AI Overview...
-
Simple Mortgage vs. Conditional Sale - Several sources clarify that a mortgage can be characterized as a simple mortgage or as a mortgage by conditional sale, which is considered an anomalous or sui generis mortgage. A simple mortgage generally involves a straightforward pledge of property as security for a loan, with the right of redemption. In contrast, a mortgage by conditional sale involves a transfer of ownership with conditions attached, often creating usufructuary rights or other complex arrangements. Pawan Rekha Devi VS Kesho Yadav - Patna, Sanjay Kumar Pandey @ Abhinu Kumar Pandey VS Rajdeo Yadav - Patna, Dipak Singh S/o Late Ramdhan Singh VS Dinesh Singh S/o Late Mahagu Singh - Patna, Binapani Purkayastha VS Narendra Kumar Purkayastha - Gauhati, Dipak Singh VS Denesh Singh - Current Civil Cases
-
Nature of Conditional Sale Mortgage - Courts have held that a mortgage by conditional sale often combines elements of usufructuary rights and conditional sale, making it an anomalous or mixed mortgage. Such mortgages may include rights to redeem, usufruct, or other conditions that distinguish them from simple mortgages. The validity and enforceability depend on the specific execution of the deed and the rights retained or transferred. Pawan Rekha Devi VS Kesho Yadav - Patna, Dipak Singh S/o Late Ramdhan Singh VS Dinesh Singh S/o Late Mahagu Singh - Patna, Dipak Singh VS Denesh Singh - Current Civil Cases
-
Legal Implications and Court Rulings - Courts have recognized that a mortgage by conditional sale is not a simple mortgage, and it often carries different rights and obligations, including the possibility of foreclosure or sale, but under specific conditions. Some judgments emphasize that such mortgages are anomalous and require careful interpretation regarding foreclosure rights and redemption. The courts have also held that when a mortgage deed is executed as a conditional sale, the rights of the mortgagor and mortgagee are governed by the terms of the deed, not by the provisions applicable to simple mortgages. Pawan Rekha Devi VS Kesho Yadav - Patna, Binapani Purkayastha VS Narendra Kumar Purkayastha - Gauhati, Dipak Singh VS Denesh Singh - Current Civil Cases
-
Redemption and Foreclosure Rights - In cases involving conditional sale mortgages, the right to redeem remains, but the process and rights differ from those in a simple mortgage. Courts have clarified that a mortgage by conditional sale may not always entitle the mortgagee to foreclosure unless specific conditions are met, and the nature of the mortgage affects the remedies available. Some judgments note that such mortgages may require a sale or foreclosure process aligned with the terms of the deed. Sanjay Kumar Pandey @ Abhinu Kumar Pandey VS Rajdeo Yadav - Patna, Binapani Purkayastha VS Narendra Kumar Purkayastha - Gauhati, Dipak Singh VS Denesh Singh - Current Civil Cases
-
Summary - Overall, while a mortgage in simple form is straightforward, a mortgage by conditional sale is more complex, often regarded as an anomalous or sui generis form of security. Its validity, enforceability, and remedies depend heavily on the specific deed's terms, with courts emphasizing the importance of distinguishing between simple mortgages and those created by conditional sale. Recognizing the nature of the mortgage is crucial for determining the appropriate legal procedures for foreclosure or redemption. Pawan Rekha Devi VS Kesho Yadav - Patna, Sanjay Kumar Pandey @ Abhinu Kumar Pandey VS Rajdeo Yadav - Patna, Dipak Singh S/o Late Ramdhan Singh VS Dinesh Singh S/o Late Mahagu Singh - Patna, Binapani Purkayastha VS Narendra Kumar Purkayastha - Gauhati, Dipak Singh VS Denesh Singh - Current Civil Cases
Search Results for "Mortgage is Simple by Deed but in Decree its Conditional Sale"
2001 0 Supreme(Pat) 264 • India - Patna
S.N.PATHAK
the mortgage-deed. ... Fact of the Case: The plaintiff filed a title suit seeking foreclosure of a mortgage-deed. ... Act and Evidence Act - Sec. 68, Sec. 70 of the Evidence Act - The court discussed the validity of a mortgage-deed, the requirement ... The appellate Court further held that a mortgage-deed with conditional sale was executed and not simple mortgage, as pleaded by....
