The of India has set aside proceedings initiated by the State of Odisha for the expansion of a mining project operated by in the Sundergarh district. In a judgment delivered on , a bench comprising Justice Dipankar Datta and Justice Satish Chandra Sharma ruled that the acquisition was legally unsustainable due to the failure of the authorities to secure the mandatory prior consent of the concerned and the required percentage of affected families. By overturning the ’s decision, the apex court reaffirmed the centrality of community participation as a non-negotiable safeguard in industrial projects within .
The dispute centered on the acquisition of approximately 273.57 acres of agricultural land in the villages of Kukuda, Bihabandha, and Lanjiberna. While Dalmia Cement already possessed a valid extended until 2040, the company required to expand its operations. Despite the local passing unanimous resolutions on , to reject the proposal, the state authorities proceeded with the acquisition process. The highlighted that this disregard for grassroots opposition undermined the democratic framework intended by the .
Procedural Lapses in Tribal
The apex court held that the acquisition for a private company fell under Section 2(2)(b) of the 2013 Act, which imposes stringent conditions, including the prior consent of at least 80% of the affected families. The state government had argued that since the acquisition was for a and the title would eventually vest in the government, the standard provisions for government-led acquisitions under Section 2(1) should apply. The categorically rejected this, emphasizing that the primary purpose was private industrial gain. The court observed that treating the consent requirement as a "continuing process" that could be satisfied at various stages was a fundamental error that rendered the statutory protections illusory.
Furthermore, because the land parcels fall within a Scheduled Area under the
, the provisions of Section 41(3) were triggered. This section mandates that prior consent of the Gram Sabha must be obtained in all cases of acquisition in such areas. The court found that the state had failed to procure even basic compliance with this requirement.
"Far from a meaningful consent, there is not even paper consent of Gram Sabha in this case,"
the bench noted, underscoring that the state’s failure to act in accordance with the law necessitated the immediate quashing of the proceedings.
Flaws in
The integrity of the acquisition process was further compromised by deficiencies in the (SIA) study. Although the statute requires a public hearing to be held in the affected areas, the noted that there was no substantive evidence to suggest that such a hearing ever occurred. Responses provided under the Right to Information Act indicated that public hearings were blocked by COVID-19 restrictions, yet the state attempted to rely on claims of "non-cooperation" by villagers to explain the lack of documentation.
The court also identified a significant regarding the composition of the Expert Group tasked with evaluating the SIA report. It emerged that the group included an individual who served as an advisor for to Dalmia Cement. The court held that the inclusion of such a person violated the mandate of Section 7(1), which requires an "independent multi-disciplinary Expert Group." By allowing a professional with a direct financial link to the company to sit on the appraisal board, the state had effectively turned the deliberation process into what the bench termed a "fixed match." The court concluded that such an arrangement inherently compromised the impartiality required to assess whether the project's social costs outweighed its benefits.
Implications for Industrial Mining
The ruling also addressed the respondents' contention that the , provided a self-contained code that could override the 2013 Act. The company had argued that its granted it a to enter the land upon paying compensation for damages, potentially bypassing the rigorous acquisition framework. The dismissed this interpretation, clarifying that the two legislations operate in entirely distinct spheres. While the mining law regulates mineral concessions, it does not extinguish the of landowners or grant a company the authority to avoid the safeguards designed for the protection of rural communities.
The court emphasized that once the respondents opted to invoke the 2013 Act to secure , they were bound by the entirety of its procedural safeguards. A contractual lease between the state and a private entity cannot be used as a shield to circumvent mandatory legal requirements intended to protect vulnerable populations in . The bench underscored that compensation for is fundamentally distinct from compensation for damages incurred during mining operations.
Following the quashing of all notifications and orders associated with the challenged acquisition, the has cleared the path for the state to initiate fresh proceedings, provided they strictly adhere to the legal mandates. This includes obtaining the required 80% consent from affected families, securing explicit approval from the relevant , and ensuring the independence of the Expert Group evaluating the project's social impact. The judgment marks a definitive judicial stance against the erosion of community rights in the name of industrial expansion, reinforcing that transparency and consent are not optional features of the process.
Gram Sabha consent - mining land acquisition