G.O. No.270/2005/H & FWD dated 25/10/2005 - Official government directive related to the Kerala Medical Education sector DR.ABDUL RASHEED
vs
STATE OF KERALA - Kerala.
Fee fixation in medical colleges - The Kerala Medical Education Act, Section 8, and the scope of the Admission and Fee Regulatory Committee (AFRC) were examined. Courts upheld the authority of the AFRC to regulate fees but clarified its limitations, such as not disallowing expenses arbitrarily. Notably, judgments in Kerala and Maharashtra (e.g., SCC 2005, 6 SCC 537 and KLT 2017, 4 KLT 809) support the view that AFRC's powers are confined to fee regulation within prescribed limits THE CHAIRMAN, AL-AZHAR MEDICAL COLLEGE AND SUPER SPECIALITY HOSPITAL Vs STATE OF KERALA - Kerala, THE CHAIRMAN Vs THE STATE OF KERALA - Kerala.
Service rules for Homoeopathic Medical Colleges - Kerala government formulated rules in 2001 for government and private homoeopathic colleges, with subsequent judicial review. The courts dismissed appeals challenging these rules, affirming their validity and the state's authority over such regulations DR SANU MUKUNDAN vs STATE OF KERALA - Kerala.
Challenges by private medical colleges - Multiple writ petitions questioned orders of the AFRC regarding fee fixation and expenses. Courts consistently upheld the AFRC's authority, emphasizing that the committee's powers are limited to fee regulation and do not extend to disallowing legitimate expenses. Judicial decisions reinforce the stance that the AFRC's scope is well-defined and within legal bounds THE CHAIRMAN Vs THE STATE OF KERALA - Kerala, DM EDUCATION RESEARCH FOUNDATION, Vs STATE OF KERALA, - Kerala, THE CHAIRMAN, AL-AZHAR MEDICAL COLLEGE AND SUPER SPECIALITY HOSPITAL Vs STATE OF KERALA - Kerala.
Judicial stance on AFRC's powers - Courts, including Kerala High Court rulings, have consistently held that while the AFRC can regulate fees, it cannot arbitrarily disallow expenses or interfere beyond its statutory mandate. This is supported by references to relevant case law, notably the Kerala and Maharashtra judgments THE CHAIRMAN, AL-AZHAR MEDICAL COLLEGE AND SUPER SPECIALITY HOSPITAL Vs STATE OF KERALA - Kerala, THE DIRECTOR vs THE STATE OF KERALA - Kerala.
Analysis and Conclusion:
The government of Kerala's directives, combined with judicial rulings, establish that the Kerala Medical Education Act and related regulations empower the AFRC primarily to regulate fees, not to scrutinize or disallow individual expenses beyond prescribed limits. Courts have upheld the authority of the state and the AFRC within their statutory scope, emphasizing that fee fixation involves balancing institutional expenses with regulatory oversight. The consistent legal position underscores that while fee regulation is comprehensive, it does not extend to micromanaging or disallowing legitimate expenses of medical colleges.
(MS) NO.270/2005/H & FWD DATED 25/10/2005.
Fees - Medical Colleges - Kerala Medical Education Act - Section 8; Article 19(1)(g) - The court held that while educational institutions ... a series of writ petitions challenging the fee fixation by the Admission and Fee Regulatory Committee for Medical Education in Kerala ... State of Kerala (Supra). ... State of Maharashtra [(2005) 6 SCC 537]. ... State of Kerala [(2017) 4 KLT 809] where the scope of the powers of the AFRC has been considered. ... State of Kerala (Supra) in support....
As per GO(P) No.79/2001/H&FWD dated 19.3.2001 Government of Kerala formulated a service rule for teachers of Government Homoeopathic Medical College named Kerala State Homoeopathic Medical Colleges service rules 2001 and the same criteria is following for promotions of teachers in private Homoeopathic ... The judgment of the learned single Judge was challenged by the State of Kerala and the Principal and the Controlling Officer in WA No.189/05. That appeal was heard along with connected appeals and was dismissed by Ext.....
of the Case: Multiple writ petitions were filed challenging the orders of the Admission and Fee Regulatory Committee in Kerala ... State of Kerala (Supra). ... State of Maharashtra [(2005) 6 SCC 537]. ... State of Kerala [(2017) 4 KLT 809] where the scope of the powers of the AFRC has been considered. ... State of Kerala (Supra) in support of their contention that the AFRC has no power to disallow any expenses, we do not agree. ... STATE OF KERALA AND ANOTHER REPORED IN 2017 (5) KHC ....
Fact of the Case: A batch of writ petitions was filed by self-financing medical colleges in Kerala challenging orders ... State of Kerala (Supra). ... State of Maharashtra [(2005) 6 SCC 537]. ... State of Kerala [(2017) 4 KLT 809] where the scope of the powers of the AFRC has been considered. ... State of Kerala (Supra) in support of their contention that the AFRC has no power to disallow any expenses, we do not agree. ... STATE OF KERALA AND ANOTHER REPORED IN 2017 (5) KHC 919.
State of Kerala (Supra). ... State of Maharashtra [(2005) 6 SCC 537]. ... KERALA PIN:679302. ... KERALA -676517REPRESENTEDBY ITS PRINCIPAL. ... JOHN A, VILLIMANGALATHU, NAVEEN NIVAS, CHATHANOOR, KOLLAM, KERALA-691 572.
State of Kerala (Supra). ... State of Maharashtra [(2005) 6 SCC 537]. ... KERALA PIN:679302. ... KERALA -676517REPRESENTEDBY ITS PRINCIPAL. ... JOHN A, VILLIMANGALATHU, NAVEEN NIVAS, CHATHANOOR, KOLLAM, KERALA-691 572.
State of Kerala (Supra). ... State of Maharashtra [(2005) 6 SCC 537]. ... KERALA PIN:679302. ... KERALA -676517REPRESENTEDBY ITS PRINCIPAL. ... JOHN A, VILLIMANGALATHU, NAVEEN NIVAS, CHATHANOOR, KOLLAM, KERALA-691 572.
State of Kerala (Supra). ... State of Maharashtra [(2005) 6 SCC 537]. ... KERALA PIN:679302. ... KERALA -676517REPRESENTEDBY ITS PRINCIPAL. ... JOHN A, VILLIMANGALATHU, NAVEEN NIVAS, CHATHANOOR, KOLLAM, KERALA-691 572.
State of Kerala (Supra). ... State of Maharashtra [(2005) 6 SCC 537]. ... KERALA PIN:679302. ... KERALA -676517REPRESENTEDBY ITS PRINCIPAL. ... JOHN A, VILLIMANGALATHU, NAVEEN NIVAS, CHATHANOOR, KOLLAM, KERALA-691 572.
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.