The has declined to grant a for , marking a significant pause in the of the health food manufacturer. In an order dated , the determined that the application filed by the liquidator was premature, as critical discrepancies regarding statutory liabilities and financial record-keeping remained unresolved. The bench, presided over by Member Shammi Khan and Member Sanjeev Sharma, emphasized that the court’s satisfaction regarding the completion of the is a mandatory prerequisite for dissolution under the .
The company, a wholly owned subsidiary of , had initiated its in . Following the appointment of as the liquidator, the entity moved to consolidate its operations into its holding company, . While the liquidator maintained that the process was conducted in accordance with the regulatory framework, the tribunal’s scrutiny uncovered significant gaps in the reporting and reconciliation of financial claims.
Scrutiny of Statutory Compliance and Records
A central point of contention involved a claim from the totaling approximately ₹14.51 lakh. This claim was received by the liquidator on —several months after the distribution of the company’s business undertaking. Although the liquidator argued that the liability had been settled by in , the tribunal observed a lack of consistency in the official disclosures.
The tribunal noted that Form-H, which is used for the final reporting of the liquidation process, contained a "NIL" disclosure regarding government dues. This directly contradicted the subsequent receipt and settlement of the EPFO claim. The court held that such discrepancies require rigorous reconciliation, stating, “The Liquidator is required to reconcile this disclosure with the liquidation accounts and place on record the claim, its verification, the settlement particulars and proof of payment, together with the basis on which the liability was dealt with outside the liquidation distribution.”
Furthermore, the tribunal emphasized that contractual arrangements between a and its holding company cannot override . While had agreed to assume the liabilities of as part of the business distribution, the tribunal clarified that such private agreements do not automatically extinguish statutory liabilities or absolve the liquidator of the responsibility to provide a full and transparent account of all debts settled during the liquidation.
Concerns Over Asset Distribution
The liquidator had informed the tribunal that the entire business undertaking, valued at approximately ₹399.01 crore, was transferred to on a . While the IBC and the related allow for the distribution of assets, the tribunal scrutinized the justification provided for this transfer.
Under , a liquidator must demonstrate that an asset cannot be "readily or advantageously sold" to justify alternative distribution methods. The NCLT found the supporting documentation regarding the going-concern transfer insufficient to fully satisfy the rigorous standards required for complete dissolution. The bench directed the liquidator to provide further evidence justifying the distribution, ensuring it remained in strict adherence to the statutory conditions prescribed for the voluntary winding-up of a .
Procedural Inconsistencies and Timeline
Beyond the treatment of liabilities, the court identified several inconsistencies in the timeline provided in the liquidation records. Discrepancies were noted regarding the public announcement of the liquidation and the stipulated last date for the submission of creditor claims. The tribunal also noted that the documentation contained internal references suggesting that the dissolution application was still in preparation, despite the fact that the application had already been formally filed before the tribunal on .
These procedural gaps prevented the bench from reaching the requisite level of certainty required to issue an order under . The court observed, “In the absence of such reconciliation, this Tribunal is unable to record the requisite satisfaction under Section 59(7) of the Code that all affairs of the have been completely wound up.”
Consequently, the prayer for dissolution was declined at this stage. The tribunal has disposed of the current petition as premature, granting the liquidator the liberty to file a fresh application once all identified deficiencies are rectified. The liquidator remains legally responsible for the preservation of all books of account and company records until the dissolution is officially sanctioned. The ruling reinforces the judiciary's stance on strict compliance during voluntary liquidations, signaling that administrative oversights or unclear financial disclosures will not be overlooked, even in cases where the major stakeholders are in agreement.
voluntary liquidation - corporate dissolution