The National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) Kolkata Bench has dismissed a high-stakes insolvency petition filed by the State Bank of India (SBI) against Rajesh Sonthalia, a personal guarantor for the debt-laden Enfield Solar Energy Limited. In a definitive ruling, the tribunal established that a creditor must strictly adhere to the contractual terms of a guarantee deed—specifically by formally invoking the guarantee—before issuing a statutory demand notice under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC). The bench, comprising Judicial Member Labh Singh and Technical Member Rekha Kantilal Shah, concluded that the bank’s failure to initiate this primary step rendered the Section 95 petition non-maintainable.

The case centered on a total outstanding debt of approximately ₹97.28 crore, comprising ₹49.38 crore in principal and ₹47.90 crore in accrued interest as of May 2025. The State Bank of India sought to trigger the insolvency resolution process against Sonthalia, who had served as a director of the principal borrower, Enfield Solar Energy Limited, during the period when the credit facilities were extended. Following the initiation of the corporate insolvency resolution process and subsequent liquidation of the corporate debtor, the bank pursued the personal guarantor to recover its losses.

However, the NCLT highlighted a critical procedural flaw in the bank’s approach. The tribunal examined the interplay between the Insolvency and Bankruptcy (Application to Adjudicating Authority for Insolvency Resolution Process for Personal Guarantors to Corporate Debtor) Rules, 2019, and the specific covenants of the deed of guarantee. The bank argued that the demand notice in Form B, served under Rule 7(1) of the PG Rules, should be interpreted as a valid invocation of the guarantee. The bench categorically rejected this position, affirming that the two processes serve distinct legal purposes and that one cannot replace the other.

The tribunal’s reasoning focused on the mandatory nature of the contract. As the bench observed, “Thus, invocation of the guarantee is a mandatory requirement against the personal guarantor before issuing of notice in Form B under Rule 7(1), and only after such invocation can the statutory requirement of serving the demand notice arise in Form B under Rule 7(1) before filing of Application under Section 95(1).”

In its analysis of the specific clauses contained in the August 14, 2013, deed of guarantee, the tribunal noted that Clause 2 clearly stipulated that the guarantor must pay the lender only “upon demand” in the event of a default. The bank relied on Clause 25 to justify its actions, but the court found this argument insufficient. The tribunal clarified, “The word 'any' used in clause 25 is with respect to service of any such demand notice issued in terms of clause 2 thus Form-B cannot be said to be any demand notice issued as contemplated in clause 2 of the Deed of the Guarantee.”

The defense, represented by counsel for the personal guarantor, had raised several objections regarding the maintainability of the petition, arguing that the claims were time-barred and that the guarantee had been executed without valid consideration for subsequent credit enhancements. While the tribunal ultimately bypassed these substantive defenses, the preliminary finding on the procedural defect provided enough grounds to dispose of the matter. The court underscored that the definition of a "guarantor" under Rule 3(1)(e) requires that the guarantee must have been invoked and remain unpaid in full or in part. Since the bank could not produce evidence of a specific demand notice invoking the guarantee prior to the issuance of the Form B notice, Sonthalia did not meet the definition of a guarantor eligible for insolvency proceedings under the current statutory framework.

This decision follows a trend of judicial scrutiny into the procedural compliance of financial creditors when targeting personal guarantors. By prioritizing the sanctity of the underlying contract of guarantee, the NCLT has reinforced the principle that creditors must follow prescribed contractual obligations before utilizing the insolvency process as a recovery tool. The court noted that because the petition was dismissed on this preliminary issue of maintainability, it was not required to adjudicate on the complex questions of limitation and the validity of the debt restructure agreements raised by the respondent.

The Resolution Professional, Daulat Resolution Services Private Limited, had previously filed a report recommending the admission of the petition, but the court found that the foundation for such a recommendation was inherently defective. As the litigation concludes for now, the registry has been directed to serve copies of the order to all parties involved, ensuring that the finality of the decision is communicated immediately. For stakeholders, this case serves as a sharp reminder that the procedural rigors of the IBC are not merely formalities but essential gateways to the insolvency mechanism. The dismissal of the petition effectively halts the insolvency proceedings against Rajesh Sonthalia, leaving the bank to reassess its strategy in light of the tribunal's strict interpretation of guarantee invocation protocols.