2025 0 Supreme(Pat) 458 • India - Patna
KHATIM REZA
Transfer of Property Act, 1882 – Section 58(c) – Redemption of mortgage – Mortgage by conditional sale – ... amount exceeding mortgage money, as defendants agreed to reconvey property at same price – Validity of plaintiffs' sale deed was ... set aside and judgment and decree passed by Additional Munsif, restored and affirmed – Appeal allowed. ... by conditional sale. ... way of conditional #HL_STA....
1967 0 Supreme(Pat) 70 • India - Patna
SHAMBHU PRASAD SINGH, RAMRATNA SINGH
The court concluded that the mortgage was an anomalous mortgage and the plaintiff was entitled to a mortgage decree for sale of the ... The court concluded that the mortgage was an anomalous mortgage and the plaintiff was entitled to a mortgage decree for sale of the ... The court also held that an anomalous mortgagee is entitled to obtain a decree for sale of t....
2010 0 Supreme(Pat) 390 • India - Patna
SHIVA KIRTI SINGH, JYOTI SARAN
mortgage by conditional sale. ... Finding of the Court: The court found that the mortgage deed created a mortgage by conditional sale with usufructury ... Ratio Decidendi: The court held that the mortgage deed created a mortgage by conditional sale with usufructury rights, and ... of the mortgaged property when the mortgage....
1990 0 Supreme(Gau) 60 • India - Gauhati
R.K.MANISANA SINGH
The court held that the mortgage was anomalous because it was not a simple mortgage, a mortgage by conditional sale, an usufructuary ... The court held that a simple money decree would meet the ends of justice because the mortgagees had no right to foreclose or sale ... The court further held that the mortgagees had no right to foreclose or sale by contract or agreement and that a simple money #HL....
1957 0 Supreme(Pat) 11 • India - Patna
AHMAD, CHOUDHARY
Subsequently in the title suit No. 84 of 1943 arising out of this mortgage a preliminary mortgage decree was passed on 29th July ... Thereafter on 27th June, 1953 before any step had been taken for execution of that mortgage decree, the property under mortgage, ... the passing of the mortgage decree under execution, and, therefore, it was not necessary for the decree-holders to obtain a fresh ... a mortgage by #HL_....
• India - Current Civil Cases
SHIVA KIRTI SINGH, JYOTI SARAN
mortgage was a combination of usufructury mortgage and mortgage by conditional sale and thus, it was anomalous mortgage but for ... a decree for foreclosure, rights of plaintiff to redeem mortgaged property remained intact—Impugned decree of appellate Court that ... by conditional sale with usufractury rights —Trial court rightly held that since defendants in suit never took any steps for obtainin....
1980 0 Supreme(Pat) 215 • India - Patna
P.S.SAHAY, K.B.N.SINGH
by conditional sale, as they lacked the essential characteristics of a mortgage by conditional sale. ... lacked the essential characteristics of a mortgage by conditional sale. ... Whether the mortgage deeds in question were usufructuary mortgage bonds or mortgages by conditional sale? 2. ... In our opinion, where a person executes a kot kobala or mort....
1892 0 Supreme(Mad) 110 • India - Madras
M.AYYAR, BEST
the end of which it becomes redeemable as a simple mortgage. ... in the case of a simple or usufructuary mortgage, and a kanom is in fact a usufructuary mortgage for a period of twelve years, at ... The Court also emphasized that the former decree did not contain a direction for foreclosure, and the relation of mortgagor and mortgagee ... It is clear from paragraph 34 of the Report of the Law Commissioners of 15th November 1879 that there may be a combination of a #HL....
1953 0 Supreme(J&K) 11 • India - Jammu and Kashmir
JANKI NATH WAZIR, JIA LAL KILAM
the plaintiff had specifically abandoned his rights on the mortgaged property and had prayed for a simple money decree. ... the plaintiff had specifically abandoned his rights on the mortgaged property and had prayed for a simple money decree. ... MORTGAGE - RESITUTION OF MORTGAGED PROPERTY ACT - APPLICABILITY - SIMPLE MORTGAGE - SUIT FOR RECOVERY OF MONEY - NOT WITHIN JURISDICTION ... ... His argument is that the....
Filter by Legal Phrase
