The Supreme Court of India has acquitted a man convicted in a 2011 double murder case, firmly reiterating that statements recorded by police during investigation cannot be treated as substantive evidence, even if witnesses later turn hostile in court. The bench comprising Justice Satish Chandra Sharma and Justice Nongmeikapam Kotiswar Singh set aside the conviction of the appellant, Naresh, who had been sentenced to life imprisonment for the deaths of two widows in Bhiwani, Haryana. The ruling emphasizes that the procedural safeguards under the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, must be strictly observed, and that evidence cannot be manufactured from inadmissible sources.

The case originated from the discovery of two deceased women, Suman and Shakuntla, in their village on April 17, 2011. While the prosecution initially alleged that the victims were targeted due to their supposed involvement in prostitution—an accusation often associated with "honour killings"—the trial court’s reliance on previous statements of witnesses proved to be legally flawed. During the trial, every private witness, including the son of one of the deceased, disowned their earlier statements made to the police. Despite this widespread hostility from prosecution witnesses, both the trial court and the High Court of Punjab and Haryana had proceeded to convict the appellant by treating his previous police statements as reliable evidence of guilt.

In its judgment, the Supreme Court clarified the scope of Section 162 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, noting that a statement to police is prohibited from being used for any purpose other than the limited scope of contradicting a witness under Section 145 of the Indian Evidence Act. The court underscored that proving a contradiction in court merely impeaches a witness's credibility; it does not transform the out-of-court statement into evidence of the facts contained within it. Justice Sharma noted in the ruling: “A proved contradiction may show that the witness is unreliable, but it cannot show that what he told the police is true.”

The prosecution's case was further hampered by significant lapses in the investigation. The initial FIR and inquest reports cited a blunt weapon, a danda, as the cause of death. However, post-mortem reports revealed that the victims had sustained multiple incised, bone-deep wounds. In an apparent attempt to align the case with medical findings, investigators later attributed the killings to a sharp-edged weapon, a gandasi, through subsequent disclosure statements. The Supreme Court found that these discrepancies undermined the credibility of the entire investigation. The court noted: “The investigation altered its account of the weapon after the post-mortem. The gaps so created were filled by the courts below with statements which the law does not permit to be used as evidence.”

The bench also addressed the issue of parity, pointing out that the High Court had previously acquitted a co-accused, Subhash, based on the same evidentiary framework that was applied to the appellant. By relying on police statements that were never substantiated in court, the lower courts had created an artificial distinction between the two accused, which the Supreme Court ruled was unsustainable. Since the evidence against both men was of an identical nature and quality, the principles of fairness required that the appellant be entitled to the same acquittal as his co-accused.

Forensic evidence similarly failed to provide a link between the appellant and the crime. While human blood was detected on the appellant's clothing and the recovered weapons, the blood group remained inconclusive in every instance, and the origin of the blood could not be determined. The court rejected the trial court’s reliance on these inconclusive forensic results, stressing that in a circumstantial case, the prosecution must demonstrate a complete chain of events that leaves no other reasonable hypothesis than the guilt of the accused. By falling short of this standard, the prosecution’s reliance on mere suspicion was deemed insufficient to justify a conviction for a grave offense such as murder.

The Supreme Court’s decision concludes a legal battle spanning fifteen years. By vacating the judgment, the Court has ordered the immediate release of the appellant and the refund of any fines paid under the original sentence. Furthermore, acknowledging the tragic nature of the deaths, the Court has recommended that the District Legal Services Authority, Bhiwani, review the case for potential compensation to the families of the victims under the applicable Victim Compensation Scheme. This ruling serves as a vital precedent, reinforcing the strict application of evidence laws in criminal proceedings and ensuring that hearsay or uncorroborated police statements are not used to bypass the necessity of proving guilt beyond a reasonable doubt in a court of law.