The National Company Law Tribunal () Mumbai Bench has issued a significant ruling clarifying the boundaries of a ’s (RP) authority during the , explicitly barring them from adjudicating on complex legal issues such as the limitation period of a claim. The bench, presided over by Member (Technical) Anil Raj Chellan and Member (Judicial) K. R. Saji Kumar, overturned the decision of the of to reject a massive ₹296.08 crore claim submitted by . The tribunal emphasized that the RP’s function remains strictly administrative and facilitative rather than adjudicatory.
The dispute centered on a long-standing financial arrangement originating in , when advanced a loan of ₹1 crore to the corporate debtor, then known as . Over nearly three decades, this debt underwent multiple assignments, eventually being transferred to Kotak Mahindra Bank. When the corporate debtor, now Galore Developers, entered the (CIRP), the bank filed a claim for over ₹296 crore. The RP, however, rejected the claim in , citing the absence of this specific liability in the debtor’s financial statements from to and arguing that the claim was .
In its judgment, the tribunal criticized the RP for stepping beyond the scope of its duties under the (IBC). The bench noted that while an RP must verify claims, this process is intended to ensure the accuracy of the by reviewing documentation rather than resolving legal disputes that fall under the purview of the . By attempting to rule on the limitation period of the debt, the RP had assumed an adjudicatory role that it does not legally possess.
"It is important to note that the claim filed by the creditor before the
does not constitute a proceeding, and the
lacks authority to adjudicate upon the limitation while discharging the administrative function of verifying the accuracy of the information/documents provided by the creditor,"
the tribunal observed in its order.
Tribunal Clarifies Administrative Scope of
The ’s ruling serves as a stark reminder of the division of labor within the insolvency process. The tribunal reinforced the principle that if an RP finds evidence of a claim to be weak, the appropriate path is to request further documentation or, if the dispute remains unresolved, to refer the matter to the . The RP’s rejection was deemed particularly flawed because the tribunal found that the creditor had provided sufficient foundational documents, including the original loan agreement, mortgage documents, and evidence of pending recovery proceedings before the (DRT).
The RP had contended that the bank’s claim had not "crystallized" because the recovery application before the DRT remained pending. The rejected this line of reasoning, noting that the definition of "claim" under is intentionally broad, encompassing rights to payment regardless of whether they have been reduced to a final judgment or remain disputed. This breadth ensures that a corporate debtor’s obligations are not prematurely extinguished during the insolvency process simply because a legal battle remains ongoing at the time of the CIRP admission.
Dispute Over Historical Debt and Statutory Charge
A central point of the bank’s argument was that its was never in doubt, as the charge had been duly registered with the (RoC). The bank maintained that such registration constitutes conclusive evidence of its , a fact that the RP had largely overlooked while focusing exclusively on the company’s internal financial records from a specific decade. The tribunal agreed that ignoring public records in favor of potentially incomplete internal books was an error in the verification process.
The bench further addressed the RP's reliance on the argument that the debt was . According to the , the RP was not the competent authority to interpret the application of the to a claim that had been consistently pursued through legal channels. The tribunal highlighted that the recovery suit filed in and subsequently transferred to the DRT had been stayed only due to the imposed under , which halts all legal proceedings against a corporate debtor once the insolvency process commences.
Recovery Proceedings Stayed by Corporate Insolvency
The tribunal’s decision effectively prevents RPs from using the "
" defense as a shortcut to shrink the pool of creditors. The order stated:
"The role is to collate and verify claims on the basis of the records and documents placed before it. Any genuine disputes regarding facts or law must be referred to the
."
By providing this guidance, the
has reaffirmed that the verification of claims is a gatekeeping function meant to ensure transparency, not a judicial process intended to filter out claims based on complex interpretations of limitation periods.
The has now directed the to conduct a fresh, thorough verification of Kotak Mahindra Bank’s claim. The court specifically instructed that the RP must account for any amounts already recovered through personal guarantees provided by the erstwhile promoters. This process will require the RP to look beyond the debtor’s financial statements and consider the cumulative legal documents that establish the debt’s validity.
The bank, which had faced the potential loss of a significant portion of its capital, now has a path toward having its claim formally admitted and accounted for in the resolution plan. For the insolvency resolution process of Galore Developers to move forward, the RP must now reconcile the documentation provided by the bank with the statutory requirements of the IBC, ensuring that the final accurately reflects the company’s liabilities as identified by the . The matter serves as a precedent for how future claims disputes should be handled, emphasizing that transparency and proper documentation take precedence over a 's personal assessment of legal enforceability.
insolvency resolution - claim verification - limitation act - adjudicatory power