The , , has formally rejected an application filed by a successful bidder seeking sweeping reliefs and concessions following the acquisition of a company during its . In a significant ruling, the bench clarified that purchasing a as a during liquidation cannot be legally equated with the revival of a company under an approved . The tribunal held that such acquisitions do not automatically entitle the purchaser to blanket exemptions from , including those owed to tax authorities.
The case involved Rajendra Dallaram Choudhary, who had successfully bid for , a company currently under liquidation. The for the firm had commenced in following a petition by , eventually leading to a liquidation order in . After participating in the auction process for the company as a in , Choudhary sought a wide range of reliefs and concessions to facilitate the business's operational continuity. These included requests to extinguish outstanding income-tax and Minimum Alternate Tax (MAT) liabilities, as well as the ability to carry forward and set off losses under the .
In its judgment, the tribunal observed that there is a fundamental legal distinction between the revival of a through an approved and the sale of assets or the entity as a under the liquidation regime. The Bench, comprising Judicial Member Chitra Hankare and Technical Member Velamur G Venkata Chalapathy, highlighted that the had been under liquidation for over six years, and the current sale did not provide a new, value-maximizing revival plan for the benefit of all creditors.
Distinction Between Liquidation and Resolution The tribunal underscored that the benefit of carry-forward and set-off of losses under Section 79(2)(c) of the Income-tax Act is specifically reserved for instances where a change in shareholding occurs pursuant to an approved under the . Because the entity had proceeded into liquidation without a successful , the statutory exceptions provided for business revival were inapplicable to the applicant. The had strongly opposed the request, asserting that no legal provision empowers an Assessing Officer to grant a blanket extinction of tax liabilities.
The court stated, “This CD has been liquidated over 6 years before this application was filed and there is no benefit or value arrived at in favour of creditors on such sale and cannot be equated to a revival under .” By rejecting the petition, the tribunal ensured that the interests of operational creditors, particularly government tax departments, were not prejudiced by an unauthorized, comprehensive waiver of liabilities that had not been subjected to the rigorous checks inherent in a formal resolution process.
Operational Consequences for Bidders The tribunal further noted that the liquidator had not obtained prior approval from the to conduct the sale as a , especially after such a prolonged period since the initiation of liquidation. Consequently, the transaction was characterized by the tribunal as a “,” which does not carry the same legal entitlements as a formal corporate restructuring. The lack of documented valuation specifically addressing the goodwill of the entity further weakened the applicant’s case for seeking blanket exemptions.
The tribunal also emphasized the importance of maintaining the integrity of the , noting that granting such broad reliefs without statutory authority could undermine the legal standing of operational creditors. In its observations, the bench remarked that: “We do not consider granting any blanket relief to the applicant other than those applicable under sale on slump basis, duly allowing any operational creditor to proceed against the suspended management other than on the assets sold, if the claim has been submitted during the liquidation period and allowed by the Liquidator and considered in distribution of assets.”
Final Disposal of the Application The court’s decision serves as a significant precedent for potential bidders in liquidation sales, clarifying the limited scope of concessions available when acquiring companies through the liquidation route. The tribunal reiterated that the IBC does not grant purchasers a blank check to avoid past statutory obligations under the guise of an acquisition.
By rejecting the application (IA No. 1485 of ), the has reaffirmed that the protections available to successful resolution applicants do not automatically extend to purchasers in liquidation proceedings. The applicant, having acquired the business as a , must now contend with the company’s existing liabilities as per the standard legal framework, absent any specific, court-sanctioned relief to the contrary. The order effectively preserves the rights of the and other operational creditors to pursue claims against the entity, reinforcing the priority of established tax laws over post-acquisition demands for waivers. The matter concludes with the rejection of the applicant’s plea, emphasizing the adherence to established liquidation protocols over attempts to import privileges from the resolution stage.
liquidation proceeding - insolvency resolution