A coalition of opposition leaders, led by the Leader of the Opposition Rahul Gandhi, has moved the Supreme Court of India with a formal application seeking permission to serve 48 written interrogatories upon the Election Commission of India ( ECI ). The move marks a significant escalation in the ongoing legal scrutiny regarding the nationwide Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls, with the petitioners demanding sworn affidavits from the Chief Election Commissioner and other Election Commissioners to clarify the poll body's internal decision-making processes.

The application, filed by ten prominent opposition leaders alongside Gandhi, centers on allegations that the ECI has operated with insufficient transparency during the SIR exercise. The petitioners contend that the commission’s previous counter-affidavits , while asserting unanimous decision-making, have failed to provide the essential documentation required to verify these claims. By seeking answers through formal interrogatories, the petitioners aim to compel the commission to disclose specific file numbers, meeting minutes, and the precise nature of the consensus achieved among the three-member body.

Challenging the Claim of Unanimous Decision-Making

At the heart of the dispute is the discrepancy between the ECI ’s formal responses to the Supreme Court and its earlier disclosures under the Right to Information Act . In a counter-affidavit affirmed by Deputy Election Commissioner Bhanu Prakash Yeturu, the poll body stated that the orders for the SIR were issued following a unanimous decision by all three members of the Commission. However, the petitioners point to an August 2025 response from the commission’s own First Appellate Authority , which suggested that no formal decision had been reached to initiate a nationwide SIR at that time.

The 48 interrogatories seek to bridge this gap by asking the ECI to detail exactly how the decision-making was conducted. Specifically, the questions probe whether the commissioners reached their decisions through formal meetings, the circulation of files, or electronic communication. The petitioners have demanded that the ECI provide verifiable dates and corresponding records for these deliberations. Furthermore, they are calling for the disclosure of any instances where individual commissioners might have expressed reservations, dissents, or suggestions for modifications regarding the SIR orders issued in June 2025 , October 2025 , and May 2026 .

Scrutiny of Voter Deletions and Digital Systems

Beyond the procedural question of authorization, the application raises critical concerns regarding the technical management of electoral databases. The petitioners have sought granular data on voter exclusions, demanding a state-wise and Union Territory-wise breakdown of electors removed from the rolls, categorized by the reasons for such actions—such as death, migration, or alleged ineligibility. This demand stems from broader anxieties regarding the integrity of the electoral roll during a period of intense administrative revision.

The interrogatories further delve into the modifications made to the online Form 6 registration process. The opposition leaders have requested clarification on the introduction of a new declaration requirement on the form, questioning who authorized this addition, when it was implemented, and whether the Commission formally ratified the change. The petition seeks to understand how many applications were rejected or left unprocessed due to these new, potentially restrictive requirements.

The application also addresses the functioning of the ECINET system, the digital backbone of the electoral registration process. The petitioners are inquiring whether the system allowed electoral registration officers to restore entries that had been omitted or deleted, and if such functionality was restricted at any point during the SIR. Moreover, they have questioned whether the Commission considered a proposal for an independent audit of the personnel who have access to, and the ability to alter, the central electoral database.

The Procedural Path Forward

The legal strategy employed by the petitioners relies on the Supreme Court’s existing rules regarding the discovery of facts . By seeking permission to serve these interrogatories, the opposition bloc hopes to force a higher level of disclosure than that typically provided in standard counter-affidavits . The application asserts that the commission’s reliance on “ bare assertions ” without supporting official records falls short of the requirements for transparency in matters concerning the constitutional duty of conducting free and fair elections.

Should the Supreme Court grant permission for the service of these interrogatories, the ECI will be required to provide sworn, record-supported responses to each of the 48 questions. The petition explicitly notes that if the commission attempts to claim privilege over any specific document, it must identify the record in question and state the precise grounds for withholding it, thereby allowing the court to independently assess the validity of the claim.

The filing includes signatures from a wide spectrum of the opposition, including leaders from the Indian National Congress , the Trinamool Congress , the Samajwadi Party , the Rashtriya Janata Dal , the Shiv Sena (UBT) , the Communist Party of India (Marxist), the Communist Party of India , the Jharkhand Mukti Morcha , the Nationalist Congress Party (Sharad Pawar) , and the Indian Union Muslim League . Two additional parliamentarians, VCK President Thol. Thirumavalavan and National Conference MP Sajjat Ahmad Kichloo, have subsequently joined the petition.

The Supreme Court’s response to this application will likely dictate the next stage of the proceedings, as the court determines whether the current evidentiary record is sufficient or if the commission must be held to a more rigorous standard of disclosure. The matter remains pending as both the petitioners and the poll body await further directions from the bench regarding the scope and nature of the sought-after discovery. The court’s decision will be a pivotal test of the institutional transparency required of the election management body during significant nationwide electoral revisions.