The has ruled that a state-level cannot evade the application of the ’s simply by citing its lack of status as a Central government entity. In a significant judgment, the court clarified that when a state statutory authority voluntarily opts to route its procurement through a (CPSE), it binds itself to the policy frameworks and administrative schemes governing that . The ruling ensures that contractors are not left without recourse when a Central agency acts on behalf of a state body, effectively preventing the latter from selectively distancing itself from the financial obligations inherent in the settlement mechanism.
The case originated from a contractual dispute involving the construction of road works on the Noida–Greater Noida Expressway. The contract was awarded by , a , on behalf of the . Following disputes, an passed an award on , directing the payment of approximately ₹9.44 crore to the contractor, , with interest at 12% per annum. While IRCON challenged the award, the petitioner sought to invoke the Vivad se Vishwas II scheme, introduced in 2023, to resolve the matter. Despite the scheme’s intent to clear litigation backlogs, IRCON rejected the settlement proposal, contending that it required express permission and funding confirmation from the , which the authority had withheld.
Resolving the Conflict
The central legal friction lay in the interpretation of , which addresses scenarios where a utilizes a to execute projects. The respondents argued that because the operates as an of the , it falls outside the jurisdiction of a scheme exclusively designed for Central government organizations. However, the High Court dismantled this defense, emphasizing that the scheme does not restrict the term “” to Central government entities alone.
Justice Amit Mahajan, in his decision, observed that the scheme was introduced as a one-time measure to address the financial losses incurred by the government due to prolonged litigation and the accumulation of high-interest liabilities. By routing the construction project through IRCON—a recognized under the scheme—the effectively accepted the regulatory framework governing that entity. The court remarked, “By choosing to route the procurement through a Central Government agency, Respondent No. 2 necessarily subjected the arrangement in respect of matters governed by the applicable policy to the framework prescribed for such procurement.”
The court further noted that the distinction between the and the is clearly defined by the scheme's functional architecture. While the is the primary contact for the contractor, the is tasked with the financial responsibility of funding the settlement, a duty it cannot evade once the procurement process has been legally established.
Mandatory Nature of the Settlement Mechanism
The judgment underscored that the is the sole competent authority to accept settlement proposals, leaving no room for the bureaucratic vetoing that IRCON attempted to exercise. The court’s interpretation of the “” within the scheme ensures that procuring entities cannot abdicate their decision-making power by referring the final determination to the .
“The thus employed in leaves no room for doubt that the would be the competent authority to accept settlement, and it cannot abdicate the obligation entrusted to it under by referring the ultimate decision to Respondent No. 2,” the court held.
Because the petitioner’s claim was well within the ₹500 crore threshold specified under the scheme, the court determined that IRCON was legally obligated to accept the claim once the were satisfied. The court rejected the notion that the could wait for the ’s permission, noting that such a requirement would render the “” initiative entirely ineffective. Furthermore, the court clarified that the ongoing challenge to the under , does not create an against settling the dispute under the scheme. The provision specifically permits cases that are under appeal to participate, provided the contractor accepts the calculated settlement amount.
Operational Consequences for Future Procurement
This ruling sets a robust precedent for how disputes involving state-funded projects executed by Central entities should be handled. By holding that the must provide the necessary budget for the settlement, the court ensured that the contractor receives the benefit of the amnesty scheme without being caught in the middle of a jurisdictional tug-of-war between the Central and state entities.
The court ultimately set aside IRCON’s rejection of the settlement claim, finding it legally unsustainable under the framework of the 2023 scheme. The High Court has now directed IRCON to proceed with the execution of the settlement, placing a clear mandate on both the to finalize the terms and the to provide the required funds. This decision reinforces the utility of the Vivad se Vishwas initiative as a tool for clearing the backlog of contractual disputes, regardless of the underlying complexity of the public-procurement structures involved. The petition was allowed, ensuring the petitioner can finally move toward a conclusive resolution of the decade-old .
contractual disputes - arbitration award settlement