The , has issued a significant ruling prohibiting financial creditors from unilaterally altering the terms of a concluded . The bench, comprising Member Shammi Khan and Member Sanjeev Sharma, ordered four major lenders—, , , and —to issue unconditional to the successful auction purchaser, Rakesh Ramanlal Shah and his consortium, The order effectively rejects the lenders' attempts to exclude from the assets already transferred to the purchaser under the .
The dispute stems from the liquidation process of , which was sold as a going concern through an e-auction held on . The consortium emerged as the winning bidder with a total consideration of ₹78 crore, which was fully paid. Following this, the liquidator issued a formal on . According to the purchaser, the certificate covered the entirety of the ’s , specifically excluding only cash and bank balances. However, several financial creditors subsequently introduced a conditional clause titled “Absolute Exclusion of ” in their respective NOCs, claiming that any rights to arbitration awards or future realizations should not pass to the new owner.
In its judgment, the Tribunal underscored that the terms of a finalized sale cannot be modified or enlarged by creditors after the fact. The bench noted that the sale as a going concern had already attained finality, having been upheld by the and subsequently by the . By inserting arbitrary restrictions into post-sale documentation, the creditors were attempting to unilaterally redefine the scope of the transfer.
The Tribunal remarked, “To the extent the validity and implementation of the sale as a going concern have been upheld in the appellate proceedings, the terms of the cannot be enlarged or varied by a subsequent NOC issued by an individual creditor. A subsequent NOC cannot, by itself, introduce an exclusion which is absent from the concluded terms of sale.” This observation highlights the Tribunal's firm stance against fragmented or post-hoc attempts by stakeholders to claw back benefits that were part of the auction process.
Safeguarding the Auction Finality
The legal challenge was initiated by the purchaser to prevent the erosion of the ’s value, which the applicant argued was fundamental to the “” principle intended for going-concern sales. The applicant, Rakesh Ramanlal Shah, contended that the was the sole governing document for the transfer of rights. By attempting to carve out arbitration claims, the lenders were, in the view of the applicant, ignoring the clear terms of the auction information document and the subsequent court-approved .
The Tribunal’s order mandates that the four banks in question provide fresh, unconditional NOCs within seven days of the receipt of the order. Crucially, the bench clarified that there is no ambiguity regarding the exclusion list, which remains limited to cash and bank balances. The inclusion of in the sale was deemed consistent with the previous orders passed by the , specifically the order dated , which held that all existing and future receivables and entitlements vest in the successful auction purchaser.
Balancing Secured Creditor Interests
While ruling in favor of the purchaser regarding the exclusion clause, the Tribunal was careful to balance these requirements with the ongoing litigation concerning . STCI, a secured creditor, had previously challenged the sale and the distribution of proceeds. The Supreme Court is currently examining the limited issue of whether STCI holds a first pari passu charge over the assets. The NCLT bench clarified that its order in this application does not prejudice the rights of STCI or any other party in relation to the pending appeal before the Supreme Court.
Regarding the applicant’s request for the issuance of Form CHG-4, which records the satisfaction of a charge, the Tribunal declined to issue a direction at this stage. It reasoned that because the priority of charges is still being litigated in the Supreme Court, any order confirming the satisfaction of a charge would prematurely adjudicate upon issues currently . The Tribunal stated, “Nothing contained in this order shall adjudicate or prejudice the inter se priority of Respondent No.6 vis-à-vis other secured creditors, the entitlement or distribution of the proceeds, or any question expressly left open by the Hon’ble Supreme Court.”
Future Implications for Liquidation Sales
The decision reinforces the sanctity of the auction process under the . By preventing creditors from introducing new conditions after the successful conclusion of an auction, the NCLT has reinforced the predictability required for high-value insolvency sales. The ruling serves as a warning that once a bid is accepted and a is issued, the transfer of title is absolute and cannot be subjected to invented by individual lenders.
The current procedural standing requires the liquidator and the affected banks to comply with the directive to issue the revised NOCs without the impugned exclusion clauses. For the purchaser, this clears a significant hurdle in the formal handover of the ’s assets, enabling the completion of the transfer process. The matter now rests on the banks to facilitate the compliance ordered by the Tribunal, while the broader questions of charge priority and asset distribution continue to be addressed through the separate appeal process in the Supreme Court. The applicant is at liberty to seek further clarifications or reliefs following the eventual outcome of the ongoing Supreme Court litigation, ensuring that the current order serves as a functional step toward the practical implementation of the sale rather than a final determination of every outstanding claim against the .
corporate insolvency - liquidation proceedings