The has dismissed a petition seeking a review of its , order, which had previously declined to interfere with the demolition of the Takiya Masjid in Ujjain. A Bench comprising Justice Vikram Nath and Justice Sandeep Mehta further denied the petitioners' request for an open-court hearing, opting instead to dispose of the matter by circulation.
In its , order, the Court affirmed that the challenge brought by the petitioners failed to meet the threshold required for a . The Bench concluded that their previous ruling did not contain any legal infirmity that would necessitate a departure from their earlier findings. As stated in the Court’s order: “We have perused the as well as the grounds in support thereof and are convinced that the order dated , of which review has been sought, does not suffer from any warranting its reconsideration.”
The legal dispute centered on the demolition of a structure identified by the petitioners as a 200-year-old mosque, which was razed in to facilitate the expansion of the parking area for the Shri Mahakaleshwar Temple complex. The petitioners, a group of thirteen residents who stated they had regularly offered prayers at the site, had challenged the legality of the demolition, asserting that the property held significant religious and historical status.
Contentions of the Petitioners The petitioners had maintained that the mosque was formally notified as a in and had remained operational until its demolition. Their legal challenge was multifaceted, invoking a range of statutory protections. They argued that the ’s actions were in direct violation of the , and the .
Furthermore, the petitioners raised concerns regarding the procedural fairness of the land acquisition process. They alleged that the government had engaged in irregularities by granting compensation to unauthorized occupants and encroachers in a move they claimed was intended to establish a false legitimacy for the acquisition. Additionally, they sought relief under the , contending that the acquisition did not comply with the stringent requirements mandated by the law for such projects.
Procedural History Before escalating the matter to the Supreme Court, the petitioners had pursued relief through the . A single judge of the High Court had initially dismissed their , a decision that was subsequently upheld by a upon appeal. The residents then sought intervention from the Supreme Court through a , which resulted in the dismissal of their challenge on .
The subsequent filing of the served as the final attempt to reopen the case. However, the Supreme Court’s narrow jurisdiction over review petitions remains restricted to rectifying “,” a standard the Bench found was not met in this instance. By rejecting the application for an open-court hearing, the Court effectively signaled that no new evidence or legal arguments of sufficient weight had been presented to disturb the finality of the original judgment.
Implications of the Ruling The dismissal of the marks the conclusion of the litigation process concerning the mosque's demolition and the associated land acquisition for the Mahakaleshwar Temple expansion project. Because the Supreme Court found no grounds for reconsideration, the merits of the arguments surrounding the Places of Worship Act and the Waqf Act remain as they stood after the November 2025 order.
The Court’s decision reiterates the limited scope of , emphasizing that such proceedings are not intended to be a rehearing of the original appeal. As the case reaches its conclusion, the state authorities may now proceed with the infrastructure project without further . The order stands as a definitive end to the current legal challenge, with all pending applications filed by the parties formally disposed of by the Bench.
judicial review - land acquisition