The National Company Law Tribunal, Mumbai Bench, has dismissed an insolvency petition initiated by Oceanic Trade Minerals Private Limited against Arisinfra Solutions Private Limited. The tribunal, presided over by Member (Technical) Hariharan Neelakanta Iyer and Member (Judicial) Lakshmi Gurung, ruled that the operational creditor failed to establish a valid debt or default under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC), 2016, primarily because the underlying contract did not explicitly assign the liability for demurrage charges to the corporate debtor.

The dispute arose from a Sale/Purchase Contract dated January 16, 2023, concerning the supply of 50,000 wet metric tons of bauxite ore. Oceanic Trade Minerals alleged that Arisinfra Solutions, acting as the seller, failed to maintain the required cargo loading rates at the Umroli Port in Maharashtra, resulting in the vessel being detained beyond the contractually permissible laytime. This detention, according to the petitioner, triggered an outstanding demurrage liability of USD 131,948.78.

However, in its evaluation of the contract, the tribunal found a critical absence of clarity regarding the payment of these charges. The bench emphasized that the contract contained no provision specifically identifying the buyer or the seller as the party responsible for bearing demurrage costs in the event of loading delays. Furthermore, the tribunal noted that the fixture note, which established the specific demurrage rate of USD 35,000 per day, was a separate agreement executed exclusively between the petitioner and the vessel owner, Shakti Shipping and Trading Private Limited. Arisinfra Solutions was not a party to this agreement, and there was no evidence that the seller had ever formally acknowledged or agreed to be bound by its terms.

Contractual Ambiguity and Lack of Proof The tribunal’s findings highlighted the lack of documentary evidence to support the petitioner's claim that the seller was liable for delays caused by the vessel’s detention at the load port. In its order, the bench stated, "The documents placed on record by the Petitioner do not stipulate as to who would be responsible for delays caused by detention at the load port."

The petitioner’s reliance on the Statement of Facts signed by the vessel's master was deemed insufficient, as those documents did not explicitly address the liability for demurrage charges. Without an express contractual term or an acknowledgment by the seller, the tribunal determined that the demurrage claim could not be considered an "operational debt" within the meaning of the IBC. This ruling underscores the necessity for specific, clearly documented contractual obligations when operational creditors seek to initiate insolvency proceedings based on disputed maritime or commercial charges.

Procedural Irregularities in Demand Issuance Beyond the substantive merits of the claim, the tribunal identified significant procedural failures in how the petitioner attempted to secure payment. The petitioner had issued a debit note dated February 26, 2024, demanding immediate payment, but it was revealed during the hearing that this document was never communicated to the respondent. This lack of communication was confirmed by the petitioner’s own counsel during the proceedings, a fact that the tribunal viewed as severely undermining the legitimacy of the demand notice served under Section 8 of the IBC on February 27, 2024.

The respondent, Arisinfra Solutions, had argued that the insolvency petition was a "counterblast" to a prior petition it had filed against the petitioner, CP/1147/2023, regarding unpaid invoice amounts for the bauxite shipment. The respondent further contended that the demand notice was legally defective, as it lacked an underlying invoice—a requirement for proving a debt—and relied instead on a debit note that had not been previously served. The tribunal accepted this argument, distinguishing the present case from precedents where petitions were admitted due to pre-existing acknowledgments of debt by the corporate debtor. In this instance, no such acknowledgment existed, and the debit note appeared as an afterthought rather than a bona fide invoice.

Adherence to Established Legal Precedents In reaching its decision, the tribunal relied on established judicial precedents, including the observations of the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal in Navin Madhavji Mehta vs. Jaldhi Overseas Pte Ltd. In that case, it was established that where a corporate debtor has not admitted the liability to pay demurrage and a genuine dispute persists regarding the obligation, the provisions of the IBC cannot be used as a tool for debt recovery.

The Mumbai Bench reiterated that the insolvency resolution process is designed to protect and revive companies, not to resolve contested commercial disputes that lack clear evidence of default. As the tribunal noted, "The provisions of IBC cannot be turned into a debt recovery proceeding as it is a beneficial legislation which envisions the revival of the Corporate Debtor and bringing it back on its feet from the perils of extinction."

The tribunal concluded that since there was no evidence of an agreement between the parties regarding the demurrage liability, and given the failure to properly communicate the claim, the petition failed to meet the threshold for admission. The court affirmed that "there is no prior acknowledgment by the Respondent towards its obligation or liability to pay the demurrage." By dismissing the petition, the NCLT has reinforced the principle that Section 9 applications require unambiguous proof of debt and a clear demonstration of default that is not contingent upon disputed interpretations of service contracts or third-party agreements. The dismissal of this petition allows the parties to pursue traditional commercial litigation for the settlement of their outstanding cargo disputes.