The tribunal has appointed Chhotulal Rawa Bhagwat as the to manage the affairs of the company and carry out the functions prescribed under the Code. The management of Spartan Engineering Industries is now vested in the , and the company's officers are directed to provide all documentation and information necessary for the resolution process within one week.
Additionally, the tribunal ordered the to provide Rs 3 lakh as an initial contribution toward the expenses of the , which will be subject to adjustments as the process unfolds. The in Mumbai has been instructed to update the master data of the company to reflect the ongoing , with a compliance report expected within seven days of receiving the order. With the appointment of the interim professional, the process will now move toward the formation of a , as the focus shifts to resolving the financial distress of the organization.
corporate insolvency - operational debt