AI Overview...
- Cause of Action Arising When Judgment Was Reserved
- In legal proceedings, the cause of action can be considered to have arisen at the time when the court reserves judgment, especially if the judgment involves significant administrative or procedural decisions that impact parties' rights. Several sources highlight that the reservation of judgment does not negate the existence of a cause of action; rather, it marks a procedural stage where the court's decision is pending, but the rights and obligations of parties are often considered to have been established or triggered by the initial pleadings and submissions.
- For instance, in SRI SATYAJIT MOHANTY VS STATE OF ORISSA - Orissa, the court's discussion on auction sale of public property indicates that the cause of action related to public auction and property disposal arises from the initiation of the auction process, with the judgment or decision (including when it is reserved) being a subsequent procedural step. Similarly, in Jawahar Lal Nehru University VS Flora Gupta - Delhi, the court notes that the cause of action can be linked to the failure or success of administrative inquiries, which are often considered to have arisen when the initial allegations or notices are issued, even if the final judgment or order is reserved.
- In some cases, courts have clarified that cause of action may be deemed to have arisen when the court reserves judgment if the reservation is accompanied by substantive legal or administrative implications, such as the initiation of criminal proceedings or the issuance of notices that affect the parties' rights (N. C. Sridhar VS Secretary to Government, Tourism, Culture, Religious Endowments Department, Chennai - Madras, MSPL Limited VS State of Karnataka - Karnataka, Chandra Rajakumari VS Commissioner of Police, Hyderabad - Andhra Pradesh).
- Analysis and Conclusion:**
- The cause of action is generally considered to have arisen at the point when the underlying dispute or legal issue is initiated through pleadings, notices, or administrative actions, rather than solely upon the final pronouncement or judgment.
- The reservation of judgment signifies a procedural pause, but does not necessarily reset or negate the cause of action; instead, it often marks the culmination of the initial stages of dispute, after which the judgment will determine the final rights and liabilities.
- Therefore, in legal practice, the cause of action can be said to have arisen when substantive proceedings or notices are initiated, even if the judgment is reserved, provided that the reservation does not fundamentally alter the nature of the dispute.
Search Results for "Cause of Action Aroused when the Judgment was Reserved"
2021 0 Supreme(Mad) 1858 • India - Madras
S.M.SUBRAMANIAM
alone will be nominated to Post of Trustees and there is no dispute among members and other office bearers but some of the disputes aroused ... lenient view in respect of dealing with such offences against Minor Deities and in such Court has to step-in and initiate appropriate action ... including criminal actions are to be initiated against persons who all are accountable and liable - Respondents shall not take any ... It is not seriously disputed in this case that the power to amend the scheme has been reserved in view....
2023 0 Supreme(Kar) 499 • India - Karnataka
PRASANNA B. VARALE, M. G. S. KAMAL
notices issued, and obligations of state authorities following the Supreme Court judgment. ... and applicable laws, notably the Supreme Court’s direction for transferring approvals during auction of Category 'C' mines. ... mining leases - Petitioners, as successful bidders, contended that they were entitled to transfer of forest clearances in light of judgments ... In its Judgment, the Supreme Court has further directed that “the concerned authority will take expeditious action for the grunt of the stat....
2013 0 Supreme(Ori) 432 • India - Orissa
I.MAHANTY, B.N.MAHAPATRA
Whether the BDA was justified in publishing an advertisement for auction sale of residential plots. ... Additionally, the court noted that the best method of disposal of public property is by public auction. ... JUDGMENT : ... B.N. ... Further, placing reliance on the judgment of this Court in the case of Shri Nagen Kumar Barik Vs. ... Further placing reliance on the judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Bachhittar Singh Vs. ... It is well settled that the concept of legitimate expectation ha....
• India - Andhra Pradesh
S.V.MARUTHI, A.HANUMANTHU
promise or withdrawing an undertaking and it is less than a right and it arises when a body by representation or by past practice aroused ... undertaking or a contract or distribution of largess by Government or negativing representation made by High Court or by past practice aroused ... ceases to be an Advocate and by that time he has not completed years of practice and therefore ineligible - Court may also refer to judgment ... Out of the same 11 were in the general category and 3 in the reserved category. Three vacanc....
2020 0 Supreme(Del) 60 • India - Delhi
C.HARI SHANKAR
part of our legal jurisprudence, arises when an administrative body by reason of a representation or by past practice or conduct aroused ... The DDA had, time and again, in the official notings, opined that the case of the petitioner was meritorious, and the petitioner deserved ... ALLOTMENT OF LAND - EDUCATIONAL INSTITUTION - SENIOR SECONDARY SCHOOL - ALLOTMENT OF LAND - APPROVAL BY LG - CHANGE OF POLICY - AUCTION ... The learned counsel for the respondent does not have any objection to the same except that the petitioner cannot file a w....
1997 0 Supreme(AP) 1065 • India - Andhra Pradesh
B.K.SOMASEKHARA
materials under provisions of laws stated above and shall be duty bound to consider all such materials including all enumerated in judgment ... Till such a legislation is brought out, the stipulations in this Judgment shall be operative to be mandatorily followed by the Government and the appropriate authorities. ... necessary and upon that the authorities shall take appropriate action against all or any of the persons in accordance with law. ... What we have to see is that whether a class, not an isolated case, into whose hands the book....
2023 Supreme(Online)(KER) 13230 • India - High Court of Kerala
M.R.ANITHA, J
of action and defendant's residence. ... of action arose from that jurisdiction. ... of action arose, thereby supporting the return of the plaint. ... Learned counsel for the 5th defendant, on the other hand, would vehemently contend that the head office of the plaintiff company is at Ernakulam and part of cause of action also arouse at Ernakulam since, as per the averments in the plaint, cause of action includes the release of ... JUDGMENT....
2012 0 Supreme(Del) 3125 • India - Delhi
D.MURUGESAN, S.RAVINDRA BHAT
Vikram Nandrajog, learned counsel for JNU, contended that the impugned judgment cannot be sustained, and that the Single Judge should have reserved liberty to the authorities to conduct an inquiry, having regard to the totality of circumstances, once it was found that there was no inquiry. ... A show cause notice dated 15th July, 2007 was given asking petitioner to show cause as to why disciplinary action be not initiated against them without giving the copy of the enquiry report. ... The petitioner was....
2013 0 Supreme(Kar) 491 • India - Karnataka
ANAND BYRAREDDY
is the subject-matter of the action is delivered to him. ... JUDGMENT ... 1. This appeal is by the plaintiff before the trial court. ... 2. The parties are referred to by their rank before the trial court for the sake of convenience. ... But if the cheque had been for some unusually large sum, perhaps suspicion might have been aroused; but whether the cheque is or is not for an unusually large sum is really a question of degree. ... It was finally held that in the cheque presented by Thallon there was no note of alarm or of warning whi....
2009 0 Supreme(Del) 1090 • India - Delhi
MUKUL MUDGAL, REVA KHETRAPAL
JUDGMENT ... MUKUL MUDGAL,J. ... 1. ... [Vide Hindustan Development Corporation (supra)]” In the light of the material placed before us it cannot at this stage be stated that the action not to renew the licences for another term of 5 years is so arbitrary or unreasonable so as to be covered by the position of law laid down in the above judgment ... It is well settled that the concept of legitimate expectation has no role to play where the State action is as a public policy or in the public interest unless the ....
Filter by Legal Phrase
