The Supreme Court of India has affirmed the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal’s power to remand non-compliant resolution plans back to the Committee of Creditors, delivering a landmark ruling that settles the operational parameters of the insolvency process. A bench comprising Justice Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha and Justice Alok Aradhe dismissed the appeals filed by Twinstar Technologies Limited, the successful resolution applicant for the Videocon Industries Limited group, reinforcing the principle that appellate bodies can rectify legal errors without encroaching upon the commercial domain of creditors.

The dispute centered on the corporate insolvency resolution process for thirteen Videocon group companies, where the Committee of Creditors had initially approved a resolution plan with a 95.09% voting share. However, the plan faced stiff resistance from dissenting financial creditors, including the Bank of Maharashtra, IFCI Limited, and the Small Industries Development Bank of India, who challenged the proposal on the grounds that it failed to meet the statutory requirements for fair treatment. The appellate tribunal subsequently set aside the plan’s approval, citing, among other failures, an improper payment structure for dissenting creditors that utilized non-convertible debentures instead of cash, and the lack of proper regulatory clearances.

In its authoritative pronouncement, the Supreme Court emphasized that while the appellate tribunal possesses the power of remand, this authority must be exercised with restraint to avoid indefinite delays in the resolution process. To provide clarity, the Court established five specific guidelines for the appellate tribunal to follow when deciding to return a plan for reconsideration. These guardrails mandate that any remand must be strictly in furtherance of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code's primary objectives: keeping the corporate debtor a going concern, ensuring fair recovery for all creditor classes, and maximizing asset value.

“The power of remand, therefore, operates as the connecting link between the three actors: it permits the appellate authority to check the legality without trespassing on the commerciality, which is the sole domain of the CoC,” the Court observed in its judgment. By affirming this role, the bench effectively balanced the need for legal oversight with the legislative intent of insulating commercial decisions from judicial interference.

Judicial Limits on Plan Modification

The Court’s decision also addressed the contentious intervention of the National Company Law Tribunal, which had previously attempted to cure defects in the Twinstar plan by directing an upfront cash payment to dissenting financial creditors. The Supreme Court invalidated this approach, ruling that the adjudicating authority exceeded its jurisdiction. The bench clarified that since the commercial terms of a plan are the prerogative of the Committee of Creditors, neither the tribunal nor the appellate court can unilaterally modify the payment structure.

The judgment underscored that such modifications are impermissible because they alter the negotiated distribution scheme, which is integral to the commercial wisdom exercised by lenders. Instead, the Court held that the only legally sound path when a plan is found deficient is to remit the entire matter back to the Committee of Creditors. This process allows the resolution applicant to introduce necessary modifications and provides the lenders with an opportunity to re-vote on a compliant version of the proposal. The Court noted that this approach is further supported by recent legislative amendments to the Code, which explicitly authorize the adjudicating authority to provide notice to the committee for rectifying defects before proceeding to rejection.

The Status of Foreign Oil and Gas Assets

A significant secondary issue resolved by the Court involved the foreign oil and gas assets of the Videocon group, which the erstwhile promoter, Venugopal Dhoot, had argued should be included in the consolidated insolvency process of the holding company. The Supreme Court rejected this contention, reaffirming the legal principle that a holding company and its subsidiary constitute distinct legal entities. Relying on the statutory exclusion provided in the Explanation to Section 18 of the Code, the Court held that assets owned by foreign subsidiaries are categorically excluded from the insolvency estate of the parent entity.

The bench also noted the conduct of the promoter, observing that he was estopped from claiming the inclusion of these assets after having previously requested that they be kept out of the insolvency proceedings. The Court found no evidence of fraud or collusion in the way these assets were handled, and it upheld the transaction approved by the Committee of Creditors of the subsidiary company, VOVL Limited, involving a third-party right of first refusal.

Continuing Role of the Creditors

The judgment further debunked the argument that the Committee of Creditors becomes functus officio —or having no further authority—upon the initial approval of a resolution plan. The Supreme Court ruled that the committee remains a functional body throughout the entire insolvency resolution process and maintains its duty of care until a plan is fully implemented or an order of liquidation is passed.

By clarifying that the committee’s authority persists throughout the life of the resolution process, the Court has provided a necessary framework for navigating post-approval complications. The order concludes by mandating that the Committee of Creditors now move forward with the resolution process in strict accordance with the legal standards clarified by the bench. For the parties involved, this means the insolvency process for the Videocon group must be recommenced or revisited without the previous structural defects, ensuring that the final outcome adheres to both the commercial will of the lenders and the stringent mandates of the insolvency framework. As the matter reverts to the lenders, the Court’s guidelines serve as a comprehensive checklist for the appellate tribunal to ensure that the ongoing resolution effort remains timely, transparent, and legally sound.