The National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) in Mumbai has dismissed an application filed by Essar Shipping Limited seeking the revival of OGD Services Limited, an Essar Group company currently under liquidation. The decision, delivered by a bench comprising Member (Technical) Anil Raj Chellan and Member (Judicial) K.R. Saji Kumar, marks a significant reinforcement of the principle that insolvency proceedings follow a rigid statutory framework that does not accommodate ad hoc withdrawals once a liquidation order is passed. Despite the applicant settling the majority of the financial and operational debts, the tribunal concluded that it lacked the inherent authority to recall or stay a liquidation order in the absence of an express legal provision.

The dispute arose after OGD Services Limited was admitted into the Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process (CIRP) in February 2023 following a petition by Punjab National Bank. With no viable resolution plan materializing, the Committee of Creditors (CoC) unanimously moved for liquidation in early 2024. Following the tribunal’s subsequent order to wind up the entity, Essar Shipping Limited—acting as the holding company and corporate guarantor—attempted to intervene by settling dues with financial creditors, including Punjab National Bank and Union Bank of India. While the applicant sought to use these settlements as a basis for reviving OGD Services as a going concern, the tribunal maintained that the legal architecture of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC) imposes strict boundaries that the bench could not circumvent.

Statutory Boundaries and Judicial Restraint

Central to the tribunal’s reasoning was the interpretation of inherent powers granted under Rule 11 of the NCLT Rules, 2016. Essar Shipping argued that the tribunal, using its discretionary authority, could permit the withdrawal of the liquidation process to prevent an "inequitable outcome," particularly when the debt that necessitated the insolvency proceedings had been satisfied. However, the bench observed that the IBC is a self-contained statute, and judicial expansion of its procedures risked undermining the legislative intent. The tribunal cited recent Supreme Court guidance, noting that the adjudicating authority must be circumspect when exercising residuary powers under Section 60(5)(c) of the IBC if it results in procedural overreach.

The court highlighted that while Section 12A of the IBC provides a clear mechanism for the withdrawal of insolvency petitions during the resolution phase, the legislature has remained silent on such a mechanism during the liquidation phase. The order stated, “The inherent power of the Tribunal cannot be exercised to permit a withdrawal during the liquidation process, thereby conferring substantive rights on persons who would otherwise not be eligible to submit a resolution plan, which is contrary to the framework established by the Code and the allied regulations.” By rejecting the application, the NCLT signaled that it would not serve as a court of equity to craft custom relief where the governing legislation has intentionally withheld it.

Limitations of Going Concern Sales

The tribunal also scrutinized the shift in regulatory standards regarding the "going concern" sale of a corporate debtor. In its submission, the applicant highlighted the company's past successes in the oil and gas drilling sector as a reason for preservation. The bench, however, pointed to the October 2025 amendment to the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India (Liquidation Process) Regulations, which effectively removed the provision for the sale of a corporate debtor as a going concern in cases where that process had not yet commenced. This legislative shift, according to the NCLT, further demonstrated a lack of statutory preference for reviving companies through non-standard channels once they reach the liquidation stage.

The tribunal remarked on the necessity of adhering strictly to the law, observing that “the recent legislative changes also fail to indicate a preference for preserving the corporate debtor as a going concern, even at the risk of losing the value of intangible assets.” Consequently, the NCLT emphasized that attempts to use the inherent power of the court to circumvent these requirements would violate the principle of separation of powers. The bench noted that any judicial creation of a remedy not explicitly provided by the statute would create unpredictability, ultimately harming the broader objectives of the IBC, which prioritizes the time-bound and orderly resolution of distressed assets.

Impact on Stakeholder Expectations

The proceedings reflected the tension between commercial settlement and the finality of liquidation. While the applicant asserted that reviving the company would yield better results for all stakeholders, including operational creditors, the liquidator and the creditors—though acknowledging the potential for enhanced recovery—did not supersede the court’s responsibility to act within the confines of the code. The tribunal ultimately held that the absence of a provision permitting withdrawal during the liquidation process is a conscious legislative choice. By adhering to this interpretation, the court reaffirmed that even in cases where debts appear to be settled by promoters, the statutory process for liquidation must remain the final recourse, provided the law does not explicitly offer an alternative path for withdrawal.

This dismissal serves as a firm reminder to promoters that the window for settlement and revival is restricted primarily to the pre-liquidation period. As the liquidation process of OGD Services Limited continues, the decision prevents potential disruptions to the prescribed sale process, ensuring that the regulatory expectations set by the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code remain consistent. The application, having failed to clear the threshold of statutory permissibility, was formally dismissed, leaving the liquidator to proceed with the liquidation process under the established rules of the code. The ruling emphasizes that the pursuit of “commercial morality” and “public interest” cannot be achieved through a departure from the clear letter of the law, affirming the NCLT’s role as an adjudicator bound by the legislative framework.